Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Chapter 13 Plan Modifications in Maryland: Job Loss, Increased Expenses, Changes in Income, and When Payments Can Be Reduced

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

A Confirmed Chapter 13 Plan Is Binding, but It Is Not Necessarily Unchangeable

A Chapter 13 repayment plan ordinarily lasts three to five years. During that period, a debtor may lose employment, experience a serious illness, retire, become responsible for additional household expenses, or encounter other financial changes that make the original payment difficult or impossible.

Financial circumstances may also improve. A debtor may receive a substantial salary increase, inheritance, settlement, or other unexpected funds.

Congress recognized that a repayment plan lasting several years may need to be adjusted.

Under 11 U.S.C. § 1329, a confirmed Chapter 13 plan may be modified in specified circumstances before completion of plan payments.

But modification is not automatic. The debtor must obtain appropriate approval, and the modified plan must satisfy applicable statutory requirements.

The availability of modification also does not mean that every debtor can reduce payments merely because the original plan has become inconvenient.

The central questions are whether the proposed modification is legally permissible, whether it remains feasible, and whether the debtor can still satisfy the obligations required for discharge.

1. What Is a Postconfirmation Modification?

A postconfirmation modification changes the terms of a Chapter 13 plan after the bankruptcy court has confirmed it.

Section 1329 authorizes specified modifications before completion of payments.

A modification may increase or reduce payments to a particular class, extend or reduce the payment period within statutory limits, or address other matters permitted by the statute.

The debtor must follow the applicable procedural requirements.

A private agreement between the debtor and a creditor does not necessarily modify the confirmed plan.

2. Who Can Request Modification?

Under § 1329(a), a modification may be requested by the debtor, trustee, or holder of an allowed unsecured claim.

The statute does not grant every secured creditor an unrestricted independent right to seek modification under § 1329(a).

However, secured creditors may possess other rights and remedies under the Bankruptcy Code.

The identity of the party requesting modification can matter.

3. Is a Substantial Change in Circumstances Required?

Section 1329 does not expressly state that every modification requires proof of a substantial change in financial circumstances.

Courts have considered the effect of confirmation, res judicata, and changed circumstances.

The Fourth Circuit addressed postconfirmation modification in In re Arnold, 869 F.2d 240 (4th Cir. 1989).

The decision recognizes the significance of substantial and unanticipated changes in the circumstances considered at confirmation.

In the Fourth Circuit, Arnold and Murphy v. O’Donnell (In re Murphy), 474 F.3d 143 (4th Cir. 2007), require a substantial and unanticipated change in financial circumstances before res judicata will yield to a payment-changing modification of the kind addressed in those cases. If that threshold is met, the court still applies § 1329 and the incorporated confirmation requirements. The statutory text should not be used to suggest that Maryland debtors can disregard that controlling framework. Trantham v. Tate, No. 22-2263 (4th Cir. Aug. 13, 2024), reiterates Murphy’s modification principle even where property vested in the debtor at confirmation.

A debtor should not assume that any desired change will automatically be approved.

4. Job Loss

Loss of employment is a common reason for seeking modification.

A debtor may have been earning $6,000 per month when the plan was confirmed but later become unemployed.

The debtor may no longer be able to make the required payment.

The debtor should promptly notify counsel and provide documentation concerning the job loss, unemployment benefits, severance, and prospects for replacement income.

Possible responses may include temporary relief, a reduced payment, modification, conversion, or dismissal.

The appropriate remedy depends on the circumstances.

5. Reduction in Income

A debtor may remain employed but experience reduced hours, lower commissions, or decreased self-employment income.

The change may affect plan feasibility.

The debtor should provide current pay statements or business records.

A modification may be appropriate when the reduction is sufficiently supported and the modified plan satisfies statutory requirements.

The debtor should not simply stop making payments without seeking advice.

6. Increased Medical Expenses

A serious illness or injury may increase household expenses.

The debtor may face recurring prescription costs, treatment expenses, transportation costs, or other necessary expenditures.

These expenses may reduce funds available for plan payments.

The debtor should document the costs and determine whether insurance or other benefits will cover them.

A proposed modification should reflect reasonable anticipated expenses.

7. Retirement

A debtor may retire during the Chapter 13 plan.

The resulting change in income may affect payment capacity.

However, retirement does not automatically justify reducing payments.

The court may consider the debtor's circumstances, reasons for retirement, financial resources, and ability to continue funding the plan.

A debtor approaching retirement should consider the anticipated change before proposing the original plan whenever possible.

8. Disability and Loss of Earning Capacity

A debtor who becomes unable to work may have grounds to seek modification.

The debtor may receive disability benefits or other replacement income.

The nature and amount of those benefits matter.

Social Security benefits receive special treatment under the Bankruptcy Code.

The debtor should distinguish statutory disposable-income calculations from actual cash flow and plan feasibility.

9. Increased Household Expenses

A debtor may experience higher rent, insurance premiums, transportation costs, or other necessary expenses.

Not every ordinary increase justifies modification.

The debtor should demonstrate the actual change and its effect on the budget.

A proposed modification must still satisfy applicable statutory requirements.

The debtor should not assume that all discretionary spending increases can be shifted to unsecured creditors.

10. Changes in Household Composition

A debtor may marry, divorce, have a child, or become responsible for another household member.

These changes can affect income and expenses.

The debtor may need to provide updated household information.

The legal treatment depends on the particular change and applicable provisions.

A modification should reflect the debtor's actual financial circumstances.

11. Increased Income

Modification is not limited to debtors experiencing financial hardship.

A trustee or qualifying creditor may seek increased payments when the debtor's income rises substantially.

For example, a debtor may receive a significant promotion or begin earning substantial additional commissions.

The effect depends on the confirmed plan, applicable law, and circumstances.

The debtor should not assume that all postconfirmation income increases may be retained without regard to creditor rights.

12. Bonuses and Overtime

A debtor may receive irregular bonuses or overtime.

The treatment depends on the plan and applicable law.

Some plans contain provisions requiring turnover of specified additional income.

Other circumstances may prompt a modification request.

The debtor should review the confirmed plan and disclose material changes as required.

A bonus is not automatically exempt from every plan obligation merely because it was unexpected.

13. Inheritances

An inheritance received during Chapter 13 can create substantial issues.

Under § 1306, the Chapter 13 estate generally includes specified property acquired after filing and before the case is closed, dismissed, or converted.

In Carroll v. Logan, 735 F.3d 147 (4th Cir. 2013), the Fourth Circuit held that an inheritance received more than 180 days after filing became property of the Chapter 13 estate.

The trustee may seek modification or other appropriate relief.

The debtor should promptly disclose the inheritance.

14. Personal Injury Settlements

A debtor may receive a personal injury settlement during the plan.

The claim may constitute estate property depending on when it arose and applicable law.

Maryland exemptions may protect qualifying personal injury compensation.

However, the debtor should not assume that settlement proceeds may be spent without disclosure or approval.

The trustee may examine the claim, exemptions, and effect on the plan.

The debtor should coordinate bankruptcy and personal injury counsel.

15. Tax Refunds

Tax refunds may affect Chapter 13 plan obligations.

Some confirmed plans require turnover of refunds or specified portions.

The treatment depends on the plan, applicable law, and the nature of the refund.

A debtor should not assume that a refund received during Chapter 13 is automatically available for unrestricted spending.

The debtor should review the plan before using the funds.

16. Reducing Payments to Unsecured Creditors

A debtor may seek to reduce distributions to general unsecured creditors when financial circumstances deteriorate.

However, the modified plan must satisfy applicable statutory requirements.

The liquidation test and other confirmation provisions may limit the reduction.

For example, a debtor whose original plan was required to pay substantial nonexempt liquidation value may not be able to eliminate that requirement merely because income has fallen.

The modified plan must be evaluated as a whole.

17. Priority Claims

Priority claims receive special treatment.

A modification generally cannot disregard mandatory statutory treatment of qualifying priority debts.

For example, certain tax obligations and domestic support arrears may require payment according to applicable provisions.

A debtor seeking reduced payments must determine whether the remaining plan term can accommodate those obligations.

18. Secured Claims

Modification of secured claim treatment may present additional issues.

The creditor's lien rights, prior payments, collateral, and confirmed plan terms must be examined.

Section 1329 contains provisions concerning certain secured claim modifications.

The debtor should not assume that surrendering collateral or changing payment terms automatically eliminates every secured creditor deficiency.

The applicable statute and case law control.

19. Surrendering a Vehicle During the Plan

A debtor may no longer be able to afford a vehicle.

The debtor may wish to surrender it and reduce plan payments.

The consequences depend on the confirmed plan, loan documents, collateral value, and applicable law.

The creditor may assert a deficiency claim.

The ability to reclassify or modify treatment after confirmation has generated litigation.

The debtor should seek appropriate relief rather than simply surrendering the vehicle and reducing payments unilaterally.

20. Extending the Plan

Section 1329(c) limits the duration of a modified plan.

A modified plan generally may not extend payments beyond five years after the first payment was due under the original confirmed plan.

The debtor cannot ordinarily obtain an unlimited extension merely because payments were missed.

The remaining statutory period may therefore limit available modification options.

21. Shortening the Plan

A debtor may seek to complete the plan earlier.

However, the applicable commitment period and projected disposable-income requirements may affect early completion.

The debtor should not assume that paying the originally projected dollar amount early automatically entitles the debtor to discharge.

The plan and statutory requirements must be examined.

22. Paying the Plan in Full Early

A debtor may receive funds sufficient to pay remaining obligations.

The effect depends on whether the plan provides for full payment of allowed claims or only a percentage distribution.

A lump-sum payment may not necessarily satisfy all applicable requirements when unsecured creditors are not being paid in full.

The debtor should obtain approval of any required modification or payoff arrangement.

23. The Procedure for Modification

Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 3015(h) governs modification of a Chapter 13 plan after confirmation.

The proposed modification generally must be filed and served according to applicable requirements.

Parties receive an opportunity to object.

The bankruptcy court determines whether the modification satisfies the statute.

Maryland local rules and forms may impose additional procedures.

Maryland Local Bankruptcy Rule 3015-5 requires a motion accompanied by the proposed modified plan. The movant selects a hearing through the court’s scheduler more than 33 but fewer than 60 days after service, and serves the required parties with a notice conforming to Form M-2. The scheduler supplies the objection date for the notice. The motion must also comply with Rule 3012-1 where valuation or lien relief is sought.

The debtor should not assume that an informal request to the trustee changes the plan.

24. Objections to Modification

The trustee or creditors may object to a proposed modification.

Issues may include feasibility, good faith, liquidation value, secured claim treatment, and compliance with statutory limits.

The debtor may need to provide updated income and expense documentation.

A contested modification may require a hearing.

The court must determine whether the modified plan satisfies applicable requirements.

25. What If Modification Is Impossible?

A debtor may be unable to fund any feasible modified plan.

For example, the debtor may have permanently lost income while substantial priority or secured obligations remain unpaid.

The debtor may need to consider conversion to Chapter 7, dismissal, or a hardship discharge when statutory requirements are satisfied.

The appropriate option depends on assets, debts, and eligibility.

Continuing an impossible plan may simply delay the inevitable.

26. Conversion to Chapter 7

Section 1307 generally permits a Chapter 13 debtor to convert to Chapter 7, subject to applicable law.

Conversion may eliminate the obligation to continue plan payments.

However, Chapter 7 may expose nonexempt property to liquidation.

The debtor should determine what property would enter the converted estate and what exemptions apply.

The Supreme Court's decision in Harris v. Viegelahn, 575 U.S. 510 (2015), addresses undistributed Chapter 13 funds following conversion.

27. Dismissal

Dismissal generally terminates the Chapter 13 case without providing the ordinary discharge.

Creditors may resume lawful collection.

The debtor may lose protection against foreclosure, repossession, and garnishment.

Payments made during the case may have reduced some obligations, but unpaid balances may remain.

The debtor should understand the consequences before voluntarily dismissing.

28. Hardship Discharge

Section 1328(b) permits a hardship discharge in limited circumstances.

The debtor generally must establish that failure to complete payments is due to circumstances for which the debtor should not justly be held accountable.

The value distributed to unsecured creditors must satisfy the statutory liquidation requirement.

Modification under § 1329 must be impracticable.

The hardship discharge is narrower than the ordinary Chapter 13 discharge.

It does not necessarily eliminate the same debts.

29. Why Prompt Action Matters

A debtor who cannot make payments should contact counsel promptly.

Missed payments may accumulate.

The trustee may file a motion to dismiss.

The debtor may have fewer options as the five-year limit approaches.

Early review may permit modification or another appropriate solution.

The debtor should not wait until several months of payments have been missed before seeking assistance.

Conclusion

A confirmed Chapter 13 plan may be modified when the statutory requirements are satisfied.

Changes in employment, income, medical expenses, household circumstances, and other financial events may justify reconsideration of plan terms.

Trustees and qualifying creditors may also seek increased payments when circumstances improve.

But modification is not automatic and does not eliminate mandatory treatment of secured or priority obligations.

The five-year limit and feasibility requirement can restrict available relief.

A debtor who experiences a material financial change during Chapter 13 should seek review promptly rather than simply stopping payments or assuming the original plan cannot be changed.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes and rules

  • 11 U.S.C. § 1329 — Postconfirmation modification.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1325 — Confirmation requirements.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1306 — Chapter 13 estate property.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1307 — Conversion and dismissal.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1328(b) — Hardship discharge.
  • Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 3015(h) — Postconfirmation modification procedures.

Selected decisions

  • In re Arnold, 869 F.2d 240 (4th Cir. 1989) — Addresses modification and substantial changes in circumstances.
  • Carroll v. Logan, 735 F.3d 147 (4th Cir. 2013) — Addresses postpetition inheritances in Chapter 13.
  • Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010) — Addresses projected disposable income.
  • Harris v. Viegelahn, 575 U.S. 510 (2015) — Addresses undistributed plan funds following conversion.
  • In re Murphy, 474 F.3d 143 (4th Cir. 2007) — Addresses postconfirmation modification and changed circumstances.

Maryland practice authorities

– United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Maryland — Local Rules and Chapter 13 procedures.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm