How Much Will You Have to Pay Each Month in Chapter 13?
One of the first questions a prospective Chapter 13 debtor asks is how much the monthly payment will be.
The answer is not simply the amount remaining after subtracting household expenses from take-home pay.
Chapter 13 payments are determined through several interacting requirements of the Bankruptcy Code. These include projected disposable income, the value of nonexempt property, the treatment of secured debts, priority claims, and the administrative costs of the plan.
A debtor may have relatively little disposable income but still be required to make substantial payments because of mortgage arrears, priority taxes, or valuable nonexempt property.
Conversely, a debtor with substantial unsecured debt may be able to confirm a plan that pays general unsecured creditors only a small percentage of their claims.
The purpose of the calculation is to determine the payment required by law and whether the debtor can realistically afford it.
A successful Chapter 13 plan must satisfy both requirements.
1. There Is No Universal Chapter 13 Payment Percentage
Chapter 13 does not require every debtor to repay a fixed percentage of unsecured debt.
A debtor may propose a plan paying 100% of qualifying unsecured claims.
Another debtor may propose a plan paying substantially less.
In some circumstances, general unsecured creditors may receive no distribution.
The result depends on the debtor's financial circumstances and the applicable confirmation requirements.
The percentage paid is ordinarily a consequence of the required plan funding rather than an independently selected target.
2. The Four Principal Components of a Plan Payment
A practical Chapter 13 calculation generally requires consideration of four matters:
The amount needed to pay secured obligations treated through the plan.
The amount needed to pay priority claims.
The amount required for general unsecured creditors under the disposable-income and liquidation tests.
Trustee compensation and other allowable administrative expenses.
These components interact.
They should not automatically be added together without considering how particular payments satisfy multiple statutory requirements.
For example, payments toward qualifying secured debts may affect the calculation of disposable income.
The plan must be modeled as a whole.
3. Schedule I and Schedule J
Schedule I reports the debtor's current income.
Schedule J reports current household expenses.
Together, they provide a picture of the debtor's actual monthly cash flow.
For example, a debtor may report $6,500 in monthly take-home income and $5,700 in ordinary expenses.
The apparent monthly surplus is $800.
But that figure does not necessarily establish the legally required Chapter 13 payment.
The means test, secured obligations, priority claims, and liquidation value may produce a different result.
4. Current Monthly Income
Section 101(10A) defines current monthly income.
The calculation generally uses income received during the six full calendar months preceding the bankruptcy filing, subject to statutory requirements.
The resulting monthly average may differ from the debtor's current earnings.
For example, a debtor may have earned substantial overtime during the lookback period but no longer receive overtime.
The means-test calculation may initially reflect the higher historical income.
The debtor's current circumstances may require separate consideration under applicable law.
5. Household Size
Household size affects the applicable median-income threshold and certain expense allowances.
The Fourth Circuit addressed household size in Johnson v. Zimmer, 686 F.3d 224 (4th Cir. 2012).
The court adopted an economic-unit approach that considers the financial relationship among household members.
A debtor may live with adult children, parents, or other relatives.
The appropriate household size depends on the circumstances rather than simply counting everyone residing at the address.
Household contributions and shared expenses may also matter.
6. Above-Median and Below-Median Debtors
The debtor's current monthly income is compared with the applicable median income for a household of the relevant size.
The median figures are periodically updated.
A below-median debtor generally has a three-year applicable commitment period, subject to statutory qualifications.
An above-median debtor generally has a five-year period.
The classification also affects how certain reasonably necessary expenses are determined.
The debtor should use the median-income figures applicable to the filing date.
7. Below-Median Debtors
For below-median debtors, actual reasonably necessary expenses generally play a significant role in determining disposable income.
The debtor must provide a realistic budget.
Expenses should reflect the debtor's household circumstances and statutory requirements.
The court may scrutinize expenses that appear excessive or unsupported.
A below-median debtor should not assume that every claimed expense will automatically be accepted.
8. Above-Median Debtors
For above-median debtors, § 1325(b)(3) generally incorporates expense calculations under § 707(b)(2).
These provisions use specified standards and deductions.
Some expenses are based on IRS standards.
Others may depend on actual qualifying costs.
The resulting calculation may differ substantially from Schedule J.
A debtor should not assume that every actual expense is deductible in the amount paid.
9. IRS National and Local Standards
The means test incorporates specified expense standards concerning categories such as food, clothing, housing, utilities, and transportation.
The applicable amounts depend on the statutory rules, household size, and location.
Some deductions are standardized.
Others involve actual expenses or additional statutory conditions.
The debtor should use the figures effective for the relevant filing period.
10. Housing Expenses
Housing deductions may include applicable allowances for mortgage or rent expenses and utilities.
The treatment depends on the debtor's circumstances and the means-test provisions.
A debtor who owns a home with substantial mortgage payments may receive different deductions from a renter.
However, the debtor should not assume that every mortgage payment automatically reduces the required payment dollar for dollar.
The interaction between secured debt deductions and plan treatment must be examined.
11. Automobile Ownership and Operating Expenses
The means test distinguishes certain vehicle ownership and operating expenses.
In Ransom v. FIA Card Services, N.A., 562 U.S. 61 (2011), the Supreme Court held that a debtor who did not have a loan or lease payment could not claim the vehicle ownership deduction under the statutory framework considered.
The decision illustrates that standardized deductions are subject to eligibility requirements.
A debtor who owns a vehicle free and clear may receive different treatment from one making loan payments.
The debtor should also distinguish vehicle operating costs from ownership costs.
12. Medical Expenses
Qualifying medical expenses may affect the means test and actual household budget.
A debtor may have substantial prescription costs, insurance premiums, ongoing treatment expenses, or other health-related obligations.
The statutory deductions and applicable documentation requirements must be examined.
The debtor should not assume that every medical bill qualifies as a current monthly expense.
Past unsecured medical debt is different from ongoing necessary medical spending.
13. Taxes and Payroll Deductions
Income taxes, Social Security taxes, Medicare taxes, and other qualifying payroll deductions may affect the debtor's available income.
The means test provides for specified deductions.
The debtor should distinguish mandatory deductions from voluntary expenditures.
For example, voluntary retirement contributions may present different issues from required payroll taxes.
The legal treatment depends on the statutory provisions and applicable precedent.
14. Retirement Contributions
Retirement contributions can create complicated Chapter 13 questions.
Section 541(b)(7) addresses certain amounts withheld or contributed to qualifying retirement plans.
Courts have considered how these provisions interact with projected disposable income.
The treatment of ongoing voluntary contributions may depend on the circumstances and controlling law.
A debtor should not assume that every proposed contribution automatically reduces the amount payable to unsecured creditors.
15. Retirement Plan Loans
Qualifying retirement plan loan repayments receive special treatment under § 1322(f).
The statute provides that specified amounts required to repay qualifying retirement plan loans do not constitute disposable income under § 1325.
The debtor should identify the plan, loan terms, repayment schedule, and statutory qualification.
The treatment differs from an ordinary unsecured personal loan.
16. Social Security Income
Section 101(10A) excludes benefits received under the Social Security Act from current monthly income.
The Fourth Circuit addressed this issue in Mort Ranta v. Gorman, 721 F.3d 241 (4th Cir. 2013).
The exclusion can materially affect projected disposable income.
However, Social Security benefits generally must still be disclosed on the appropriate bankruptcy schedules.
The debtor should distinguish statutory current monthly income from actual household cash flow.
17. Projected Disposable Income
Section 1325(b)(1)(B) generally requires commitment of projected disposable income during the applicable commitment period when the trustee or an unsecured creditor objects to confirmation and the plan does not pay unsecured claims in full.
The Supreme Court addressed the calculation in Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010).
The Court approved a forward-looking approach permitting consideration of changes in income or expenses that are known or virtually certain at confirmation.
This is important when the historical six-month average does not accurately reflect the debtor's expected financial circumstances.
18. The Liquidation Test
Section 1325(a)(4) generally requires unsecured creditors to receive at least as much under the Chapter 13 plan as they would receive in a hypothetical Chapter 7 liquidation.
This is often called the best-interests-of-creditors test.
The calculation generally examines nonexempt property value, liens, hypothetical liquidation costs, and other relevant factors.
A debtor with valuable nonexempt assets may need to pay substantial amounts to unsecured creditors even when disposable income is limited.
19. Example: Nonexempt Home Equity
Assume a debtor owns a residence with $80,000 in nonexempt equity after accounting for valid liens and available exemptions.
The hypothetical Chapter 7 liquidation analysis may require adjustments for costs of sale, trustee compensation, and other applicable expenses.
Suppose the resulting amount available for general unsecured creditors is $60,000.
The Chapter 13 plan generally must provide at least that required liquidation value to unsecured creditors.
Over sixty months, $60,000 represents an average of $1,000 per month before considering other plan costs and timing.
The debtor's ability to retain the home depends on funding a feasible plan.
20. Priority Taxes
Certain tax obligations receive priority under § 507(a)(8).
Chapter 13 generally requires specified treatment of priority claims under § 1322(a)(2).
For example, a debtor may owe $24,000 in qualifying priority income taxes.
The plan may need to provide for payment of that amount, subject to the applicable statutory provisions and creditor agreement.
The debtor should identify priority and nonpriority taxes separately.
A tax claim's age and classification can materially affect the required payment.
21. Domestic Support Obligations
Qualifying domestic support obligations receive priority treatment.
Chapter 13 imposes requirements concerning payment of domestic support obligations and compliance with ongoing obligations.
The debtor should identify arrears and current support.
Failure to remain current on qualifying postpetition support obligations can create confirmation and discharge problems.
The plan must account for applicable statutory requirements.
22. Mortgage Arrears
Chapter 13 may permit curing qualifying mortgage arrears while maintaining ongoing payments.
The arrears may be paid through the trustee.
For example, $30,000 in arrears over sixty months represents $500 per month before trustee compensation and other applicable costs.
The debtor must also afford ongoing mortgage payments.
A plan that cures arrears but leaves insufficient money for current housing expenses is not feasible.
23. Vehicle Loans
A Chapter 13 plan may provide for payment of secured vehicle claims.
The treatment depends on the loan, collateral value, acquisition date, and applicable statutory provisions.
Some claims may be modified.
Others may be subject to the 910-day restriction.
The plan must provide the treatment required by § 1325(a)(5).
24. Trustee Compensation
Chapter 13 trustees receive compensation under applicable federal law.
The percentage charged can vary.
The debtor should use the applicable trustee percentage when modeling plan funding.
For example, a plan requiring $50,000 in creditor distributions may need additional funding to cover trustee compensation.
The trustee's percentage should not be guessed.
The actual rate and treatment of payments must be confirmed under applicable procedures.
25. Attorney's Fees
Chapter 13 attorney's fees may be paid partly before filing and partly through the plan, subject to applicable court procedures and approval requirements.
Fees paid through the plan affect required funding.
The debtor should understand the fee arrangement.
The attorney should distinguish fees already paid from amounts remaining to be paid through the trustee.
26. Example: Calculating a Plan Payment
Assume a debtor proposes a sixty-month plan with the following required distributions:
Plan component
Amount
Mortgage arrears
$30,000
Priority taxes
$18,000
Vehicle secured claim
$15,000
Required unsecured distribution
$12,000
Attorney's fees through plan
$5,000
Total before trustee compensation
$80,000
The average monthly funding requirement before trustee compensation is:
$80,000 ÷ 60 = $1,333.33.
The actual payment must also account for trustee compensation, applicable interest on secured claims, distribution timing, and other plan requirements.
This example illustrates the arithmetic, not a universally applicable payment formula.
27. Disposable Income May Require a Higher Payment
A debtor may calculate the minimum required distributions and discover that projected disposable income requires greater payments to unsecured creditors.
For example, a plan may satisfy the liquidation test with $12,000 for unsecured creditors.
But the debtor may have projected disposable income requiring $30,000 in distributions over the applicable commitment period.
The plan generally must satisfy the applicable disposable-income requirement.
The debtor cannot simply select the lower figure.
28. Liquidation Value May Require a Higher Payment
The reverse can also occur.
A debtor may have limited projected disposable income but substantial nonexempt property.
The liquidation test may require greater distributions than the disposable-income calculation alone would produce.
For example, a debtor may have only $400 in monthly projected disposable income but possess $50,000 in nonexempt equity.
The debtor may need to fund the required liquidation value to retain the property.
The plan must satisfy both applicable tests.
29. The Feasibility Requirement
Section 1325(a)(6) requires a finding that the debtor will be able to make all payments under the plan and comply with it.
A mathematically sufficient plan is not necessarily feasible.
The debtor must have enough income to fund the proposed payments while meeting reasonable living expenses.
A plan based on speculative overtime, uncertain business profits, or unrealistic expense reductions may fail.
The debtor should account for foreseeable irregular expenses.
30. Why Plan Payments May Change
A confirmed Chapter 13 plan may be modified under § 1329 in specified circumstances.
Changes in income, expenses, secured claims, or other relevant conditions may affect the payment.
For example, a debtor may lose employment or experience a substantial reduction in income.
Alternatively, income may increase.
The debtor should promptly report material changes and seek appropriate relief when necessary.
31. The Difference Between Minimum Funding and Affordable Funding
The minimum amount required by the Bankruptcy Code may exceed what the debtor can realistically afford.
That creates a feasibility problem.
A debtor may need to consider surrendering collateral, reducing expenses, increasing reliable income, or selecting another bankruptcy chapter.
The law does not guarantee that every debtor can retain every asset through Chapter 13.
A successful plan must be both legally sufficient and financially sustainable.
Conclusion
Calculating a Chapter 13 payment requires more than subtracting expenses from income.
The plan must satisfy applicable projected disposable-income requirements, the liquidation test, secured claim treatment, priority debt requirements, and administrative expenses.
The means test may differ substantially from the debtor's actual budget.
A debtor with substantial nonexempt assets may need to make significant payments even when disposable income is limited.
Conversely, a debtor with little nonexempt property and limited disposable income may pay only a small portion of ordinary unsecured debt.
The correct Chapter 13 payment is the amount required to satisfy the Bankruptcy Code through a plan the debtor can realistically complete—not simply the lowest payment that can be proposed.
Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010) — Addresses projected disposable income and known or virtually certain changes.
Ransom v. FIA Card Services, N.A., 562 U.S. 61 (2011) — Addresses vehicle ownership expense deductions.
Mort Ranta v. Gorman, 721 F.3d 241 (4th Cir. 2013) — Addresses Social Security income exclusion.
Johnson v. Zimmer, 686 F.3d 224 (4th Cir. 2012) — Addresses household size.
Till v. SCS Credit Corp., 541 U.S. 465 (2004) — Addresses present-value interest for secured claims.
In re Quigley, 673 F.3d 269 (4th Cir. 2012) — Addresses projected disposable income and expenses associated with surrendered collateral.
Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions
Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.