Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Chapter 13 and Tax Refunds, Inheritances, Bonuses, and Personal Injury Settlements: Who Gets the Money During the Plan?

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Chapter 13 Bankruptcy and Postpetition Property

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Receiving Money During Chapter 13 Does Not Necessarily Mean You Can Keep or Spend It

A Chapter 13 repayment plan generally lasts three to five years. During that period, a debtor's financial circumstances may change substantially.

The debtor may receive an inheritance, a tax refund, a substantial employment bonus, proceeds from a personal injury settlement, or money from the sale of property.

These events raise an important question: Who is entitled to the money?

Unlike Chapter 7, Chapter 13 generally includes certain property and earnings acquired after the bankruptcy petition within the bankruptcy estate.

However, the fact that property becomes part of the estate does not automatically mean that the Chapter 13 trustee is entitled to take all of it.

Exemptions, the confirmed plan, disposable-income requirements, and the Bankruptcy Code's modification provisions may affect the result.

A debtor should not assume that every unexpected payment belongs to the trustee.

Nor should the debtor assume that money received after filing is available for unrestricted personal use.

1. Chapter 13 Estate Property

Section 541 generally defines property of the bankruptcy estate.

Section 1306 expands the Chapter 13 estate to include specified property acquired after filing and earnings from services performed after commencement of the case.

The statutory period generally extends until the case is closed, dismissed, or converted.

The scope of estate property can therefore be broader than in an ordinary Chapter 7 case.

The debtor should disclose material acquisitions and changes as required by law and applicable court procedures.

2. The Effect of Confirmation

Section 1327(b) generally provides that confirmation vests property of the estate in the debtor unless the plan or confirmation order provides otherwise.

Section 1306, however, addresses property acquired during the Chapter 13 case.

Courts have developed different approaches to reconciling these provisions.

The confirmed plan and applicable Fourth Circuit precedent are important.

The debtor should not assume that confirmation automatically removes every later-acquired asset from bankruptcy administration.

Trantham v. Tate, No. 22-2263 (4th Cir. Aug. 13, 2024), holds that a local form’s default vesting provision cannot categorically prevent a debtor from proposing a Code-compliant alternative that vests property at confirmation. Whether property remains in the estate affects the need for approval of its use or sale. The decision also preserves Murphy’s rule allowing a qualifying modification based on a substantial and unanticipated change; vesting does not eliminate every later payment issue.

3. Tax Refunds

A debtor may receive federal or Maryland income tax refunds during the plan.

The treatment depends on the confirmed plan, applicable law, and the source of the refund.

Some plans require turnover of tax refunds or specified portions.

Other circumstances may permit the debtor to retain funds.

The debtor should review the confirmed plan before spending a substantial refund.

The fact that the refund was received after filing does not automatically establish that it is unrestricted.

4. Why Tax Refunds Can Be Significant

A tax refund generally represents an overpayment of tax.

The debtor may have received less take-home income during the year because of withholding.

The trustee may argue that substantial recurring refunds indicate that more income is available for plan payments.

However, the treatment depends on the plan and applicable law.

The debtor should distinguish recurring excess withholding from an unusual one-time refund.

5. Adjusting Tax Withholding

A debtor who consistently receives large refunds may consider adjusting withholding to more closely approximate actual tax liability.

However, the debtor should not change withholding merely to avoid plan obligations.

The change may affect monthly disposable income and plan funding.

The debtor should consult counsel and a tax professional when appropriate.

The objective is accurate tax payment and compliance with the confirmed plan.

6. Employment Bonuses

A debtor may receive an annual bonus, commission, profit-sharing payment, or other additional compensation.

The treatment depends on the plan and applicable law.

A recurring bonus may have been anticipated in the original income calculation.

An unexpected substantial bonus may prompt review of disposable income or modification.

The debtor should disclose material income changes as required.

7. Overtime Earnings

A debtor may begin working substantial overtime during the plan.

The additional income may affect the debtor's financial circumstances.

However, not every temporary increase necessarily requires modification.

The trustee may examine whether the increase is substantial, continuing, or otherwise relevant under applicable law.

The debtor should preserve pay statements and provide accurate information when requested.

8. Salary Increases

A debtor may receive a promotion or substantial raise.

The trustee or a qualifying unsecured creditor may seek modification under § 1329.

The Fourth Circuit has addressed postconfirmation modification when financial circumstances materially improve.

The debtor should not assume that all increased earnings may be retained without regard to the plan.

However, the applicable legal standard and confirmed plan terms must be examined.

9. Inheritances

An inheritance received during Chapter 13 can present substantial issues.

In Carroll v. Logan, 735 F.3d 147 (4th Cir. 2013), the Fourth Circuit held that an inheritance received more than 180 days after filing became property of the Chapter 13 estate.

The decision is particularly important in Maryland.

A debtor should not assume that an inheritance received more than six months after filing is automatically excluded.

The timing, nature, and value of the inheritance matter.

10. The 180-Day Rule

Section 541(a)(5) generally includes certain inheritances and other specified interests acquired within 180 days after filing.

However, § 1306 expands Chapter 13 estate property.

The Fourth Circuit's decision in Carroll illustrates that the 180-day limitation does not necessarily exclude later inheritances from the Chapter 13 estate.

The debtor should distinguish Chapter 7 treatment from Chapter 13 treatment.

11. What If the Inheritance Is Exempt?

An inheritance may include cash, real estate, retirement interests, or other property.

The debtor may possess applicable exemption rights.

However, the availability and amount of exemptions depend on the property and governing law.

The debtor should not assume that every inherited asset is exempt.

Nor should the debtor assume that estate property must automatically be surrendered without considering exemptions and plan requirements.

12. Inherited Real Estate

A debtor may inherit an interest in a residence or other real property during Chapter 13.

The interest may become estate property.

The debtor should determine ownership, liens, value, and available exemptions.

A proposed sale or transfer may require compliance with bankruptcy procedures.

The debtor should not convey the property without evaluating the bankruptcy consequences.

13. Personal Injury Claims

A debtor may be injured in an automobile accident or other incident during Chapter 13.

The resulting cause of action may constitute property of the bankruptcy estate.

The debtor should disclose the claim.

The bankruptcy court may need to approve employment of counsel, settlement, or other matters under applicable law and procedures.

The debtor should not assume that a claim arising after filing is outside the bankruptcy case.

14. Maryland Personal Injury Exemptions

Maryland provides substantial exemption protection for qualifying personal injury compensation under Courts and Judicial Proceedings § 11-504(b)(2).

The exemption may protect compensation for personal injury, subject to statutory language and applicable law.

The Fourth Circuit addressed Maryland's personal injury exemption in In re Butcher, 125 F.3d 238 (4th Cir. 1997).

The exemption can be particularly important when a Chapter 13 debtor receives settlement proceeds.

However, the debtor must distinguish exemption rights from plan modification and other statutory issues.

Maryland § 11-504(i) expressly permits execution on a child-support-arrearage judgment against 25% of the debtor’s defined net personal injury or qualifying workers’ compensation indemnity recovery. The ordinary personal injury exemption also does not itself extinguish valid liens or reimbursement rights.

15. Personal Injury Settlement Proceeds

A debtor may receive a substantial settlement during the plan.

The settlement may include compensation for medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, or other damages.

The legal treatment may depend on the nature of the claim and applicable exemptions.

The debtor should coordinate bankruptcy and personal injury counsel.

Settlement proceeds should not be distributed without determining the estate's interest, exemption rights, liens, and applicable court requirements.

16. Workers' Compensation Benefits

A debtor may receive workers' compensation benefits or a settlement during Chapter 13.

Maryland law provides protections for qualifying workers' compensation benefits.

However, the debtor should disclose the claim and determine its bankruptcy treatment.

The nature of the payment may affect exemption and disposable-income questions.

A lump-sum settlement may require different analysis from periodic wage-replacement benefits.

17. Life Insurance Proceeds

A debtor may become entitled to life insurance proceeds during Chapter 13.

The treatment depends on the policy, beneficiary designation, timing, and applicable exemption law.

Section 541(a)(5) addresses certain interests acquired within 180 days after filing.

Section 1306 may expand the Chapter 13 estate beyond that period.

The debtor should disclose the proceeds and determine available exemptions.

18. Gifts

A debtor may receive a substantial gift from a family member or another person.

The gift may constitute property acquired during Chapter 13.

The debtor should not assume that a gift is excluded merely because it was not earned income.

The confirmed plan and applicable law may affect whether the funds must be disclosed or used for plan payments.

Ordinary small gifts may present different practical considerations from substantial transfers.

19. Lottery and Gambling Winnings

A debtor may receive lottery winnings or other gambling proceeds during Chapter 13.

The winnings may constitute property of the estate under § 1306.

A substantial award may affect the debtor's financial circumstances and prompt modification.

The debtor should disclose the winnings.

The fact that the funds were acquired through chance rather than employment does not automatically exclude them from bankruptcy administration.

20. Sale of Property During Chapter 13

A debtor may wish to sell real estate, a vehicle, or other valuable property during the plan.

The sale may require bankruptcy court approval or compliance with applicable procedures.

The proceeds may be subject to liens, exemptions, and estate interests.

The debtor should determine how the transaction affects the confirmed plan.

A sale should not be completed without considering the bankruptcy consequences.

21. Refinancing Real Estate

A debtor may refinance a home during Chapter 13.

The transaction may generate cash proceeds or change secured obligations.

The debtor may need court approval or compliance with local procedures.

The trustee may examine the effect on creditors and plan feasibility.

The debtor should not assume that equity withdrawn through refinancing can be spent without restriction.

22. Trustee Motions to Modify

Section 1329 permits specified parties to seek modification before completion of plan payments.

The trustee may seek increased payments when the debtor's financial circumstances improve.

The proposed modification must satisfy applicable statutory requirements.

The debtor may oppose the modification.

The court determines whether the change is permissible.

23. The Fourth Circuit's Decision in Murphy

In In re Murphy, 474 F.3d 143 (4th Cir. 2007), the Fourth Circuit addressed postconfirmation modification in circumstances involving changes in property value and financial circumstances.

The decision is important when evaluating whether a debtor's improved financial position may support increased payments.

The court considered the effect of substantial and unanticipated changes.

The case should be examined alongside § 1329 and the confirmed plan.

24. Exempt Property and Modification

The fact that property is exempt does not automatically resolve every Chapter 13 disposable-income or modification question.

Exemptions protect specified property interests from creditor administration under applicable law.

The plan's treatment of income and postconfirmation changes may involve separate statutory provisions.

The debtor should not assume that every exempt asset can be spent without regard to the confirmed plan.

Conversely, the trustee should not assume that every receipt of exempt property automatically requires turnover.

The precise legal basis for any proposed modification must be established.

25. Why Disclosure Matters

A debtor who receives substantial funds during Chapter 13 should promptly notify counsel.

Failure to disclose an inheritance, settlement, or other significant asset may create serious problems.

The debtor may face objections, modification proceedings, or allegations of bad faith.

Accurate disclosure permits counsel to determine whether the funds are exempt, subject to the plan, or otherwise available.

The debtor should not wait until the trustee independently discovers the transaction.

26. What If the Debtor Spends the Money Before Disclosure?

Spending substantial proceeds without determining their bankruptcy status can create complications.

The trustee may seek information or relief.

The court may examine the debtor's conduct.

The debtor may be unable to restore funds that should have been preserved.

The debtor should obtain legal advice before using substantial unexpected funds during Chapter 13.

27. Why the Confirmed Plan Must Be Reviewed

The confirmed plan may contain provisions concerning tax refunds, additional income, property sales, or other financial changes.

Those provisions may affect the debtor's obligations.

The debtor should not rely solely on general statements about Chapter 13 estate property.

The actual plan, confirmation order, and applicable law control.

Conclusion

Chapter 13 debtors may acquire substantial property or income during the repayment period.

Section 1306 generally expands the bankruptcy estate to include specified postpetition property and earnings.

Tax refunds, bonuses, inheritances, settlements, gifts, and other funds may therefore affect the case.

However, inclusion in the estate does not automatically establish that every dollar belongs to the trustee.

Exemptions, confirmed plan provisions, and modification requirements must be considered.

A Chapter 13 debtor who receives substantial unexpected money should disclose it promptly and determine its legal treatment before spending or transferring the funds.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes and rules

  • 11 U.S.C. § 541 — Property of the bankruptcy estate.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1306 — Chapter 13 estate property.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1327 — Effect of confirmation.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1329 — Postconfirmation modification.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 522 — Exemptions.

Maryland law

– Maryland Courts and Judicial Proceedings § 11-504 — Maryland exemptions.

Selected decisions

  • Carroll v. Logan, 735 F.3d 147 (4th Cir. 2013) — Holds that an inheritance acquired more than 180 days after filing may become Chapter 13 estate property.
  • In re Murphy, 474 F.3d 143 (4th Cir. 2007) — Addresses postconfirmation modification and changes in financial circumstances.
  • In re Arnold, 869 F.2d 240 (4th Cir. 1989) — Addresses modification following changed circumstances.
  • In re Butcher, 125 F.3d 238 (4th Cir. 1997) — Addresses Maryland's personal injury exemption.
  • Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010) — Addresses projected disposable income.
  • Harris v. Viegelahn, 575 U.S. 510 (2015) — Addresses undistributed Chapter 13 funds following conversion to Chapter 7.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm