A Chapter 13 Case Can End in Several Different Ways—and the Consequences Are Not the Same
A Chapter 13 debtor may spend years making payments to the bankruptcy trustee but encounter financial difficulties before completing the repayment plan.
Job loss, illness, increased living expenses, divorce, or unexpected financial obligations may make continued payments impossible.
The debtor may seek to modify the plan, convert to Chapter 7, request dismissal, or, in limited circumstances, obtain a hardship discharge.
These alternatives have very different consequences.
1. The Four Principal Ways a Chapter 13 Case May End
A Chapter 13 case may conclude through successful completion and discharge, dismissal, conversion to another bankruptcy chapter, or a hardship discharge under § 1328(b).
Successful completion generally produces the ordinary Chapter 13 discharge.
Dismissal ordinarily leaves the debtor without that discharge.
Conversion changes the governing bankruptcy chapter and may expose nonexempt property to liquidation.
A hardship discharge is available only when specific statutory requirements are satisfied and is narrower than the ordinary Chapter 13 discharge.
The debtor should understand the consequences before selecting an alternative.
2. Missing Chapter 13 Payments
Under § 1307(c)(4), failure to commence making timely payments under § 1326 may constitute cause for dismissal or conversion.
A debtor who falls behind after confirmation may also face dismissal proceedings for material default under the confirmed plan.
The trustee may file a motion seeking dismissal.
The debtor may be able to cure the delinquency, propose a modification, or otherwise respond.
However, repeated missed payments can make successful completion increasingly difficult.
3. Motions to Dismiss
Section 1307(c) authorizes dismissal or conversion for cause, subject to applicable requirements.
Grounds may include unreasonable delay prejudicial to creditors, failure to make required payments, material default under a confirmed plan, or denial of confirmation under specified circumstances.
The debtor ordinarily receives notice and an opportunity to respond.
The court may determine whether dismissal or conversion is in the best interests of creditors and the estate.
A debtor should not ignore a trustee's motion merely because payments have resumed.
4. Can the Debtor Reduce Payments Instead?
Section 1329 permits specified modifications of a confirmed Chapter 13 plan before completion of payments.
A debtor whose income has declined may seek reduced payments or other permissible adjustments.
But the modified plan must satisfy applicable statutory requirements.
Priority obligations, secured claims, liquidation value, and the maximum plan duration may restrict the available relief.
A debtor cannot necessarily reduce payments below the amount needed to satisfy mandatory plan obligations.
5. The Five-Year Limit
Chapter 13 plans generally cannot extend beyond five years.
Section 1329(c) restricts the duration of modified plans.
A debtor who falls substantially behind late in the case may have limited time to cure the delinquency.
The court ordinarily cannot extend the plan indefinitely merely because the debtor needs more time.
This is one reason prompt attention to missed payments matters.
6. Voluntary Dismissal
Section 1307(b) generally gives a Chapter 13 debtor who did not previously convert the case a right to seek dismissal.
The statute contains specific language governing that right.
Questions concerning bad faith, pending motions, and the relationship between dismissal and conversion have generated litigation.
A debtor should not assume that dismissal eliminates the consequences of conduct occurring during the case.
Dismissal also ordinarily terminates bankruptcy protection and leaves unpaid debts enforceable.
7. What Happens to Creditors After Dismissal?
Dismissal generally terminates the automatic stay under § 362(c)(2)(B).
Creditors may resume lawful collection activity, subject to applicable nonbankruptcy law and court orders.
A mortgage lender may resume foreclosure.
An automobile lender may pursue repossession.
Unsecured creditors may resume lawsuits or judgment enforcement.
The debtor generally does not receive a discharge of unpaid debts.
8. Are Payments Made During Chapter 13 Lost?
Not necessarily.
Money already distributed to creditors ordinarily remains credited according to applicable law.
For example, trustee payments may have reduced a vehicle loan or cured part of a mortgage arrearage.
However, the debtor may have paid trustee compensation, attorney's fees, and other expenses during the case.
Dismissal does not ordinarily require creditors to return all payments received under the plan.
The debtor should obtain a trustee accounting before evaluating the remaining debts.
9. What Happens to Money Still Held by the Trustee?
Undistributed funds require separate analysis.
The result can depend on whether the case is dismissed, converted, or otherwise terminated, and on the applicable statutory provisions.
In Harris v. Viegelahn, 575 U.S. 510 (2015), the Supreme Court held that undistributed postpetition wages held by a Chapter 13 trustee ordinarily must be returned to the debtor following conversion to Chapter 7 in the circumstances addressed.
Dismissal presents a different statutory framework, including § 349 and § 1326.
The debtor should not assume that all funds held by the trustee receive identical treatment regardless of how the case ends.
10. Conversion to Chapter 7
Under § 1307(a), a Chapter 13 debtor generally may convert the case to Chapter 7, subject to applicable statutory requirements.
Conversion may be appropriate when the debtor can no longer afford plan payments.
However, the debtor must qualify for Chapter 7 relief.
The debtor should also determine whether nonexempt property may become available for liquidation.
Conversion may eliminate the obligation to continue the Chapter 13 plan, but it does not guarantee that the debtor can retain every asset.
11. Property of the Converted Chapter 7 Estate
Section 348(f) generally governs property of the estate when a Chapter 13 case converts to Chapter 7.
In a qualifying good-faith conversion, the converted estate generally includes property belonging to the estate on the original petition date that remains in the debtor's possession or control at conversion.
Section 348(f)(2) instead uses property of the estate as of conversion when the debtor converts in bad faith. Section 348(f)(1)(B) also prevents the Chapter 13 valuation and allowed-secured-claim determination from automatically carrying into Chapter 7. Asset ownership, disposition, valuation, and lien issues should be examined before conversion.
The debtor should examine property acquired or disposed of during Chapter 13 before converting.
12. The Hardship Discharge
Section 1328(b) permits a hardship discharge when the debtor cannot complete payments because of circumstances for which the debtor should not justly be held accountable.
The debtor must also satisfy the statutory liquidation-value requirement.
Modification under § 1329 must be impracticable.
The hardship discharge is not automatically available whenever the debtor loses employment or becomes ill.
The court must determine whether all requirements have been met.
13. The Hardship Discharge Is Narrower
A hardship discharge under § 1328(b) does not provide the same scope of relief as an ordinary Chapter 13 discharge under § 1328(a).
Section 1328(c) limits the hardship discharge to covered unsecured debts and incorporates all § 523(a) categories, as well as excluding debts provided for under § 1322(b)(5). Non-support divorce obligations and certain intentional-injury debts therefore can receive a different result from an ordinary completion discharge.
Certain debts that might be discharged following successful plan completion may survive a hardship discharge.
The debtor should compare the consequences before requesting relief.
31. Why Completing the Plan Matters
The financial benefit of Chapter 13 may extend beyond the amounts paid through the trustee.
A debtor may complete a plan in which some unsecured creditors receive only partial distributions and others receive none because they failed to file timely claims.
Upon entry of discharge, qualifying remaining personal liabilities may be eliminated.
Dismissal before discharge can leave those obligations enforceable.
The discharge—not the expiration of the claims deadline—is ordinarily the event that permanently eliminates qualifying remaining personal liability.
Conclusion
A Chapter 13 case may end through successful completion, dismissal, conversion, or hardship discharge. The consequences differ substantially. A debtor who cannot finish should compare modification, the converted estate, and the scope of hardship relief before choosing a course. Dismissal ordinarily leaves unpaid obligations enforceable and terminates the automatic stay. Payments already made and funds still held by the trustee require separate accounting and legal analysis.
Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities
Federal statutes and rules
11 U.S.C. § 501 — Filing proofs of claim.
11 U.S.C. § 502 — Allowance and disallowance of claims.
11 U.S.C. § 348 — Effect of conversion.
11 U.S.C. § 349 — Effect of dismissal.
11 U.S.C. § 1307 — Conversion and dismissal.
11 U.S.C. § 1328 — Ordinary and hardship discharge.
11 U.S.C. § 1329 — Modification.
Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 3002 — Proof-of-claim deadlines.
Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 3004 — Claims filed by debtors or trustees.
Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 1019 — Procedures following conversion.
Selected decisions
Harris v. Viegelahn, 575 U.S. 510 (2015) — Addresses undistributed postpetition wages following conversion from Chapter 13 to Chapter 7.
United Student Aid Funds, Inc. v. Espinosa, 559 U.S. 260 (2010) — Addresses the binding effect of confirmed plans and procedural requirements.
Rake v. Wade, 508 U.S. 464 (1993) — Discusses claims provided for by a Chapter 13 plan.
In re Arnold, 869 F.2d 240 (4th Cir. 1989) — Addresses postconfirmation modification.
In re Murphy, 474 F.3d 143 (4th Cir. 2007) — Addresses changed circumstances and plan modification.
Maryland practice
United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Maryland — Local Rules, claims register, and Chapter 13 procedures.
National Data Center — Online access to payment and distribution information for participating Chapter 13 trustees.
Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions
Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.