Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

How Soon Can You File Bankruptcy Again? Waiting Periods, Repeat Discharges, and Limitations on the Automatic Stay

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Bankruptcy Eligibility and Repeat Filings

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Filing Bankruptcy Again Is Not the Same as Qualifying for Another Discharge

A person who previously filed bankruptcy may need relief again because of unemployment, illness, divorce, business failure, or other financial difficulties.

Federal bankruptcy law does not impose a universal prohibition against filing another bankruptcy case.

However, the Bankruptcy Code restricts how frequently an individual may receive a discharge. It also limits automatic-stay protection in certain repeat-filing situations.

These are separate questions.

A debtor may be permitted to file another bankruptcy petition but be ineligible to receive a discharge in the new case.

Similarly, a debtor may be eligible for a new discharge but receive limited protection from foreclosure, repossession, or other collection activity because of recently dismissed cases.

Understanding the differences is essential before filing again.

1. Three Questions Must Be Answered

When evaluating a repeat bankruptcy filing, counsel should determine whether the debtor is eligible to commence the new case, whether the debtor is eligible to receive a discharge, and whether the automatic stay will arise and remain effective.

These questions are governed by different provisions of the Bankruptcy Code.

Eligibility to file is addressed principally through § 109 and other applicable provisions.

Eligibility for a Chapter 7 discharge is governed in part by § 727(a)(8) and (9).

Eligibility for a Chapter 13 discharge is governed in part by § 1328(f).

Repeat-filing restrictions on the automatic stay appear principally in § 362(c)(3) and (4).

A debtor should not assume that satisfying one set of requirements satisfies the others.

2. The Waiting Periods for Another Bankruptcy Discharge

The following table summarizes the ordinary waiting periods between successive discharges.

Previous discharge New case Ordinary waiting period
Chapter 7 Chapter 7 8 years
Chapter 7 Chapter 13 4 years
Chapter 13 Chapter 7 6 years, subject to statutory exceptions
Chapter 13 Chapter 13 2 years

These periods generally are measured from the filing date of the earlier case to the filing date of the new case—not from the date the earlier discharge was entered.

That distinction can materially affect eligibility.

3. Chapter 7 Followed by Another Chapter 7: Eight Years

Under § 727(a)(8), a debtor generally cannot receive a Chapter 7 discharge if the debtor received a discharge in a Chapter 7 or Chapter 11 case commenced within eight years before the filing of the new Chapter 7 petition.

Example

A debtor files Chapter 7 on March 15, 2020, and receives a discharge several months later.

The ordinary eight-year period is measured from March 15, 2020.

The debtor generally would not be eligible for another Chapter 7 discharge in a case filed before March 15, 2028.

The date of the earlier discharge is not the starting point.

The debtor must still satisfy the other eligibility requirements.

4. Chapter 7 Followed by Chapter 13: Four Years

Under § 1328(f)(1), a debtor generally cannot receive a Chapter 13 discharge if the debtor received a discharge in a Chapter 7, Chapter 11, or Chapter 12 case filed during the four years preceding the new Chapter 13 filing.

A debtor may nevertheless be able to file Chapter 13 before four years have passed.

The absence of discharge eligibility does not necessarily prevent confirmation of a plan in every circumstance.

For example, a debtor who recently completed Chapter 7 may need Chapter 13 to cure mortgage arrears or address other obligations through a repayment plan.

This sequence is sometimes described as a Chapter 20 strategy.

It is not a separate chapter of the Bankruptcy Code.

The debtor's eligibility, good faith, plan feasibility, and available relief must be examined carefully.

5. Chapter 13 Followed by Chapter 7: Six Years

Under § 727(a)(9), a debtor generally cannot receive a Chapter 7 discharge if the debtor received a discharge in a Chapter 12 or Chapter 13 case commenced within six years before the new Chapter 7 filing.

However, the statute provides important exceptions.

The six-year restriction does not apply when the payments under the earlier plan totaled at least 100% of allowed unsecured claims.

An exception also applies when payments totaled at least 70% of allowed unsecured claims and the plan was proposed in good faith and represented the debtor's best effort.

These exceptions can materially affect the calculation.

Counsel should review the prior confirmed plan, payment history, trustee records, and discharge order rather than assuming that every prior Chapter 13 discharge creates a six-year bar.

6. Chapter 13 Followed by Another Chapter 13: Two Years

Under § 1328(f)(2), a debtor generally cannot receive a Chapter 13 discharge if the debtor received a discharge in a Chapter 13 case filed during the two years preceding the new filing.

Because Chapter 13 plans commonly last three to five years, the two-year restriction may already have expired by the time the debtor completes the earlier case.

Nevertheless, unusual circumstances can make the provision relevant.

The period is measured between petition dates.

7. What If the Earlier Case Was Dismissed Without Discharge?

A dismissal is different from a discharge.

The ordinary two-, four-, six-, and eight-year discharge waiting periods generally depend on a discharge having been received in the earlier case.

A case dismissed without discharge ordinarily does not trigger those particular restrictions.

However, dismissal can create other barriers.

Section 109(g) may impose a 180-day restriction in specified circumstances.

Repeat dismissals can also limit or prevent the automatic stay in a new case.

A debtor should therefore not assume that dismissal means another case can be filed immediately with full protection.

8. The 180-Day Filing Restriction Under § 109(g)

Section 109(g) generally makes an individual ineligible to be a debtor for 180 days after certain dismissals.

The restriction may apply when the prior case was dismissed because of the debtor's willful failure to obey court orders or appear before the court in proper prosecution of the case.

It may also apply when the debtor voluntarily dismissed the case following the filing of a request for relief from the automatic stay.

The statutory language and relevant case law must be examined.

Not every dismissal for failure to file documents automatically establishes the willfulness required under § 109(g)(1).

The reason for dismissal matters.

9. One Dismissed Case Within the Previous Year: The Thirty-Day Rule

Section 362(c)(3) addresses certain debtors who had one bankruptcy case pending and dismissed during the preceding year.

When the provision applies, the automatic stay generally terminates on the thirtieth day after the new filing with respect to the debtor, unless the court extends it.

The statute contains exceptions and qualifications.

Courts have disagreed about whether the termination extends to property of the bankruptcy estate.

That distinction can be critical in foreclosure cases.

A debtor who files again should not assume that the stay will protect every relevant interest for the full duration of the case.

10. Extending the Stay Beyond Thirty Days

Section 362(c)(3)(B) permits a party in interest to request an extension of the automatic stay.

The motion must be filed and heard within the statutory period.

The court must find that the later case was filed in good faith as to the creditors to be stayed.

The statute establishes presumptions of bad faith in specified circumstances.

A debtor seeking an extension should be prepared to explain why the earlier case failed and why the new case is likely to succeed.

For example, a debtor whose earlier Chapter 13 case was dismissed after job loss may have stronger evidence of good faith if the debtor has since obtained stable employment and can fund a feasible plan.

The hearing must be completed before expiration of the thirty-day period.

A motion filed shortly before the deadline may therefore be too late to obtain effective relief.

11. Two or More Dismissed Cases Within the Previous Year: No Automatic Stay

Under § 362(c)(4), when two or more qualifying cases were pending and dismissed during the preceding year, the automatic stay generally does not take effect upon filing the new petition.

This is more severe than the thirty-day limitation.

The debtor may file a new case without receiving the ordinary immediate protection against foreclosure, repossession, or collection.

A party in interest may request an order imposing the stay.

The motion must satisfy the statutory timing and good-faith requirements.

For § 362(c)(4), the request to impose the stay must be made within 30 days after the new case is filed; an order generally becomes effective when entered. That motion deadline differs from § 362(c)(3), which requires completion of the extension hearing before the original 30-day stay expires.

The court may impose the stay after notice and hearing when the required showing is made.

12. Why Repeat Filings Can Be Dangerous Before Foreclosure

A debtor facing an imminent foreclosure may believe that filing another bankruptcy petition will automatically stop the sale.

That assumption can be wrong.

If § 362(c)(4) applies, no automatic stay may arise.

If § 362(c)(3) applies, the stay may terminate after thirty days unless extended.

The effect of the filing also depends on the timing and status of the foreclosure proceeding.

A debtor should not rely on repeated petitions as a substitute for a feasible plan to resolve mortgage arrears.

13. What If the Previous Bankruptcy Was Voluntarily Dismissed?

A voluntary dismissal can have different consequences depending on the circumstances.

Under § 109(g)(2), a debtor who voluntarily dismisses a case following a creditor's request for relief from the automatic stay may face a 180-day eligibility restriction.

The statutory language has generated litigation concerning the required relationship between the stay-relief request and dismissal.

A debtor should not assume that voluntarily dismissing a case eliminates all consequences for future filings.

The procedural history must be reviewed.

14. Does Conversion Count as Another Bankruptcy Filing?

Conversion from one chapter to another generally does not commence a new bankruptcy case.

Under § 348(a), conversion ordinarily does not change the date of the filing of the petition, commencement of the case, or order for relief, except as otherwise provided.

This distinction matters when calculating discharge waiting periods.

For example, a case originally filed under Chapter 13 and later converted to Chapter 7 generally retains the original petition date for the relevant calculation.

The chapter under which the debtor ultimately received a discharge also matters.

The docket and discharge order should be reviewed.

15. What If the Prior Discharge Was Denied?

A debtor whose discharge was denied may face additional restrictions.

Section 523(a)(10) addresses certain debts that were or could have been listed in a prior case in which discharge was waived or denied under specified provisions.

A later bankruptcy does not necessarily eliminate debts that survived because of misconduct in the earlier case.

The consequences depend on the statutory basis for the prior denial.

A debtor should not assume that waiting eight years automatically cures every prior discharge problem.

16. Can a Debtor File Chapter 13 Without Being Eligible for a Discharge?

Potentially, yes.

A debtor who recently received a Chapter 7 discharge may seek Chapter 13 relief to address mortgage arrears, secured obligations, or other debts.

But the debtor must satisfy Chapter 13 eligibility, good faith, feasibility, and confirmation requirements.

The absence of discharge eligibility can affect the benefits available at completion.

A debtor should understand that plan completion may not eliminate remaining personal liability for obligations that otherwise would have been discharged.

17. Repeat Filings and Good Faith

Bankruptcy courts may examine whether a repeat filing represents a legitimate effort to obtain relief or an abusive attempt to delay creditors.

Relevant factors can include the debtor's financial circumstances, reasons for prior dismissals, changes in income, accuracy of disclosures, and feasibility of the proposed plan.

Repeat filing alone does not necessarily establish bad faith.

But a history of unsuccessful cases filed shortly before foreclosure may warrant heightened scrutiny.

The debtor should be prepared to explain what has changed and why the new case is likely to succeed.

18. Why the Prior Bankruptcy Docket Matters

The debtor's recollection of an earlier case may be incomplete.

A person may remember filing Chapter 13 but not recall whether the case was dismissed, converted, or discharged.

The relevant dates may also differ from the debtor's assumptions.

Before filing again, counsel should obtain the prior bankruptcy docket and determine the original petition date, chapter, conversion history, dismissal or discharge date, and reasons for dismissal.

Any prior stay-relief motions should also be reviewed.

The docket may reveal restrictions that materially affect the new case.

19. Can a New Bankruptcy Discharge Old Debts That Survived the Previous Case?

Sometimes, depending on why the debts survived and the applicable statutory provisions.

For example, a debt may have survived because the earlier case was dismissed without discharge.

A later qualifying bankruptcy may discharge that debt.

But debts excepted from discharge under § 523 may remain nondischargeable.

Debts associated with certain prior denials of discharge may also be excepted under § 523(a)(10).

The nature of the debt and the outcome of the earlier case must be examined.

20. Why Filing Eligibility and Discharge Eligibility Must Be Kept Separate

A debtor may be eligible to file Chapter 13 but ineligible for another discharge.

A debtor may be eligible for discharge but subject to a shortened automatic stay.

A debtor may also be temporarily ineligible to file because of § 109(g).

These are different legal consequences.

A careful repeat-filing analysis should identify each restriction separately.

The debtor should not rely on a simplified statement that bankruptcy can be filed only once every seven or eight years.

That statement is incorrect.

Conclusion

Federal bankruptcy law permits repeat filings in appropriate circumstances, but it imposes important restrictions on successive discharges and automatic-stay protection.

The ordinary discharge waiting periods are two, four, six, or eight years, depending on the chapters involved and applicable exceptions.

Those periods generally run from the filing date of the earlier case to the filing date of the new case.

Dismissed cases may create separate restrictions, including a possible 180-day filing bar and limitations on the automatic stay.

Before filing bankruptcy again, the prior case's docket, discharge history, dismissal history, and stay-relief proceedings should be examined.

A repeat filing should be undertaken only after determining what protection and relief the new case can actually provide.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes

  • 11 U.S.C. § 109(g) — Certain 180-day eligibility restrictions.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 348 — Effect of conversion.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 362(c)(3)–(4) — Automatic-stay limitations for repeat filings.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(10) — Certain debts affected by prior denial or waiver of discharge.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 727(a)(8)–(9) — Restrictions on successive Chapter 7 discharges.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1328(f) — Restrictions on successive Chapter 13 discharges.

Selected decisions

  • Marrama v. Citizens Bank of Massachusetts, 549 U.S. 365 (2007) — Addresses bad faith and conversion between bankruptcy chapters.
  • In re Tomlin, 105 F.3d 933 (4th Cir. 1997) — Addresses dismissal with prejudice and the effect of prior bankruptcy dismissal orders.
  • In re Dilley, 125 B.R. 189 (Bankr. N.D. Ohio 1991) — Discusses repeat filings and eligibility restrictions.
  • In re Casse, 198 F.3d 327 (2d Cir. 1999) — Addresses abusive repeat filings and bankruptcy court authority to impose filing restrictions.
  • In re Jumpp, 356 B.R. 789 (1st Cir. BAP 2006) — Discusses the scope of stay termination under § 362(c)(3).
  • In re Reswick, 446 B.R. 362 (9th Cir. BAP 2011) — Addresses the scope of § 362(c)(3)(A) stay termination.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm