Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

IRS Expense Standards in Chapter 7 and Chapter 13: Why Debtors May Deduct More Than They Actually Spend

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Means Testing and Disposable Income

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

The Means Test Does Not Always Use What the Debtor Actually Spends

One of the more counterintuitive features of consumer bankruptcy law is that a debtor may sometimes deduct more for living expenses than the debtor actually spends.

The Bankruptcy Code incorporates expense standards developed by the Internal Revenue Service. These standards are used in determining whether a presumption of abuse arises in Chapter 7 and in calculating disposable income for certain Chapter 13 debtors.

But the means test is not simply a household budget.

The distinction is especially important for individuals who live economically, share housing expenses, drive older vehicles, or otherwise spend less than the applicable standardized allowances.

In the Fourth Circuit, Lynch v. Jackson, 853 F.3d 116 (4th Cir. 2017), provides important guidance concerning the use of IRS expense standards.

However, the debtor must distinguish between expenses determined under statutory standards and expenses that depend on actual amounts paid.

The debtor must also distinguish the mechanical means test from Schedule J, which reports actual or reasonably anticipated household expenses.

1. Why Bankruptcy Uses IRS Standards

Congress incorporated specified IRS expense standards into the Bankruptcy Code through the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005.

Section 707(b)(2)(A)(ii)(I) addresses certain expense deductions in the Chapter 7 means test.

Section 1325(b)(3) generally incorporates the same expense framework for above-median-income Chapter 13 debtors.

The purpose is to create a standardized method for calculating specified living expenses rather than relying exclusively on each debtor's reported spending.

The statutory approach can produce deductions greater or smaller than actual expenditures.

2. IRS National Standards

IRS National Standards generally address categories such as food, clothing, and certain miscellaneous expenses.

The applicable amounts depend on household size and other relevant factors.

For qualifying categories, the debtor generally may use the standardized allowance even when actual spending is lower.

Example

Assume the applicable National Standard is $1,150 per month.

The debtor actually spends $800.

The debtor generally may claim the $1,150 standardized amount on the means test when the deduction applies.

The debtor does not need to increase spending to qualify.

3. IRS Local Standards

IRS Local Standards generally concern housing, utilities, and transportation.

The applicable figures may vary by geographic area and household circumstances.

The Bankruptcy Code refers to applicable monthly expense amounts specified under the National and Local Standards.

However, not every category operates identically.

The debtor must qualify for the particular deduction.

Vehicle ownership expenses present an important example.

4. The Fourth Circuit's Decision in Lynch v. Jackson

In Lynch v. Jackson, 853 F.3d 116 (4th Cir. 2017), the Fourth Circuit addressed the use of IRS standardized expense allowances in bankruptcy.

The court recognized the distinction between applicable standardized amounts and actual expenses.

The decision supports the principle that a qualifying debtor may claim the applicable standardized deduction even when actual expenditures are lower.

Lynch permits the full applicable National or Local Standard when the debtor incurs the category of expense, even if the actual amount is lower. It does not authorize an allowance for an inapplicable category; Ransom’s requirement of a qualifying loan or lease expense for the vehicle ownership allowance remains controlling.

This principle is important for Maryland debtors because federal bankruptcy courts in Maryland are bound by Fourth Circuit precedent.

A debtor should not assume that economical living automatically reduces the statutory means-test allowance.

5. Why IRS Collection Rules Are Different

The IRS uses expense standards when evaluating a taxpayer's ability to pay delinquent taxes.

In that context, the IRS may apply rules limiting certain allowances to the lesser of actual expenses or the applicable standard.

Bankruptcy law incorporates the standards through its own statutory language.

The IRS's administrative collection procedures do not automatically govern bankruptcy means testing.

The distinction was central to litigation concerning the meaning of standardized deductions.

A debtor should not assume that every instruction in the IRS Financial Analysis Handbook applies to bankruptcy.

6. Vehicle Ownership Expenses: The Ransom Limitation

In Ransom v. FIA Card Services, N.A., 562 U.S. 61 (2011), the Supreme Court held that a debtor who owned a vehicle free and clear could not claim the vehicle ownership deduction under the statutory framework considered.

The debtor did not have a qualifying loan or lease payment.

The Court distinguished between an applicable expense category and a deduction for an expense the debtor would not incur.

Thus, a debtor who owns a vehicle without a loan or lease generally cannot claim the ownership allowance merely because the IRS publishes one.

7. Vehicle Operating Expenses

Vehicle operating expenses are different from ownership expenses.

A debtor who owns a vehicle may incur gasoline, maintenance, registration, and other operating costs even without a loan payment.

When the debtor qualifies for the applicable operating allowance, the standardized amount generally may be used despite lower actual expenditures.

The debtor must accurately identify the vehicles and circumstances relevant to the deduction.

The operating allowance should not be confused with the ownership allowance.

8. Housing and Utilities

Housing and utility deductions may include standardized allowances for specified categories.

A debtor may spend less than the applicable standard.

However, the treatment of mortgage payments and other secured obligations requires attention to the means-test calculation and applicable form instructions.

The debtor should not simply claim the full housing standard and separately deduct every mortgage payment without considering the statutory adjustments.

The correct calculation must avoid impermissible duplication.

9. Actual Expenses Under the Means Test

Not every expense is determined through a standardized allowance.

Section 707(b)(2) provides for specified actual expenses and additional deductions.

Examples may include qualifying health insurance expenses, certain secured debt payments, priority claims, and other amounts satisfying statutory requirements.

The debtor must distinguish standardized categories from actual-expense categories.

A debtor cannot automatically substitute an IRS allowance for an expense that the statute requires to be established by actual payment or other qualifying criteria.

10. Chapter 7 Means Testing

Chapter 7 means testing generally applies to qualifying individual debtors whose debts are primarily consumer debts.

A debtor whose current monthly income exceeds the applicable median may need to complete Form 122A-2.

The form calculates deductions under the statutory framework.

A debtor may properly claim standardized allowances greater than actual expenditures.

The resulting calculation determines whether a presumption of abuse arises under § 707(b)(2).

However, the means test is not the only possible basis for dismissal.

11. Below-Median Chapter 7 Debtors

A below-median-income debtor generally does not complete the full expense-deduction calculation on Form 122A-2.

The statutory presumption of abuse ordinarily does not arise.

The debtor still must disclose actual income and expenses on Schedules I and J.

A below-median debtor should not use IRS standardized allowances to inflate Schedule J.

The distinction is important.

12. Schedule J Is Not the Means Test

Schedule J reports the debtor's actual or reasonably anticipated monthly expenses.

It is intended to provide a realistic picture of the debtor's household budget.

The debtor should not automatically insert IRS standardized allowances when actual expenses are lower.

For example, a debtor who pays $400 in rent should not report $1,800 merely because a housing standard permits that amount on the means test.

The Schedule J figure should reflect the debtor's actual or reasonably anticipated expense.

The standardized allowance belongs in the appropriate means-test calculation.

13. Example: Means Test Versus Schedule J

Assume a debtor has the following expenses:

Expense Actual monthly expense Applicable IRS standard
Food, clothing, miscellaneous $850 $1,200
Housing and utilities $1,300 $1,900
Vehicle operating expenses $225 $375

On the means test, the debtor generally may claim the applicable standardized amounts when the statutory requirements are satisfied.

On Schedule J, the debtor should report the actual or reasonably anticipated expenses.

The two forms may therefore show different amounts without either being incorrect.

14. Why a Debtor May Pass the Means Test but Have a Surplus

A debtor may qualify under the means test because standardized allowances reduce calculated disposable income.

But Schedule I and Schedule J may show a substantial actual monthly surplus.

This is not necessarily a mathematical error.

The forms serve different purposes.

However, the difference may become important under § 707(b)(3).

A debtor should not assume that passing the means test eliminates every possible abuse objection.

15. Section 707(b)(3): Totality of Financial Circumstances

Section 707(b)(3) permits consideration of bad faith and the totality of the debtor's financial circumstances when the statutory presumption of abuse does not arise or is rebutted.

The United States Trustee may examine the debtor's actual financial ability to repay creditors.

For example, a debtor may properly claim standardized means-test deductions but have a substantial actual monthly surplus.

That surplus may be relevant to the totality-of-circumstances inquiry.

However, the trustee cannot simply rewrite the statutory means test by substituting actual expenses for authorized standardized deductions.

The separate statutory inquiries must be respected.

16. The Fourth Circuit's Decision in Green v. Staples

In Green v. Staples (In re Green), 934 F.2d 568 (4th Cir. 1991), the Fourth Circuit addressed substantial abuse under the pre-2005 statutory framework.

The court identified factors relevant to evaluating the debtor's financial circumstances.

The decision predates the current § 707(b) provisions.

Nevertheless, it remains historically important to the Fourth Circuit's treatment of ability to pay and abuse.

The current statutory framework must be applied rather than assuming the pre-2005 standard controls unchanged.

17. Primarily Nonconsumer Debts

Section 707(b) generally applies to individual debtors whose debts are primarily consumer debts.

A debtor whose obligations are primarily nonconsumer debts ordinarily is not subject to the § 707(b) means-test presumption or its separate abuse provisions.

Business loans, commercial guarantees, and certain investment-related debts may be nonconsumer obligations.

The classification depends on the purpose of the debt.

The debtor must still satisfy other Bankruptcy Code requirements.

18. Chapter 13 Above-Median Debtors

Section 1325(b)(3) generally requires above-median Chapter 13 debtors to calculate reasonably necessary expenses under § 707(b)(2).

The standardized allowances therefore can affect projected disposable income.

A debtor who spends less than the applicable IRS standard may nevertheless claim the qualifying standardized amount.

The result may reduce the amount required for general unsecured creditors.

However, the debtor must also satisfy feasibility, good faith, and other confirmation requirements.

19. Chapter 13 Below-Median Debtors

Below-median Chapter 13 debtors generally do not use the same standardized expense framework to determine reasonably necessary expenses under § 1325(b)(3).

Actual reasonable and necessary expenses are particularly important.

The debtor should provide an accurate household budget.

The court may examine whether expenses are reasonable under the circumstances.

A below-median debtor should not assume that every IRS standardized allowance automatically controls plan payments.

20. The Effect of Hamilton v. Lanning

In Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010), the Supreme Court addressed projected disposable income in Chapter 13.

The Court approved consideration of changes in income or expenses that are known or virtually certain at confirmation.

The decision recognizes that the mechanical calculation may not always reflect expected future financial circumstances.

However, Lanning does not authorize routine replacement of statutory standardized allowances with lower actual expenses merely because the debtor spends less.

The cases address related but distinct questions.

21. Feasibility in Chapter 13

Section 1325(a)(6) requires a finding that the debtor can make all payments under the plan.

A debtor may have a legally calculated disposable-income amount that differs from actual cash flow.

The proposed plan must nevertheless be financially feasible.

For example, a debtor may have substantial actual expenses exceeding standardized allowances.

The debtor may be unable to fund a plan payment calculated without considering the full financial circumstances.

The court must evaluate feasibility separately from the disposable-income test.

22. Good Faith

Section 1325(a)(3) requires that the plan be proposed in good faith and not by any means forbidden by law.

A debtor's use of a legally authorized standardized deduction does not automatically establish bad faith.

However, the debtor's overall conduct and circumstances may be relevant.

The court should distinguish lawful use of statutory allowances from inaccurate disclosures or manipulative conduct.

A debtor should not conceal actual financial circumstances merely because the means test permits standardized deductions.

23. Why Standardized Allowances Can Benefit Economical Debtors

The standardized system can benefit debtors who live below the published allowances.

A debtor who shares housing, purchases inexpensive food, or drives an economical vehicle may spend less than the applicable standards.

When the debtor qualifies for the statutory deduction, the means test generally permits use of the standardized amount.

The debtor should not be penalized within the mechanical calculation merely for spending less.

But the debtor must remain accurate in reporting actual expenses elsewhere.

24. Why the Distinction Matters in Practice

The difference between the means test and Schedule J can materially affect bankruptcy eligibility and Chapter 13 plan calculations.

An attorney who substitutes actual expenses for standardized allowances on Form 122A-2 may unnecessarily create a presumption of abuse.

Conversely, an attorney who copies IRS allowances into Schedule J may overstate actual household expenses.

Both errors can affect the case.

The correct approach is to apply the governing instructions to each form independently.

Conclusion

The Bankruptcy Code permits qualifying debtors to use applicable IRS National and Local Standard allowances in means-test calculations even when actual expenses are lower.

The Fourth Circuit's decision in Lynch v. Jackson is important to Maryland practice.

But the debtor must qualify for the deduction, and some categories depend on actual expenses.

Ransom limits vehicle ownership deductions when no qualifying loan or lease expense exists.

Schedule J remains a separate disclosure of actual or reasonably anticipated household expenses.

In Chapter 7, substantial actual disposable income may raise issues under § 707(b)(3) even when the debtor passes the mechanical means test.

In Chapter 13, standardized deductions interact with projected disposable income, feasibility, and good faith.

The correct approach is neither to substitute actual expenses for every IRS allowance nor to use IRS allowances as though they were actual household expenditures. Each calculation must be performed for its own statutory purpose.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes and forms

  • 11 U.S.C. § 707(b)(2) — Chapter 7 means-test deductions.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 707(b)(3) — Bad faith and totality-of-circumstances abuse.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1325(b) — Chapter 13 projected disposable income.
  • Official Bankruptcy Forms — Forms 122A-2, 122C-2, and Schedule J.

Selected decisions

  • Lynch v. Jackson, 853 F.3d 116 (4th Cir. 2017) — Addresses the use of IRS standardized expense allowances.
  • Ransom v. FIA Card Services, N.A., 562 U.S. 61 (2011) — Addresses the vehicle ownership deduction.
  • Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010) — Addresses projected disposable income and known or virtually certain changes.
  • Green v. Staples (In re Green), 934 F.2d 568 (4th Cir. 1991) — Addresses substantial abuse under the former statutory framework.
  • In re Quigley, 673 F.3d 269 (4th Cir. 2012) — Addresses deductions concerning collateral the debtor intends to surrender.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm