Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Household Size in Bankruptcy: Adult Children, Elderly Parents, Separated Spouses, and Shared Living Arrangements

BELSKY BANKRUPTCY LEGAL LIBRARY | CHAPTER 7 ELIGIBILITY AND MEANS TESTING

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Who Counts as a Member of Your Household?

Determining household size in bankruptcy can be surprisingly complicated. A married couple with two minor children ordinarily presents a straightforward case. But what about an unmarried debtor supporting an elderly parent, a divorced person living with adult children, or spouses who remain married but maintain separate households?

The answer can significantly affect Chapter 7 eligibility.

Household size determines which median-income threshold applies under the bankruptcy means test. It can also affect standardized living-expense allowances and the assessment of a debtor's actual household expenses.

The Bankruptcy Code does not establish a single comprehensive definition of household size applicable to every bankruptcy calculation. Courts have developed different approaches, sometimes reaching different conclusions on similar facts.

Consequently, the number of people residing at a particular address does not always establish the number who should be included in the bankruptcy household.

1. Why Household Size Matters

Under 11 U.S.C. § 707(b)(7), an individual debtor whose annualized current monthly income does not exceed the applicable state median income for the relevant family size generally is not subject to the presumption of abuse under § 707(b)(2).

Median-income thresholds increase with household size.

A debtor whose income exceeds the median for a household of one may fall below the median for a household of three.

For above-median debtors, household size can also affect the allowable amounts for food, clothing, housing, utilities, and other expenses.

Thus, household size may influence both the initial median-income comparison and the subsequent means-test calculation.

However, increasing household size does not necessarily increase every allowable deduction, and the appropriate household count may vary according to the particular form or legal issue involved.

2. Three Approaches Courts Have Used

Courts have generally discussed three approaches to determining household size: the heads-on-beds approach, the income-tax-dependent approach, and the economic-unit approach.

These labels describe judicial approaches rather than three alternatives freely available for debtors to choose.

The heads-on-beds approach

Under this approach, household size generally reflects the number of people who regularly reside in the home.

Its advantage is relative simplicity.

Its weakness is that it may include individuals who share an address but maintain substantially independent finances.

For example, a debtor who rents a bedroom to an unrelated tenant ordinarily should not assume that the tenant automatically qualifies as part of the debtor's bankruptcy household merely because they occupy the same residence.

The income-tax-dependent approach

This approach looks to the individuals whom the debtor may claim as dependents under applicable federal tax rules.

It provides a relatively objective measure of financial dependency.

However, bankruptcy household composition and federal income-tax dependency are not necessarily identical.

A debtor may provide meaningful support to a relative who does not qualify as a tax dependent. Conversely, a person claimed on a tax return may not reside with the debtor throughout the relevant period.

The economic-unit approach

The economic-unit approach examines the degree to which individuals function together financially.

Relevant factors may include shared housing, food, utilities, transportation, household purchases, and the extent to which one person supports another.

This approach recognizes that a household is often an economic arrangement rather than simply a collection of people living at the same address.

Its disadvantage is that it requires a fact-intensive examination.

3. The Fourth Circuit's Decision in Johnson v. Zimmer

For Maryland bankruptcy cases, an important decision is Johnson v. Zimmer, 686 F.3d 224 (4th Cir. 2012).

The Fourth Circuit addressed household size in a Chapter 13 case and approved the economic-unit approach.

The court rejected a rigid method based solely on physical residence or tax dependency.

Instead, the analysis considers whether individuals operate as a financially integrated household.

Although Johnson arose in Chapter 13, its reasoning is highly relevant to household-size questions arising in Chapter 7 means testing.

The decision does not establish that every person living in a debtor's home must be counted. Nor does it require that every household member be completely financially dependent on the debtor.

The inquiry focuses on the actual economic relationship among the individuals.

4. Adult Children Living With a Parent

Adult children present one of the most common household-size questions.

An adult child may live with a parent while attending college, seeking employment, recovering from financial difficulties, or saving money for independent housing.

The child's age alone does not resolve whether the child belongs in the bankruptcy household.

Example: Two adult children living at home

A divorced debtor lives with two adult children.

The debtor pays the mortgage, utilities, homeowners insurance, and most household expenses.

The children occupy bedrooms in the residence, use the kitchen and laundry facilities, and share groceries and other household necessities.

Even though the children are adults, these circumstances may support treating the household as an economic unit of three people.

The analysis becomes stronger if the debtor provides substantial financial support and the children have limited independent income.

But if both children are fully employed, pay rent, purchase their own food, and maintain substantially separate finances, the conclusion may differ.

The relevant issue is not simply whether the children reside in the home, but how the household actually functions.

5. Must Adult Children Be Financially Dependent?

Not necessarily in the same sense required under federal tax law.

The economic-unit approach does not always require complete financial dependency.

An adult child may contribute toward household expenses while remaining part of an integrated family economic unit.

For example, an employed adult child might contribute $500 monthly toward household expenses while the parent pays the mortgage, utilities, insurance, and most food costs.

That contribution does not automatically establish that the child is a separate household.

Likewise, an adult child with no income may be financially dependent upon the parent even though the child is not claimed as a tax dependent.

The amount and regularity of financial contributions should be documented.

6. Adult Children Who Pay Rent

A child who pays rent to a parent may occupy either of two different financial positions.

The arrangement may resemble an ordinary landlord-tenant relationship, with the child maintaining independent finances.

Alternatively, the payment may be an informal contribution toward a shared family household.

Relevant considerations include whether the payment reflects market rent, whether food and utilities are shared, whether the parent provides additional support, and whether the parties maintain separate financial arrangements.

The label placed on the payment is not necessarily controlling.

A payment described as rent may function economically as a household contribution.

Conversely, an adult child who pays a fixed amount for a separate living area and otherwise maintains independent finances may not function as part of the same economic unit.

7. Elderly Parents and Other Relatives

A debtor may provide housing and financial support to an elderly parent, disabled relative, sibling, grandchild, or other family member.

These arrangements can support inclusion in household size where the facts establish an integrated economic unit.

For example, a debtor who houses an elderly parent, purchases groceries, pays utilities, and provides transportation may have a larger household than the debtor's tax return suggests.

But the parent's own income and contributions may also be relevant.

A parent receiving Social Security benefits who contributes toward shared expenses may still be part of the economic unit.

The classification of Social Security benefits for current-monthly-income purposes is a separate question from whether the recipient belongs to the household.

8. Married Debtors Living Together

A married couple residing together ordinarily presents a household of at least two.

If they have children or other qualifying household members, the household may be larger.

However, whether one spouse files alone or both spouses file jointly can affect the means-test income calculation.

The income of a nonfiling spouse may need to be included, subject to the applicable rules governing marital adjustments and contributions toward household expenses.

Household size and income inclusion are related but distinct questions.

A spouse's presence in the household does not mean every dollar of that spouse's income is necessarily treated identically for every bankruptcy calculation.

9. Married but Separated Spouses

Separation creates additional complications.

Some spouses live at different addresses and maintain independent finances. Others remain under the same roof because neither can afford separate housing.

A couple may be legally separated, informally separated, or involved in divorce proceedings.

The legal status of the marriage does not by itself resolve household size.

A debtor who lives separately from a spouse may have a different household composition from a debtor who remains in a shared residence with the spouse.

The means-test forms also distinguish certain circumstances involving spouses who are legally separated or living separately.

The precise treatment of income and expenses requires review of the statutory provisions, official forms, and actual financial arrangements.

10. Divorced Spouses Who Continue Living Together

A divorce does not necessarily result in separate residences.

Former spouses may continue living in the same house because of financial necessity, unresolved property issues, or arrangements concerning children.

They may share a kitchen, laundry facilities, utilities, and mortgage payments while maintaining separate bedrooms and personal finances.

The fact that they are divorced does not automatically establish that they constitute separate economic units.

Conversely, continued residence in the same property does not necessarily establish a single bankruptcy household.

The actual financial relationship is critical.

Example: Former spouses sharing a home

A debtor and former spouse remain joint owners of their residence after divorce.

Each pays half the mortgage. They share utility costs but purchase groceries separately and maintain separate bank accounts.

They occupy different portions of the house.

Whether they form one economic unit requires examining the extent of shared expenses, financial dependency, and household integration.

The answer may differ from a case in which one former spouse pays nearly all expenses and supports the other.

11. Roommates and Unrelated Adults

Sharing a residence does not automatically make unrelated adults members of the same bankruptcy household.

Roommates may divide rent and utilities while maintaining entirely separate finances.

A debtor renting a room to an unrelated individual may have rental income or household contributions that require disclosure, but that does not necessarily establish that the tenant should be counted as a household member.

Conversely, unrelated individuals may function as an integrated economic unit when they share finances and support one another.

The inquiry should focus on economic reality rather than family relationship alone.

12. Children Who Divide Their Time Between Households

Shared custody and other arrangements involving children who reside in more than one household present difficult questions.

A child may spend weekdays with one parent and weekends with another, or divide time approximately equally.

The debtor may pay substantial expenses for the child even when the child is not present every day.

Courts applying the economic-unit approach may consider the amount of time the child resides with the debtor and the extent of financial support.

The appropriate treatment is fact-specific.

A debtor should not automatically exclude a child merely because the child also resides with another parent.

Nor should the debtor assume that every child for whom support is paid must be counted as a full household member.

Johnson approved a fact-based household calculation that accounted for children who lived with the debtor only part of the time. The decision permits attention to the actual economic unit rather than mechanically counting every child as a full-time resident; it does not authorize a debtor to choose whichever household count produces the best result.

13. Household Contributions and Current Monthly Income

The Bankruptcy Code's definition of current monthly income generally includes amounts regularly paid by another person toward the household expenses of the debtor or the debtor's dependents, subject to statutory rules.

This can create an important interaction between household size and income.

Suppose an adult child contributes $600 each month toward household expenses.

That contribution may be relevant to the debtor's current-monthly-income calculation even if the child is not counted as a household member.

Similarly, an adult child's membership in the economic unit does not automatically mean the child's entire income must be included in the debtor's means test.

The amount actually and regularly contributed toward qualifying household expenses may be the relevant measure.

A household-size analysis should therefore be accompanied by an accurate examination of financial contributions.

14. Household Size and Expense Deductions

Household size can affect standardized allowances for food, clothing, and other living expenses.

Housing and utility allowances may depend on household composition and geographic location.

However, not every expense is determined solely by the number of household members.

Some deductions depend on actual payments, statutory limitations, or other factors.

The means test should not be manipulated by including household members for the purpose of increasing allowances while disregarding relevant household contributions.

Consistency between the household description, income disclosures, and expense calculations is important.

15. How Household Size Affects Schedule J

Schedule J reports the debtor's current monthly expenses.

Its purpose differs from the means test, which employs a historical income calculation and specified standardized deductions.

Schedule J ordinarily concerns the debtor's actual and anticipated household expenses.

A debtor may have legitimate expenses supporting adult children or other relatives even when those individuals' treatment under the means test requires additional analysis.

Conversely, expenses paid by other household members should not automatically be attributed entirely to the debtor.

The figures reported on Schedule J should reflect the actual financial arrangement and comply with the official form's instructions.

Differences between Schedule J and the means-test forms may be appropriate, but they should be explainable.

16. Evidence That May Be Important

A household-size determination may require more than a statement identifying who lives at the residence.

Relevant evidence can include household expense records, bank statements, utility bills, grocery expenditures, rent contributions, employment information, and documentation of financial support.

Tax returns may be relevant, although they do not necessarily control.

The debtor should be prepared to explain who pays the mortgage or rent, who purchases food, whether household members share transportation, and how expenses are allocated.

In cases involving adult children or relatives, a clear explanation of the financial arrangement can be particularly important.

17. Can Household Size Change Before Filing?

Yes.

A child may leave home, a relative may move in, spouses may separate, or a household member may begin contributing toward expenses.

The appropriate household size ordinarily must reflect the relevant circumstances under the applicable law and forms.

A debtor should not artificially alter living arrangements solely to create a misleading means-test result.

However, genuine changes in household composition may properly affect bankruptcy eligibility.

The filing date, current living arrangements, and reasonably anticipated changes should all be considered.

18. Why Household Size Should Be Evaluated Before Choosing a Bankruptcy Chapter

Household size can determine whether a debtor falls below the Maryland median-income threshold.

For above-median debtors, it can affect allowable expenses and the resulting means-test calculation.

In Chapter 13, household composition may also influence projected disposable income and the feasibility of a proposed repayment plan.

Consequently, a debtor with adult children, dependent relatives, shared custody arrangements, or unusual living circumstances should not assume that household size is self-evident.

A careful analysis may materially change the debtor's available options.

Conclusion

Household size in bankruptcy is not always determined by counting bedrooms, reviewing a tax return, or identifying everyone who receives mail at the debtor's address.

In Maryland, the Fourth Circuit's economic-unit approach provides important guidance by focusing on how individuals actually function together financially.

Adult children, elderly parents, former spouses, and unrelated residents may present very different circumstances.

The relevant questions concern residence, financial support, shared expenses, economic integration, and the requirements of the particular bankruptcy calculation.

A properly supported household-size determination can make a significant difference in whether a debtor qualifies for Chapter 7 and how household expenses are treated.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes

  • 11 U.S.C. § 101(10A) — Definition of current monthly income, including certain household contributions.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 707(b) — Chapter 7 means testing and abuse analysis.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1325(b) — Disposable-income requirements in Chapter 13.

Official forms and administrative materials

  • United States Trustee Program — Means Testing — State median-income figures and expense standards.
  • United States Courts — Bankruptcy Forms — Official Forms 122A-1, 122A-2, and Schedules I and J.

Selected decisions

  • Johnson v. Zimmer, 686 F.3d 224 (4th Cir. 2012) — Adopts the economic-unit approach to household size in a Chapter 13 means-test context.
  • In re Robinson, 449 B.R. 473 (Bankr. E.D. Va. 2011) — Discusses household-size approaches and economic interdependence.
  • In re Morrison, 443 B.R. 378 (Bankr. M.D.N.C. 2011) — Examines household size and the treatment of children residing in more than one household.
  • Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010) — Addresses consideration of known or virtually certain financial changes in calculating projected disposable income in Chapter 13.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm