Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Chapter 13 Plan Confirmation in Maryland: Trustee Objections, Creditor Objections, Feasibility, Good Faith, and the Confirmation Hearing

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Filing Chapter 13 Does Not Mean the Repayment Plan Has Been Approved

A Chapter 13 debtor ordinarily files a proposed repayment plan shortly after commencing the bankruptcy case. But filing the plan does not mean that the bankruptcy court has approved it.

Before confirmation, the Chapter 13 trustee and creditors have opportunities to examine the debtor's financial circumstances, evaluate the proposed treatment of claims, and object to provisions that do not comply with the Bankruptcy Code.

The bankruptcy court must determine whether the plan satisfies the requirements of 11 U.S.C. §§ 1322 and 1325.

A plan may be rejected because it fails to provide sufficient payments to creditors, improperly treats a secured claim, does not account for priority debts, or depends on income the debtor is unlikely to receive.

Other objections concern good faith, the value of nonexempt property, or whether the debtor has accurately disclosed financial information.

Many objections are resolved through amendments and negotiations rather than a contested evidentiary hearing.

The debtor's objective is not simply to obtain confirmation. It is to obtain confirmation of a plan that can realistically be completed.

1. What Is Confirmation?

Confirmation is the bankruptcy court's approval of the proposed Chapter 13 plan.

Section 1325 establishes the principal confirmation requirements.

The court must determine that the plan complies with applicable provisions of the Bankruptcy Code and satisfies the statutory standards.

Once confirmed, the plan generally binds the debtor and creditors under § 1327(a), subject to applicable law.

Confirmation is therefore a significant legal event.

It establishes the framework governing payments and treatment of claims during the plan.

2. Filing the Proposed Plan

Under § 1321, the debtor must file a Chapter 13 plan.

Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 3015 generally requires filing within fourteen days after the petition unless the court grants an extension.

The District of Maryland has local requirements concerning the form and content of Chapter 13 plans.

The debtor should use the applicable local plan form and comply with current filing and service requirements.

Maryland Local Bankruptcy Rule 3015-1 requires a plan conforming to Local Bankruptcy Form M, signed by the debtor, and a certificate of service using Form M-1. Plan provisions seeking valuation or lien avoidance require the additional evidence and service specified in that rule; ordinary mailing of the plan does not replace the required service on the affected lienholder.

An incomplete or improperly prepared plan may produce objections or delay confirmation.

3. Plan Payments Begin Before Confirmation

A common misunderstanding is that payments do not begin until the bankruptcy court approves the plan.

Under § 1326(a)(1), the debtor generally must begin making required payments within thirty days after filing the plan or the order for relief, whichever is earlier, unless the court orders otherwise.

The debtor should not wait for confirmation.

Payments made before confirmation generally are held or distributed according to the applicable statutory provisions.

Failure to commence payments can jeopardize the case.

4. The Chapter 13 Trustee

The Chapter 13 trustee reviews the debtor's schedules, income, expenses, assets, debts, and proposed plan.

The trustee evaluates whether the plan satisfies applicable confirmation requirements.

The trustee may request additional documents or explanations.

The trustee also monitors payments and administers distributions under confirmed plans.

In Maryland, the standing Chapter 13 trustee's procedures and applicable local requirements should be reviewed.

The trustee's recommendation or objection can materially affect the confirmation process.

5. The Meeting of Creditors

Under § 341, the debtor ordinarily must attend a meeting of creditors.

The trustee may examine the debtor under oath concerning income, expenses, assets, debts, transfers, and the proposed repayment plan.

Creditors may also ask appropriate questions.

The meeting is not itself confirmation.

However, information obtained at the meeting may lead to objections or requests for amendments.

The debtor should provide accurate testimony and requested documentation.

6. Trustee Objections

The Chapter 13 trustee may object to confirmation for several reasons.

Common objections include insufficient projected disposable income, inaccurate expenses, inadequate treatment of priority claims, failure to satisfy the liquidation test, and lack of feasibility.

The trustee may also question the debtor's household size, income calculation, property valuations, or claimed exemptions.

An objection does not necessarily mean the case will be dismissed.

Many objections identify issues that can be corrected through additional evidence or plan amendments.

7. Creditor Objections

Creditors may object when they believe the proposed plan improperly affects their rights.

A mortgage lender may dispute the stated arrearage.

An automobile lender may challenge collateral valuation or interest.

An unsecured creditor may argue that the debtor has failed to commit required disposable income.

A creditor may also raise good-faith or other confirmation issues.

The objection must be evaluated under the applicable statutory provisions.

A creditor's dissatisfaction with the proposed repayment percentage does not automatically establish a valid objection.

8. The Good-Faith Requirement

Section 1325(a)(3) requires that the plan be proposed in good faith and not by any means forbidden by law.

Section 1325(a)(7) separately addresses whether the debtor filed the petition in good faith.

The inquiry is fact-specific.

Courts may consider the debtor's financial disclosures, conduct, proposed treatment of creditors, and overall circumstances.

A low repayment percentage does not automatically establish bad faith.

Nor does the debtor's lawful use of statutory exemptions or expense allowances necessarily establish misconduct.

9. Fourth Circuit Good-Faith Decisions

In Deans v. O'Donnell, 692 F.2d 968 (4th Cir. 1982), the Fourth Circuit addressed good faith in Chapter 13 confirmation and rejected a rigid minimum-payment requirement.

In Neufeld v. Freeman, 794 F.2d 149 (4th Cir. 1986), the court addressed the relevance of the debtor's prepetition conduct and the dischargeability of particular obligations.

These decisions remain important to the development of Chapter 13 good-faith analysis.

However, both predate substantial statutory amendments.

Their application must be considered alongside current §§ 1325(a)(3), 1325(a)(7), and 1325(b).

10. Feasibility

Section 1325(a)(6) requires the court to determine that the debtor will be able to make all payments under the plan and comply with it.

This is the feasibility requirement.

A debtor may propose a mathematically sufficient plan but lack the income necessary to fund it.

For example, a plan may require $1,600 monthly while the debtor's actual household budget leaves only $900 available.

Unless the discrepancy can be explained or corrected, the plan may not be feasible.

The court must consider whether the proposed payments are realistically sustainable.

11. Projected Disposable Income

Section 1325(b) becomes particularly important when the trustee or an allowed unsecured creditor objects to confirmation.

The debtor generally must satisfy the applicable projected disposable-income requirement unless unsecured claims are paid in full.

For above-median debtors, statutory expense standards may apply.

For below-median debtors, actual reasonably necessary expenses generally play a greater role.

The Supreme Court addressed projected disposable income in Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010).

The calculation may account for known or virtually certain changes in financial circumstances.

12. The Liquidation Test

Section 1325(a)(4) requires general unsecured creditors to receive at least the value they would receive in a hypothetical Chapter 7 liquidation.

This is the best-interests-of-creditors test.

The debtor's nonexempt property value may therefore affect the plan.

For example, a debtor may have substantial nonexempt equity in real estate.

Even if projected disposable income is modest, the plan may need to provide unsecured creditors with the required liquidation value.

The trustee may object when property is undervalued or exemptions are improperly claimed.

13. Property Valuation Disputes

The trustee or a creditor may challenge the debtor's valuation of real estate, vehicles, business interests, or other assets.

The valuation may affect secured claim treatment or the liquidation test.

Evidence may include appraisals, comparable sales, account statements, and other reliable information.

A debtor should not assign arbitrary values merely to make the proposed plan affordable.

The relevant valuation standard depends on the statutory issue.

14. Secured Claim Objections

A secured creditor may object to the proposed treatment of its claim.

The dispute may involve collateral value, interest, maturity, arrears, or other contractual rights.

Section 1325(a)(5) establishes requirements concerning allowed secured claims.

A plan may need amendment to satisfy the statute.

The debtor should distinguish disputes concerning claim amount from disputes concerning plan treatment.

15. Mortgage Arrearage Disputes

A mortgage lender may file a proof of claim identifying prepetition arrears.

The debtor may disagree with the amount.

The discrepancy may involve missed payments, escrow advances, fees, or other charges.

The debtor should review the proof of claim and supporting documents.

A plan that understates the required cure amount may not provide the relief the debtor expects.

Mortgage claim procedures under Rule 3002.1 may also become important during plan performance.

16. Automobile Loan Objections

Vehicle lenders may challenge proposed collateral values, interest rates, or treatment under the 910-day provision.

The debtor should determine whether the purchase-money restriction applies.

If modification is permitted, the plan must still satisfy applicable secured-claim requirements.

The Supreme Court's decisions in Till v. SCS Credit Corp., 541 U.S. 465 (2004), and Associates Commercial Corp. v. Rash, 520 U.S. 953 (1997), provide important guidance concerning interest and valuation.

17. Priority Claim Objections

Certain debts receive priority under § 507.

The plan generally must provide required treatment for qualifying priority claims.

Examples include domestic support obligations and certain taxes.

The trustee may object if the plan fails to account for these obligations.

A debtor should determine whether the claim is actually entitled to priority rather than accepting the creditor's designation without review.

Confirmation also requires payment of domestic support obligations first becoming payable after the petition as specified in § 1325(a)(8), and filing of applicable tax returns under §§ 1308 and 1325(a)(9). These are independent conditions, not simply matters of including arrears in the payment calculation.

18. Attorney's Fees and Administrative Expenses

Chapter 13 attorney's fees and other administrative expenses may be paid through the plan, subject to applicable procedures.

The plan must provide sufficient funding.

The debtor should distinguish fees paid before filing from amounts remaining payable through the trustee.

The court may review professional compensation under applicable provisions.

Unaccounted administrative expenses can make a plan underfunded.

19. Objections Based on Household Expenses

A trustee may question expenses that appear excessive, inconsistent, or unsupported.

The applicable legal standard depends on whether the debtor is above or below median income and the particular expense category.

For above-median debtors, certain IRS standardized allowances may apply even when actual expenditures are lower.

The Fourth Circuit's decision in Lynch v. Jackson, 853 F.3d 116 (4th Cir. 2017), is important in this regard.

However, Schedule J must accurately report actual or reasonably anticipated expenses.

A debtor should not confuse the standardized means-test calculation with the household budget.

20. Amending the Plan

A debtor may amend a proposed Chapter 13 plan before confirmation, subject to applicable rules.

Amendments may address trustee objections, creditor claims, or changes in financial circumstances.

For example, the debtor may need to increase payments to satisfy the liquidation test or adjust treatment of a secured claim.

Amended plans may require notice and an opportunity for objection.

The debtor should not assume that a revised payment becomes effective without complying with the required procedures.

21. Negotiating Objections

Many confirmation objections can be resolved without contested evidentiary hearings.

Counsel may provide additional documentation, correct calculations, amend the plan, or negotiate claim treatment.

However, an agreement with one creditor does not necessarily resolve all statutory requirements.

The court must still determine whether confirmation is appropriate.

The debtor should understand any changes to the payment amount or plan obligations.

22. The Confirmation Hearing

The bankruptcy court considers whether the plan satisfies the applicable confirmation requirements.

Some cases may proceed through streamlined or uncontested procedures under local practice.

Contested matters may require argument or evidence.

The debtor may need to testify when factual disputes remain.

The court may confirm the plan, continue the matter, require amendments, or deny confirmation.

The applicable Maryland procedures should be reviewed before the hearing.

Under Maryland Local Bankruptcy Rule 3015-2, the debtor and counsel must attend scheduled confirmation hearings unless excused by the trustee or court. The rule sets confirmation hearings at least 35 days after filing the plan, ordinarily requires objections no later than seven days before the hearing, and requires the Form O pre-confirmation certificate within the seven days before the initial hearing and an updated certificate before a continued hearing. Read these provisions together with the actual notice and applicable federal timing rules.

23. What Happens If Confirmation Is Denied?

Denial of confirmation does not necessarily require immediate dismissal.

The debtor may be permitted to file an amended plan.

However, § 1307(c)(5) identifies denial of confirmation and denial of a request for additional time to file another plan as potential cause for dismissal or conversion.

Repeated inability to propose a confirmable plan can jeopardize the case.

The debtor should address objections promptly.

24. The Binding Effect of Confirmation

Section 1327(a) generally provides that the confirmed plan binds the debtor and creditors.

This can be significant when a creditor received proper notice but failed to object.

However, confirmation does not eliminate every independent statutory requirement.

The Supreme Court's decision in United Student Aid Funds, Inc. v. Espinosa, 559 U.S. 260 (2010), illustrates the importance of finality while recognizing procedural and statutory limitations.

The effect of confirmation depends on the plan language, notice, and governing law.

25. Confirmation Does Not Guarantee Completion

A confirmed plan may last three to five years.

The debtor must continue making required payments and complying with other obligations.

Job loss, illness, increased expenses, or other changes may threaten completion.

The debtor may seek modification under § 1329 when appropriate.

Confirmation is an important milestone, but successful completion requires continued performance.

26. Why Confirmation Preparation Begins Before Filing

The best opportunity to obtain confirmation often arises before the petition is filed.

Counsel should identify secured claims, priority debts, nonexempt property, actual expenses, and available income.

The debtor should understand the proposed payment and the obligations that must be maintained outside the plan.

A realistic initial plan may reduce objections, amendments, and delays.

The objective is to obtain a plan that satisfies the Bankruptcy Code and can be completed.

Conclusion

Chapter 13 confirmation is the process through which the bankruptcy court determines whether the debtor's proposed repayment plan complies with federal law.

The trustee and creditors may object concerning disposable income, feasibility, good faith, secured claims, priority obligations, or liquidation value.

Many objections can be resolved through documentation and amendments.

But a debtor cannot obtain confirmation merely by proposing a payment that appears affordable.

The plan must satisfy statutory requirements and provide a realistic path to completion.

A successful Chapter 13 case begins with a confirmable plan, but it ends only when the debtor fulfills the required obligations and receives a discharge.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes and rules

  • 11 U.S.C. § 1321 — Filing the Chapter 13 plan.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1322 — Plan contents.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1325 — Confirmation requirements.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1326 — Payments.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1327 — Binding effect of confirmation.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1329 — Postconfirmation modification.
  • Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 3015 — Chapter 13 plans.
  • Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 3015.1 — Local Chapter 13 plan forms.

Selected decisions

  • Deans v. O'Donnell, 692 F.2d 968 (4th Cir. 1982) — Addresses Chapter 13 good faith and rejects a rigid minimum-payment requirement.
  • Neufeld v. Freeman, 794 F.2d 149 (4th Cir. 1986) — Addresses prepetition conduct and Chapter 13 good faith.
  • Hamilton v. Lanning, 560 U.S. 505 (2010) — Addresses projected disposable income.
  • Lynch v. Jackson, 853 F.3d 116 (4th Cir. 2017) — Addresses IRS standardized expense allowances.
  • Till v. SCS Credit Corp., 541 U.S. 465 (2004) — Addresses interest rates on secured claims.
  • Associates Commercial Corp. v. Rash, 520 U.S. 953 (1997) — Addresses collateral valuation.
  • United Student Aid Funds, Inc. v. Espinosa, 559 U.S. 260 (2010) — Addresses the binding effect of confirmed plans and procedural defects.

Maryland practice authorities

– United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Maryland — Local Rules, Chapter 13 plan forms, and filing procedures.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm