Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Student Loans in Bankruptcy: Undue Hardship, Parent PLUS Loans, Private Loans, and the Possibility of Discharge

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Student Loan Debt and Dischargeability

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Student Loans Are Difficult to Discharge, but They Are Not Immune From Bankruptcy

One of the most persistent misconceptions about bankruptcy is that student loans can never be discharged.

That is incorrect.

Section 523(a)(8) of the Bankruptcy Code excepts certain educational debts from discharge unless requiring repayment would impose an undue hardship on the debtor and the debtor's dependents.

The statute does not make every debt associated with education nondischargeable. Nor does it prohibit a bankruptcy court from discharging qualifying student loans when undue hardship is established.

For many years, student loan discharge litigation was regarded as particularly difficult, expensive, and unpredictable.

In 2022, the United States Department of Justice and Department of Education introduced a coordinated process intended to simplify the handling of federal student loan undue-hardship proceedings.

That process did not change the statute or eliminate the requirement for judicial relief. It did, however, create a more structured method for evaluating a debtor's financial circumstances and determining whether the government should stipulate to relevant facts or recommend discharge.

For Maryland debtors, the analysis must also account for Fourth Circuit precedent, including the demanding undue-hardship standard established in Educational Credit Management Corp. v. Frushour, 433 F.3d 393 (4th Cir. 2005).

1. What Does § 523(a)(8) Actually Say?

Section 523(a)(8) generally excepts three categories of educational obligations from discharge unless undue hardship is established.

The categories include certain educational benefit overpayments and loans made, insured, or guaranteed by governmental units or qualifying nonprofit institutions; obligations to repay funds received as educational benefits, scholarships, or stipends; and certain qualified education loans as defined by federal tax law.

These categories are not identical.

A debt may fall outside § 523(a)(8) even though the borrower used the proceeds to pay educational expenses.

Conversely, a qualifying educational loan may remain nondischargeable even when it was made by a private lender.

The creditor must establish that the obligation falls within the applicable statutory category.

If it does, the debtor ordinarily must establish undue hardship to obtain discharge.

2. Federal Student Loans

Federal Direct Loans and other qualifying federally backed educational loans ordinarily fall within § 523(a)(8).

These loans generally survive an ordinary Chapter 7 discharge unless the debtor obtains an undue-hardship determination.

A debtor should not assume that listing the loans in the bankruptcy schedules is sufficient to discharge them.

Nor does the entry of a general discharge order necessarily establish that the student loans were eliminated.

A separate adversary proceeding ordinarily is required to obtain an undue-hardship determination.

3. Parent PLUS Loans

Parent PLUS loans are federal educational loans incurred by qualifying parents to finance a child's education.

The parent borrower is generally personally responsible for repayment.

The student does not ordinarily become personally liable merely because the loan financed the student's education.

A Parent PLUS loan generally falls within § 523(a)(8).

The parent may seek an undue-hardship discharge in bankruptcy, but must satisfy the applicable legal requirements.

The fact that the parent is retired, disabled, or living on fixed income may be relevant, but does not automatically establish undue hardship.

4. Parent PLUS Loans and Divorce

Parent PLUS loans can create complicated obligations following divorce.

A marital settlement agreement may require former spouses to share repayment of a loan legally owed to only one parent.

That agreement ordinarily does not release the named borrower from liability to the federal government.

It may, however, create a separate obligation between the former spouses.

The dischargeability of that divorce-related obligation must be distinguished from the dischargeability of the Parent PLUS loan itself.

For example, § 523(a)(15) may affect a reimbursement obligation owed to a former spouse in Chapter 7, even though the underlying federal loan remains governed by § 523(a)(8).

5. Private Student Loans

Private educational loans require careful classification.

Some qualify as nondischargeable educational loans under § 523(a)(8)(B).

Others may fall outside the statute.

A private lender cannot establish nondischargeability merely by labeling an obligation a student loan.

The legal inquiry may involve whether the loan was incurred solely to pay qualified higher education expenses, whether the educational institution was eligible under applicable federal law, and whether other statutory requirements were satisfied.

The loan documents, school records, and disbursement history may be important.

A private loan may also fall within § 523(a)(8)(A)(i) if made under a program funded in whole or in part by a governmental unit or nonprofit institution. Failure to meet the qualified-education-loan definition in subsection (B) therefore does not, by itself, establish dischargeability; every potentially applicable statutory category must be checked.

6. Loans Exceeding Qualified Educational Expenses

A private loan may exceed the borrower's qualifying educational expenses.

That circumstance may affect whether the loan satisfies the statutory definition of a qualified education loan.

However, the analysis is not necessarily resolved simply by comparing the loan amount with tuition.

Qualified higher education expenses may include specified costs of attendance beyond tuition.

The relevant tax-law definitions and statutory requirements must be applied.

A debtor should not assume that every private educational loan is nondischargeable or that every loan exceeding tuition is dischargeable.

7. Bar Examination Loans and Other Educational Financing

Some lenders offer loans to finance bar examination preparation, professional licensing expenses, relocation, or other costs associated with entering a profession.

These obligations may not necessarily satisfy the definition of a qualified education loan.

The analysis depends on the purpose of the loan, the expenses financed, and the applicable statutory category.

For example, a loan used solely to pay living expenses after graduation while studying for a licensing examination may present different issues from a qualifying loan used for educational expenses during enrollment.

The creditor must establish the applicable basis for nondischargeability.

8. The Undue-Hardship Exception

Section 523(a)(8) permits discharge when excepting the educational debt from discharge would impose an undue hardship on the debtor and the debtor's dependents.

Congress did not provide a detailed statutory definition of undue hardship.

Courts therefore developed standards for evaluating the debtor's circumstances.

The Fourth Circuit generally applies the three-part test originating in Brunner v. New York State Higher Education Services Corp., 831 F.2d 395 (2d Cir. 1987).

The debtor must establish all three elements.

9. The First Brunner Requirement: Minimal Standard of Living

The debtor must establish that, based on current income and expenses, repayment would prevent maintenance of a minimal standard of living for the debtor and dependents.

This does not mean that the debtor must be completely destitute.

However, courts examine whether the debtor can meet basic living expenses while making required payments.

Relevant expenses may include housing, food, utilities, transportation, medical care, and other reasonable necessities.

The court may scrutinize expenses considered excessive or insufficiently supported.

The debtor should provide a realistic budget rather than relying solely on generalized assertions of financial hardship.

10. The Second Brunner Requirement: Persistence of Financial Hardship

The debtor must establish additional circumstances indicating that the inability to repay is likely to persist for a significant portion of the repayment period.

This requirement can be particularly difficult.

Courts may examine age, employment history, earning capacity, education, disability, medical limitations, and other circumstances.

A temporary reduction in income may not be sufficient.

But a debtor whose earning capacity is permanently or substantially limited may present stronger evidence.

The analysis should be supported by objective facts when available.

11. The Third Brunner Requirement: Good-Faith Efforts to Repay

The debtor must demonstrate good-faith efforts to repay the loans.

Courts may consider payment history, employment efforts, budgeting, communications with the loan servicer, and attempts to obtain available repayment relief.

The analysis is not necessarily limited to the total amount paid.

A debtor with very limited resources may have been unable to make substantial payments despite genuine efforts.

The court must evaluate the debtor's circumstances.

However, voluntary decisions that unnecessarily reduce income or increase expenses may affect the good-faith analysis.

12. The Fourth Circuit's Decision in Frushour

In Educational Credit Management Corp. v. Frushour, 433 F.3d 393 (4th Cir. 2005), the Fourth Circuit applied the Brunner standard and emphasized the demanding nature of undue-hardship relief.

The court rejected discharge under the circumstances presented.

The decision remains an important authority for Maryland bankruptcy proceedings.

A debtor seeking discharge should not assume that financial difficulty alone satisfies the test.

The evidence must address present hardship, likely persistence, and good-faith repayment efforts.

The Department of Justice's later administrative guidance does not overrule Frushour or replace the governing judicial standard.

13. The Department of Justice's Streamlined Student Loan Discharge Process

In November 2022, the Department of Justice and Department of Education announced a coordinated process for handling undue-hardship cases involving federal student loans.

The process is designed to improve consistency, reduce unnecessary litigation, and permit government attorneys to recommend discharge when the evidence supports the statutory standard.

A debtor generally provides financial information through an attestation addressing income, expenses, assets, repayment history, and circumstances affecting future ability to repay.

Government attorneys evaluate that information under the applicable guidance.

The process can lead to stipulations and a recommended discharge, but it does not guarantee that the government will agree.

The bankruptcy court retains responsibility for entering the appropriate judgment.

14. The Attestation Process

The attestation is intended to provide a standardized presentation of the debtor's financial circumstances.

Information may include household composition, income, necessary living expenses, assets, employment history, and factors affecting future earning capacity.

The debtor may also provide information concerning repayment efforts and available loan programs.

The supporting documentation should be accurate and consistent with the bankruptcy schedules.

A debtor should not exaggerate expenses, omit income, or assume that the attestation substitutes for truthful testimony and disclosure.

The government may request additional information when necessary.

15. Is a Trial Always Necessary?

No.

An adversary proceeding may be resolved through stipulations, agreement, or other appropriate procedures when the parties establish a sufficient basis for relief.

The streamlined federal process may reduce the need for extensive discovery and contested trial proceedings.

However, a debtor should not assume that filing an attestation automatically produces discharge.

If the government contests the claim, the debtor may need to prove undue hardship through ordinary litigation.

The bankruptcy court ultimately determines the relief available.

16. How an Adversary Proceeding Begins

Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7001 requires an adversary proceeding for a determination of dischargeability.

The debtor ordinarily files a complaint in the bankruptcy court naming the appropriate defendant or defendants.

The complaint should identify the loans, their legal character, and the factual basis for undue hardship.

Service must comply with Rule 7004 and other applicable requirements.

In federal student loan cases, counsel should determine the appropriate governmental parties and service procedures.

The filing of the bankruptcy petition alone does not commence the adversary proceeding.

17. When Should the Adversary Proceeding Be Filed?

An undue-hardship complaint may be filed during the bankruptcy case.

Unlike certain creditor complaints under § 523(c), the ordinary sixty-day deadline under Rule 4007(c) does not govern a debtor's undue-hardship determination under § 523(a)(8).

Rule 4007(b) generally permits complaints concerning debts outside § 523(c) to be filed at any time.

A closed bankruptcy case may be reopened when appropriate to obtain a dischargeability determination.

The debtor should nevertheless consider timing, available evidence, and the practical benefits of prompt action.

18. Can a Closed Chapter 7 Case Be Reopened?

Yes.

Under § 350(b), a bankruptcy court may reopen a case to provide relief to the debtor or for other cause.

A debtor who previously received a Chapter 7 discharge but did not pursue student loan relief may seek to reopen the case and commence an appropriate adversary proceeding.

Reopening does not itself discharge the student loans.

The debtor must establish the statutory basis for relief.

The availability of evidence concerning the debtor's current and anticipated financial circumstances may affect the litigation.

19. What If the Debtor Is Retired?

Retirement can be important in an undue-hardship analysis.

A debtor who has reached retirement age may have limited prospects for increasing income.

However, retirement does not automatically establish undue hardship.

The court may examine the debtor's financial resources, employment prospects, expenses, assets, and repayment obligations.

A debtor who voluntarily retired while retaining substantial earning capacity may present different circumstances from one whose age or health materially limits employment.

The inquiry remains individualized.

20. Disability and Medical Limitations

A debtor with a significant disability or chronic medical condition may have evidence supporting persistent inability to repay.

Medical records, disability determinations, employment history, and functional limitations may be relevant.

But a disability determination under another federal program does not automatically satisfy the Brunner test.

The debtor's actual financial circumstances and future earning capacity must be evaluated.

Federal student loan administrative discharge programs based on total and permanent disability may also provide relief outside bankruptcy.

Those programs should be considered separately.

21. Income-Driven Repayment Plans

Federal student loan borrowers may have access to income-driven repayment arrangements, subject to current program requirements.

The availability and terms of such plans have changed over time and may be affected by litigation or regulatory developments.

Under the Brunner good-faith analysis, courts may consider the debtor's efforts to investigate or participate in available repayment programs.

However, the availability of a reduced-payment plan does not necessarily establish that repayment would impose no undue hardship.

A debtor may face circumstances in which even reduced payments are unaffordable or the financial burden remains significant.

The current program rules should be verified rather than relying on outdated repayment-plan descriptions.

22. Does a Zero-Dollar Payment Defeat Undue Hardship?

Not automatically.

A borrower may qualify for a zero-dollar monthly payment under an applicable income-driven repayment arrangement.

That fact may be relevant to the undue-hardship analysis, but it does not necessarily resolve the question.

The court may consider the debtor's overall circumstances, anticipated repayment obligations, duration of hardship, and good-faith efforts.

The result depends on controlling law and the facts.

23. Partial Discharge and Other Relief

Courts have considered whether relief may be granted concerning only part of an educational obligation or through other appropriate mechanisms.

The availability of partial discharge or modification depends on governing law and the statutory framework.

A debtor should not assume that the only possible outcomes are complete discharge of every loan or denial of all relief.

However, any proposed partial relief must be supported by applicable precedent and the court's authority.

The Fourth Circuit's treatment of partial discharge requires particular attention.

Any partial discharge must rest on the undue-hardship requirement and applicable judicial authority; general equitable power is not a substitute for § 523(a)(8). DOJ guidance permits a government recommendation of partial relief in appropriate cases, but the recommendation neither binds the court nor displaces Fourth Circuit precedent.

24. Chapter 7 Versus Chapter 13

Student loan obligations generally receive similar undue-hardship treatment under § 523(a)(8) in both chapters.

Chapter 7 ordinarily permits prompt discharge of other qualifying unsecured debts.

Chapter 13 may permit repayment through a plan, but the student loan balance may remain after plan completion unless discharged through an undue-hardship determination or other applicable relief.

Interest and repayment-program consequences can affect the remaining balance.

The debtor should not assume that completing a Chapter 13 plan automatically eliminates student loans.

25. Student Loan Payments During Chapter 13

A Chapter 13 plan may provide for treatment of student loan claims under applicable provisions.

However, separate classification and payment of student loans can raise unfair-discrimination and confirmation issues.

The debtor generally cannot simply prefer student loan creditors over other unsecured creditors without satisfying the Bankruptcy Code.

The treatment of long-term obligations may also implicate § 1322(b)(5).

Plan drafting requires careful consideration of the debtor's objectives and applicable case law.

26. Student Loan Consolidation and Refinancing

Federal consolidation and private refinancing can change the legal and practical characteristics of educational debt.

A debtor should consider whether refinancing sacrifices federal repayment protections, administrative discharge options, or other benefits.

The bankruptcy classification of a refinanced obligation depends on the governing documents and applicable statutory provisions.

The debtor should not assume that replacing a federal student loan with a private loan automatically makes it dischargeable.

The transaction's legal character must be examined.

27. Student Loans and Tax Consequences

Student loan forgiveness or discharge may have federal or state tax consequences depending on the applicable law and tax year.

Certain exclusions from cancellation-of-debt income may apply.

The tax treatment of an administrative loan discharge may differ from other forms of forgiveness.

The debtor should obtain current tax advice rather than assuming that every forgiven student loan creates taxable income or that every discharge is tax-free.

A qualifying discharge granted in a Title 11 case is excluded from federal cancellation-of-debt income under § 108(a)(1)(A), subject to the statute’s requirements and tax-attribute rules. That bankruptcy exclusion is separate from temporary or program-specific exclusions governing administrative student loan forgiveness.

28. Why the Student Loan Documents Matter

A debtor seeking discharge should obtain a complete loan history.

Relevant documents may include promissory notes, disbursement records, school enrollment information, repayment histories, consolidation documents, and current balances.

For private loans, the educational institution's eligibility and the purpose of the loan may be critical.

For federal loans, the debtor should identify the precise loan programs and servicers.

The attorney should not rely solely on a credit report description.

29. Why Student Loan Discharge Should Be Evaluated During Bankruptcy Planning

A debtor may have substantial student loan obligations and comparatively little other debt.

If the loans are nondischargeable and undue hardship cannot be established, Chapter 7 may provide limited relief.

Conversely, a debtor with substantial ordinary unsecured debt may benefit from Chapter 7 even when student loans survive.

A debtor with a potentially strong undue-hardship claim should consider whether to pursue an adversary proceeding.

The availability of the Department of Justice's streamlined federal process makes that evaluation particularly important.

Conclusion

Student loans are not categorically immune from bankruptcy discharge.

Section 523(a)(8) protects qualifying educational obligations unless repayment would impose undue hardship.

The Fourth Circuit applies the demanding Brunner standard, but the Department of Justice's coordinated federal student loan review process may simplify the presentation and resolution of appropriate cases.

Private educational loans also require careful classification because not every loan associated with education falls within § 523(a)(8).

Parent PLUS loans, retirement, disability, repayment history, and future earning capacity can materially affect the analysis.

A debtor with substantial student loan debt should not assume that discharge is impossible without first examining the loan's legal classification and the debtor's actual ability to repay.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes and rules

  • 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(8) — Educational debt exceptions and undue hardship.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 350(b) — Reopening bankruptcy cases.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1322 — Chapter 13 plan provisions.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1328 — Chapter 13 discharge.
  • Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 4007 — Dischargeability proceedings.

Federal statutes

  • Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7001 — Adversary proceedings.
  • Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7004 — Service of summons and complaint.

Federal administrative guidance

  • U.S. Department of Justice — Student Loan Bankruptcy Discharge Guidance — Department of Justice and Department of Education process for evaluating federal student loan undue-hardship cases.
  • U.S. Department of Education — Federal Student Aid — Federal loan information, repayment programs, and administrative discharge options.

Selected decisions

  • Brunner v. New York State Higher Education Services Corp., 831 F.2d 395 (2d Cir. 1987) — Establishes the three-part undue-hardship test.
  • Educational Credit Management Corp. v. Frushour, 433 F.3d 393 (4th Cir. 2005) — Applies the Brunner test in the Fourth Circuit and addresses the debtor's burden of establishing undue hardship.
  • In re Mosko, 515 F.3d 319 (4th Cir. 2008) — Addresses undue hardship and the good-faith repayment requirement.
  • In re Ekenasi, 325 F.3d 541 (4th Cir. 2003) — Addresses undue hardship and the debtor's future financial circumstances.
  • United Student Aid Funds, Inc. v. Espinosa, 559 U.S. 260 (2010) — Addresses student loan discharge provisions in a confirmed Chapter 13 plan and the consequences of failure to object.
  • McDaniel v. Navient Solutions, LLC, 973 F.3d 1083 (10th Cir. 2020) — Addresses the scope of § 523(a)(8)(A)(ii) concerning certain private educational obligations.
  • Homaidan v. Sallie Mae, Inc., 3 F.4th 595 (2d Cir. 2021) — Addresses private educational loans and the statutory meaning of educational benefits.
  • In re Crocker, 941 F.3d 206 (5th Cir. 2019) — Addresses the distinction between educational loans and obligations covered by § 523(a)(8)(A)(ii).

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm