Student Loans Are Not Automatically Excluded From Bankruptcy Relief
One of the most persistent misconceptions about bankruptcy is that student loans can never be discharged.
That is incorrect.
Federal bankruptcy law permits discharge of qualifying educational debt when repayment would impose an undue hardship on the debtor and the debtor's dependents.
The difficulty is that Congress has not provided a comprehensive statutory definition of undue hardship. Courts have developed standards for applying the exception, and the resulting litigation can be demanding.
For Maryland debtors, the Fourth Circuit's decisions are particularly important.
Recent federal administrative procedures have also made it possible to resolve some federal student loan hardship cases through a more standardized review process.
These developments do not make student loans automatically dischargeable, but they provide reasons for financially distressed borrowers to reconsider assumptions about their available options.
1. What Does the Bankruptcy Code Say About Student Loans?
The principal provision is 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(8).
It excepts specified educational debts from discharge unless repayment would impose an undue hardship on the debtor and the debtor's dependents.
The provision covers several categories of educational obligations, including certain governmental or nonprofit educational loans, obligations to repay funds received as educational benefits, and qualifying private educational loans.
But not every debt associated with education necessarily falls within the statutory exception.
The classification of the obligation is the first step in the analysis.
2. Federal Student Loans
Federal student loans generally fall within § 523(a)(8).
These may include Direct Loans, certain older Federal Family Education Loan Program obligations, and other qualifying federally supported educational loans.
A borrower seeking to discharge these obligations ordinarily must establish undue hardship in an adversary proceeding.
The debtor's financial circumstances, repayment history, earning capacity, health, dependents, and other relevant factors may be considered.
The availability of federal repayment programs can also affect the analysis, although participation in a particular program is not necessarily an absolute prerequisite to discharge.
3. Private Student Loans
Private educational loans require a more careful classification.
Section 523(a)(8)(B) excepts qualifying educational loans as defined by reference to the Internal Revenue Code.
A loan does not automatically qualify merely because a lender calls it a student loan.
For example, a loan used for expenses outside the statutory definition of qualified higher education expenses may raise different issues.
Similarly, loans associated with educational programs or institutions that do not satisfy applicable statutory requirements may fall outside the exception.
Courts have examined whether particular private loans actually satisfy the statutory language.
A debtor should not assume that every private loan associated with schooling requires proof of undue hardship.
A privately originated loan can also qualify under § 523(a)(8)(A)(i) if it was made under a program funded in whole or in part by a governmental unit or nonprofit institution. Failure to meet the qualified-education-loan definition in subsection (B) does not by itself establish dischargeability if another statutory category applies.
4. The Difference Between Dischargeability and Undue Hardship
Two separate questions must be answered.
First, is the obligation the type of educational debt described in § 523(a)(8)?
If not, it may be discharged under the ordinary bankruptcy discharge provisions, subject to other applicable exceptions.
Second, if the obligation falls within § 523(a)(8), would requiring repayment impose an undue hardship?
Only the second question requires application of the undue-hardship standard.
This distinction can be especially important for private educational loans.
5. The Brunner Test
The Fourth Circuit applies the three-part test associated with Brunner v. New York State Higher Education Services Corp., 831 F.2d 395 (2d Cir. 1987).
The debtor generally must establish:
That repayment would prevent the debtor from maintaining a minimal standard of living for the debtor and dependents.
That additional circumstances indicate the debtor's financial difficulties are likely to persist for a significant portion of the repayment period.
That the debtor has made good-faith efforts to repay the loans.
The test is demanding, but it does not categorically prohibit discharge.
The inquiry is fact-specific and requires evidence concerning the debtor's financial condition and realistic future prospects.
6. The Fourth Circuit's Decision in Frushour
In Educational Credit Management Corp. v. Frushour, 433 F.3d 393 (4th Cir. 2005), the Fourth Circuit applied the Brunner framework and emphasized the demanding nature of the undue-hardship standard.
The court examined the debtor's financial circumstances, employment prospects, and repayment efforts.
The decision also discussed the significance of income-contingent repayment options in evaluating good faith.
However, the availability of a repayment program does not mean that every debtor who declines participation automatically loses an undue-hardship claim.
The circumstances surrounding the debtor's decisions remain relevant.
7. What Is a Minimal Standard of Living?
The first Brunner requirement does not demand that a debtor live in complete destitution.
The question is whether the debtor can maintain a minimal standard of living while making the required student loan payments.
Reasonable housing, food, utilities, transportation, healthcare, and other necessary expenses are relevant.
A debtor's household circumstances may also matter.
For example, an elderly debtor with fixed income and substantial medical expenses may present a different case from a younger debtor with similar current income but significant future earning potential.
The analysis is not limited to whether any money remains at the end of the month.
The court examines whether the debtor's budget is reasonable and whether repayment can realistically be accommodated.
8. Additional Circumstances and Future Financial Prospects
The second Brunner requirement focuses on whether the debtor's financial difficulties are likely to persist.
Relevant circumstances may include age, health limitations, disabilities, employment history, education, vocational skills, caregiving obligations, and realistic earning potential.
Temporary unemployment may not establish persistent hardship.
Conversely, a debtor approaching retirement with limited income and little realistic prospect of increased earnings may have stronger evidence of continuing financial difficulty.
Medical and vocational evidence may be important in appropriate cases.
The debtor's future circumstances should be evaluated realistically rather than through unsupported assumptions about potential earnings.
9. Good-Faith Efforts to Repay
The third Brunner requirement examines the debtor's efforts to address the student loan obligation.
Courts may consider payment history, attempts to obtain employment, efforts to maximize income, reasonable expense management, communications with lenders, and consideration of available repayment options.
A debtor who made payments when financially able may have favorable evidence.
But an inability to make substantial payments does not necessarily establish bad faith.
The debtor's conduct must be considered in light of actual financial circumstances.
10. The Department of Justice's Streamlined Process
In November 2022, the Department of Justice and Department of Education announced a process intended to promote more consistent and efficient handling of federal student loan undue-hardship cases.
The process uses an attestation form and specified financial information to evaluate whether the government should stipulate to relevant facts and support discharge.
It does not amend § 523(a)(8) or eliminate the requirement for judicial determination.
Nor does it automatically apply to every private educational loan.
The process may reduce litigation burdens in qualifying federal student loan cases, but its availability and current implementation should be verified when the proceeding is commenced.
11. What Is an Adversary Proceeding?
A student loan undue-hardship determination ordinarily requires an adversary proceeding within the bankruptcy case.
An adversary proceeding is a separate lawsuit governed by Part VII of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure.
The debtor files a complaint seeking a determination that the student loan debt is dischargeable.
The creditor or appropriate governmental entity is served and may respond.
The proceeding may involve discovery, financial documentation, motions, settlement negotiations, and, if necessary, trial.
The debtor bears the burden of establishing undue hardship under the applicable standard.
12. Can Student Loans Be Partially Discharged?
The possibility of partial relief has been addressed differently by courts.
Some courts permit discharge of a qualifying portion of educational debt when the applicable undue-hardship requirements are proved for that portion. General equitable authority does not permit a court to bypass § 523(a)(8). DOJ guidance permits recommendations for partial relief in appropriate federal cases, but the bankruptcy court must apply the governing statute and circuit law.
The Fourth Circuit's decisions and the limits imposed by the Bankruptcy Code must be examined before assuming partial discharge is available.
A debtor should not assume that inability to repay the entire balance necessarily establishes a right to discharge only part of it.
The requested relief must be supported by governing law.
13. Parent PLUS Loans
Parent PLUS loans can create particularly difficult financial problems.
A parent may borrow substantial amounts to finance a child's education and remain personally obligated long after the child graduates.
The legal borrower ordinarily is the parent, not the student.
A private family agreement under which the child promises to make payments generally does not, by itself, release the parent from liability to the federal loan holder.
For bankruptcy purposes, the parent must evaluate the obligation as the parent's own debt.
Example
A parent approaching retirement owes $180,000 in Parent PLUS loans.
The parent's income is declining, retirement savings are limited, and the monthly payments substantially exceed the parent's realistic ability to pay.
The debtor may have grounds to examine undue hardship, particularly where the evidence demonstrates limited future earning capacity and persistent financial difficulties.
The amount of the debt alone does not establish undue hardship.
But the debtor's age, income, expenses, employment prospects, and available repayment arrangements may be highly relevant.
14. What If a Divorce Agreement Requires the Other Spouse to Pay?
Divorce agreements sometimes allocate responsibility for student loans between former spouses.
For example, one spouse may agree to pay half of a Parent PLUS loan even though the other spouse remains the only borrower under the federal loan documents.
Such an agreement ordinarily does not alter the federal lender's contractual rights.
The lender may continue to pursue the named borrower.
The divorce agreement may create separate obligations between the former spouses, potentially implicating § 523(a)(15) or other bankruptcy provisions.
Consequently, the dischargeability of the student loan and the enforceability of the former spouse's reimbursement obligation are separate legal questions.
15. Student Loans and Chapter 13
Chapter 13 may provide temporary protection from student loan collection through the automatic stay while the debtor makes payments under a confirmed repayment plan.
However, completion of a Chapter 13 plan does not ordinarily discharge student loans covered by § 523(a)(8) unless the debtor establishes undue hardship.
Interest may continue accruing during the case, depending on the loan and applicable law.
A debtor may therefore emerge from Chapter 13 still owing a substantial educational debt.
The plan's treatment of student loans and other unsecured creditors must comply with the Bankruptcy Code.
16. Should a Debtor Wait Until After Bankruptcy to Seek Student Loan Relief?
Not necessarily.
An undue-hardship adversary proceeding can be pursued in connection with the bankruptcy case.
The timing should reflect the debtor's financial circumstances, available evidence, and procedural considerations.
In some cases, it may be appropriate to seek a determination while the main bankruptcy case remains open.
In others, later proceedings may be possible.
A debtor should not assume that student loan dischargeability must be resolved before the ordinary Chapter 7 discharge is entered.
17. What Evidence Is Important?
A successful undue-hardship case ordinarily requires more than a statement that the payments are unaffordable.
Relevant evidence may include income records, tax returns, household budgets, medical documentation, employment history, vocational limitations, retirement projections, student loan payment history, and communications concerning repayment options.
The debtor's testimony may be important, but documentary support can strengthen the claim.
A careful assessment should also distinguish temporary financial hardship from conditions likely to persist.
18. Alternatives to Bankruptcy Discharge
Federal student loan borrowers may have access to income-driven repayment arrangements, deferment, forbearance, disability-related discharge, or other federal relief programs.
Eligibility and program terms change over time.
Private student loans generally do not offer the same range of federal protections, although lenders may provide contractual hardship arrangements.
These alternatives should be considered when evaluating bankruptcy strategy.
However, the existence of a repayment program does not necessarily mean it provides meaningful relief for every borrower.
A program requiring little or no current payment may still leave the debtor facing a substantial long-term obligation.
Conclusion
Student loans are not categorically immune from bankruptcy discharge.
The Bankruptcy Code permits discharge of qualifying educational obligations when repayment would impose an undue hardship.
In Maryland, the Fourth Circuit's application of the Brunner test governs the principal undue-hardship analysis.
Private educational loans may also require careful examination to determine whether they fall within § 523(a)(8) at all.
The Department of Justice's federal student loan review process provides an additional avenue for potentially resolving qualifying undue-hardship cases.
A debtor burdened by substantial educational debt should not assume that bankruptcy offers no possible relief without first examining the nature of the loans and the debtor's actual financial circumstances.
Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7001 — Adversary proceedings.
Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 4007 — Determination of dischargeability.
Federal administrative guidance
Department of Justice — Student Loan Bankruptcy Discharge Guidance — Guidance concerning federal student loan undue-hardship proceedings.
Federal Student Aid — Federal student loan programs and repayment information.
Selected decisions
Brunner v. New York State Higher Education Services Corp., 831 F.2d 395 (2d Cir. 1987) — Establishes the three-part undue-hardship framework.
Educational Credit Management Corp. v. Frushour, 433 F.3d 393 (4th Cir. 2005) — Applies the Brunner test in the Fourth Circuit.
In re Mosko, 515 F.3d 319 (4th Cir. 2008) — Addresses good faith and undue hardship in student loan dischargeability.
In re Spence, 541 F.3d 538 (4th Cir. 2008) — Addresses the demanding requirements for establishing undue hardship.
United Student Aid Funds, Inc. v. Espinosa, 559 U.S. 260 (2010) — Addresses student loan discharge provisions in a confirmed Chapter 13 plan and the consequences of procedural error.
Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions
Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.