Not All Creditors Receive the Same Treatment in Chapter 13
Chapter 13 permits qualifying individuals to repay debts through a court-supervised plan lasting generally three to five years.
But the debtor cannot simply decide which creditors to pay and how much each will receive.
The Bankruptcy Code establishes priorities for certain obligations.
Domestic support obligations, specified taxes, and certain administrative expenses receive treatment different from ordinary credit card balances and medical bills.
Some priority claims generally must be paid in full through the plan unless the creditor agrees to different treatment or a statutory exception applies.
Other obligations may be nondischargeable even when they do not receive priority treatment.
The distinction between priority and nondischargeability is important.
A debtor may have a debt that survives discharge but is not entitled to priority distribution. Conversely, a priority claim may receive mandatory plan treatment even though the debtor could discharge some related obligations under different circumstances.
Understanding these categories is essential to calculating a feasible Chapter 13 payment.
1. What Is a Priority Claim?
Section 507 establishes categories of claims entitled to priority in bankruptcy distributions.
Priority determines the order and treatment of qualifying claims.
In Chapter 13, § 1322(a)(2) generally requires full payment of claims entitled to priority under § 507 unless the holder agrees to different treatment, subject to statutory exceptions.
The debtor should not assume that every governmental or legally important debt is a priority claim.
The creditor must establish entitlement under the applicable statutory provision.
2. Priority Versus Nondischargeability
Priority and nondischargeability are separate concepts.
Priority concerns distribution through the bankruptcy process.
Nondischargeability concerns whether the debtor remains personally liable after discharge.
For example, a qualifying domestic support obligation generally receives priority and is nondischargeable.
A student loan may be nondischargeable under § 523(a)(8) but ordinarily does not receive general priority merely because it is a student loan.
The distinction affects plan design.
3. Domestic Support Obligations
Section 101(14A) defines domestic support obligations.
Qualifying child support and alimony generally fall within the definition.
Domestic support obligations receive first-priority treatment under § 507(a)(1), subject to statutory distinctions.
They generally are nondischargeable under § 523(a)(5).
The debtor should identify the obligee, amount owed, and whether arrears exist.
4. Child Support Arrears
A debtor may owe past-due child support when Chapter 13 is filed.
The arrears may constitute a priority domestic support obligation.
The plan generally must provide the required statutory treatment.
The debtor also must remain current on qualifying postpetition domestic support obligations.
Failure to do so may prevent confirmation or discharge.
5. Alimony Arrears
Qualifying alimony obligations may also constitute domestic support obligations.
The legal character depends on the substance of the obligation.
A payment labeled alimony in a divorce agreement may require examination of its actual purpose.
Likewise, an obligation described as a property settlement may function as support.
The underlying order and circumstances matter.
6. Divorce Property Settlements
Not every divorce-related debt is a domestic support obligation.
Section 523(a)(15) addresses certain obligations owed to a spouse, former spouse, or child arising from divorce or separation that are not domestic support obligations.
Such obligations may be nondischargeable in Chapter 7 but receive different treatment in Chapter 13.
They do not automatically receive domestic support priority.
The debtor should distinguish support from property division and indemnification.
7. Ongoing Support Payments
A debtor must address domestic support obligations arising after filing.
Section 1325(a)(8) requires the specified postpetition domestic support obligations to have been paid as a condition of confirmation. Applicable procedures may require evidence or certification of compliance; a certification is not a substitute for the substantive payment requirement.
Section 1328(a) contains related discharge requirements.
A debtor who fails to remain current may face serious consequences even when trustee payments are otherwise complete.
8. Domestic Support Certifications
The debtor may be required to certify that qualifying domestic support obligations due after filing have been paid.
The applicable requirements arise under the Bankruptcy Code and procedural rules.
The debtor should maintain payment records.
A certification must be accurate.
The debtor should not assume that completion of the repayment plan automatically establishes compliance with support obligations.
9. Priority Income Taxes
Section 507(a)(8) grants priority to specified tax claims.
Certain relatively recent income taxes may qualify.
The classification depends on return due dates, assessment dates, and other statutory provisions.
The debtor should obtain federal and Maryland tax records.
A tax debt's priority status cannot reliably be determined merely from the tax year.
10. The Three-Year Rule
Section 507(a)(8)(A)(i) generally addresses certain income taxes for which returns were last due, including extensions, within three years before filing.
The period may be suspended or extended under applicable provisions.
A debtor should not simply count three calendar years from the end of the tax year.
The actual return due date matters.
11. The 240-Day Assessment Rule
Section 507(a)(8)(A)(ii) generally addresses certain income taxes assessed within 240 days before filing.
The period may be adjusted by specified events.
An old tax year may still produce a priority claim when additional tax was assessed recently.
The debtor should review assessment records.
12. Tax Claims and Late Returns
Late-filed returns can complicate tax dischargeability.
However, priority classification and nondischargeability are distinct.
A tax may be nondischargeable because of return-filing issues even when it does not qualify for priority under every provision of § 507(a)(8).
The debtor should not assume that every nondischargeable tax must be paid in full as a priority claim through Chapter 13.
The precise statutory classification controls.
13. Federal Payroll Taxes
Certain taxes withheld or collected from others receive special treatment.
These may include employee withholding taxes and other trust fund obligations.
Section 507(a)(8)(C) provides priority treatment for qualifying taxes required to be collected or withheld and for which the debtor is liable.
These obligations generally are not treated like ordinary older income taxes.
Business owners and responsible persons may face substantial personal exposure.
14. Maryland Sales and Withholding Taxes
Maryland tax obligations may include income taxes, sales and use taxes, and employer withholding obligations.
The bankruptcy classification depends on the nature of the tax and applicable law.
Certain obligations may qualify as trust fund taxes.
Others may fall under different priority provisions.
The debtor should obtain itemized records from the Maryland Comptroller.
15. Tax Penalties
Tax penalties may receive different treatment from the underlying tax.
Some penalties may be subordinated or classified as general unsecured claims.
Others may be nondischargeable under applicable provisions.
The debtor should distinguish principal tax, interest, penalties, and collection charges.
The entire tax balance should not automatically be classified as priority.
16. Interest on Priority Taxes
Interest on tax claims may require separate treatment depending on whether the claim is secured, unsecured, priority, or nondischargeable.
Prepetition interest may be included in the allowed claim under applicable law.
Postpetition interest generally raises different questions.
The debtor should not assume that every priority tax claim continues accruing interest payable through the plan in the same manner.
The applicable statutes and claim status matter.
Where the Code requires interest on a tax claim, § 511 generally uses the rate determined under applicable nonbankruptcy law, rather than simply applying Till’s vehicle-loan formula. For unsecured nondischargeable obligations, § 1322(b)(10) limits voluntary payment of accruing postpetition interest to disposable income remaining after provision for full payment of all allowed claims. Interest liability and the amount permitted or required through the plan must be analyzed separately.
17. Secured Tax Claims
A taxing authority may possess a valid lien.
A secured tax claim is not identical to an unsecured priority tax claim.
The plan must address the government's secured rights under applicable provisions.
The lien may survive unless properly treated or otherwise resolved.
The debtor should determine whether federal or Maryland tax liens exist before filing.
18. Administrative Expenses
Section 507(a)(2) provides priority for qualifying administrative expenses allowed under § 503(b).
In Chapter 13, administrative expenses may include approved attorney's fees and other qualifying costs.
The plan must provide appropriate treatment.
The debtor should distinguish administrative expenses from ordinary unsecured debts.
19. Chapter 13 Attorney's Fees
Attorney's fees may be paid partly before filing and partly through the plan.
The amount and treatment depend on the fee agreement, applicable law, and court procedures.
Fees paid through the trustee increase the amount that must be funded.
The debtor should understand how much of each plan payment is allocated to administrative expenses.
20. Trustee Compensation
The Chapter 13 trustee receives compensation under applicable federal law.
The trustee percentage affects plan funding.
The rate may vary.
The debtor should use the applicable trustee compensation rate rather than an assumed universal percentage.
The payment calculation must account for the trustee's administration of plan distributions.
21. What If Priority Claims Are Larger Than Expected?
A creditor may file a priority claim exceeding the amount scheduled by the debtor.
For example, the IRS may file a $35,000 priority claim when the debtor anticipated only $18,000.
The discrepancy may materially affect feasibility.
The debtor may need to object to the claim, amend the plan, or consider another option.
The creditor's designation of priority should be reviewed rather than automatically accepted.
22. Objecting to Priority Claims
A debtor may challenge a claim's amount, validity, or priority classification.
Section 502 and applicable Bankruptcy Rules govern claims allowance and objections.
The debtor should obtain supporting documentation.
For tax claims, account transcripts and assessment records may be necessary.
A successful objection may reduce the required plan funding.
However, the debtor must establish the legal basis for the objection.
23. Can Priority Creditors Agree to Different Treatment?
Section 1322(a)(2) generally permits a priority claim holder to agree to different treatment.
The agreement should be clear and legally effective.
The debtor should not assume that silence necessarily constitutes consent to improper treatment.
The plan must satisfy the applicable confirmation requirements.
Section 1322(a)(4) supplies a particular exception for claims entitled to priority under § 507(a)(1)(B), generally specified assigned or governmental support claims: less than full payment may be proposed only if all projected disposable income for the prescribed five-year period is applied to plan payments. This is not a general power to reduce support owed directly to a spouse, former spouse, or child.
24. Priority Debts and the Plan Payment
Priority obligations can materially increase the required monthly payment.
Example
Assume a debtor has:
Obligation
Amount
Priority income taxes
$24,000
Domestic support arrears
$12,000
Attorney's fees through plan
$4,000
Total
$40,000
Over sixty months, $40,000 requires average funding of approximately $666.67 per month before trustee compensation and other required distributions.
The debtor may also need to fund secured claims and general unsecured creditor payments.
The plan must account for all applicable requirements.
25. What If the Debtor Cannot Pay Priority Claims in Full?
A debtor may lack sufficient income to pay required priority obligations within the maximum plan term.
The debtor may seek a permissible alternative arrangement or creditor agreement.
But Chapter 13 does not automatically authorize reduction of mandatory priority payments.
If no feasible plan can be proposed, the debtor may need to consider Chapter 7, Chapter 11, or nonbankruptcy alternatives.
The appropriate response depends on the debts and financial circumstances.
26. Priority Claims and Discharge
Completion of a Chapter 13 plan generally results in discharge of qualifying debts under § 1328(a).
However, some obligations survive discharge.
Domestic support obligations generally remain nondischargeable.
Certain tax debts and other obligations may also survive.
The debtor should not assume that payment of all required priority distributions necessarily eliminates every related personal obligation.
27. Why Priority Classification Matters Before Filing
A debtor may appear capable of funding a Chapter 13 plan until priority claims are identified.
For example, substantial tax obligations may require full payment over the plan period.
The debtor should obtain tax transcripts, support orders, and other relevant records before filing.
Accurate classification can prevent an unrealistic plan.
Conclusion
Chapter 13 gives special treatment to certain priority claims.
Domestic support obligations, specified taxes, and administrative expenses can materially affect the required plan payment.
But priority and nondischargeability are different concepts.
Not every nondischargeable debt receives priority, and not every amount claimed by a government agency qualifies for priority treatment.
A feasible Chapter 13 plan begins with accurate identification of priority obligations and the amount that must be paid through the plan.
Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities
Federal statutes
11 U.S.C. § 101(14A) — Domestic support obligations.
United States v. Sotelo, 436 U.S. 268 (1978) — Addresses trust fund tax liability.
United States v. Noland, 517 U.S. 535 (1996) — Addresses equitable subordination of tax penalty claims.
In re Kestell, 99 F.3d 146 (4th Cir. 1996) — Addresses debtor conduct and abuse; relevance to priority classification is limited.
Maryland practice authorities
United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Maryland — Chapter 13 procedures and local forms.
Maryland Comptroller — State tax records and claims.
Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions
Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.