Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Chapter 13 and Automobile Loans in Maryland: Cramdown, the 910-Day Rule, Interest Rates, Surrender, and What Happens When the Car Is Totaled

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Chapter 13 Bankruptcy and Secured Vehicle Debt

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Chapter 13 Can Change How a Vehicle Loan Is Paid, but Not Every Automobile Loan Can Be Reduced to the Vehicle's Value

A debtor who files Chapter 13 may need to retain an automobile to work, transport family members, or meet ordinary daily obligations.

But the debtor may owe substantially more than the vehicle is worth.

Chapter 13 can provide options unavailable in Chapter 7, including payment of certain secured vehicle claims through a repayment plan and, in appropriate circumstances, reduction of the secured claim to the vehicle's value.

That reduction is commonly called cramdown.

However, the Bankruptcy Code restricts cramdown for certain recently purchased vehicles.

The 910-day rule can require different treatment of qualifying purchase-money automobile loans.

Other issues arise when the vehicle is surrendered, repossessed, destroyed in an accident, or subject to insurance and GAP coverage.

The debtor must distinguish the amount owed, the value of the collateral, the creditor's security interest, and the statutory requirements governing plan treatment.

1. Automobile Loans Are Secured Debts

An automobile lender ordinarily holds a security interest in the financed vehicle.

The lien gives the creditor rights against the collateral when the borrower defaults.

In Chapter 13, the debtor may propose treatment of the secured claim through the repayment plan.

The creditor's rights depend on the loan agreement, lien validity, collateral value, and applicable bankruptcy provisions.

The debtor should not assume that filing bankruptcy automatically eliminates the lender's lien.

2. Section 1325(a)(5)

Section 1325(a)(5) establishes principal requirements for treatment of allowed secured claims.

The creditor may accept the plan.

Alternatively, the plan may provide treatment satisfying the statutory requirements, including retention of the lien and distribution of the required value.

The debtor may also surrender the collateral.

The appropriate treatment depends on the claim and the debtor's objectives.

3. What Is Cramdown?

Cramdown generally refers to modifying a secured claim based on the value of the collateral when the Bankruptcy Code permits that treatment.

Example

Assume a debtor owes $28,000 on a vehicle worth $15,000.

If cramdown is available, the plan may treat $15,000 as secured and the remaining $13,000 as unsecured.

The secured portion generally must receive the required present-value treatment.

The unsecured deficiency receives treatment with other unsecured claims.

However, the 910-day rule may prevent this treatment for certain recently acquired vehicles.

4. The 910-Day Rule

The hanging paragraph following § 1325(a)(9) restricts application of § 506 to certain purchase-money security interests in motor vehicles acquired for the debtor's personal use within 910 days before filing.

When the statutory requirements are satisfied, the debtor generally cannot reduce the qualifying claim to the vehicle's current value through ordinary cramdown.

The debtor should determine the purchase date, loan purpose, and nature of the security interest.

The restriction does not apply automatically to every automobile loan.

The statutory wording tests whether the qualifying debt was incurred within 910 days before the petition and whether the motor vehicle was acquired for the debtor’s personal use; the age of the vehicle alone is not the test. Refinancing and mixed loan components require separate purchase-money analysis. The same hanging paragraph also contains a one-year restriction for qualifying purchase-money debt secured by other things of value.

5. Why 910 Days Matters

Nine hundred ten days is approximately two and one-half years.

A debtor who purchased a qualifying vehicle within that period may face different plan treatment from one who purchased the same vehicle earlier.

Example

A debtor owes $30,000 on a vehicle worth $17,000.

If the vehicle was acquired 800 days before filing and the other statutory requirements are satisfied, the 910-day restriction may prevent cramdown.

If the vehicle was acquired 1,100 days before filing, cramdown may be available, subject to the remaining statutory requirements.

The exact acquisition date should be verified.

6. Purchase-Money Security Interests

The 910-day restriction generally concerns qualifying purchase-money security interests.

A purchase-money obligation ordinarily involves financing used to acquire the collateral.

However, automobile financing agreements may include additional amounts.

These may include taxes, fees, service contracts, GAP products, and negative equity from a trade-in.

Whether each component qualifies as purchase-money debt can be disputed.

The governing law and applicable precedent must be examined.

7. Negative Equity From a Trade-In

A borrower may trade in a vehicle worth less than the outstanding loan balance.

The dealer may include the unpaid negative equity in the financing for the replacement vehicle.

For example, the borrower may owe $8,000 more than the trade-in is worth.

That amount may be rolled into the new loan.

The bankruptcy treatment of negative equity under the 910-day provision has generated litigation.

The debtor should obtain the retail installment contract and transaction documents.

8. GAP Coverage

Guaranteed Asset Protection, commonly called GAP coverage, may address certain deficiencies when a financed vehicle is totaled or stolen.

The actual coverage depends on the contract.

GAP products may be insurance policies or contractual debt-cancellation arrangements.

The debtor should determine whether coverage exists, whether the event qualifies, and what amount is payable.

Bankruptcy does not automatically create GAP protection when none was purchased.

9. Vehicle Valuation

When cramdown is available, collateral valuation becomes important.

Section 506(a)(2) generally provides a replacement-value standard for specified personal property acquired for personal, family, or household purposes.

The Supreme Court addressed valuation in Associates Commercial Corp. v. Rash, 520 U.S. 953 (1997).

The debtor should consider vehicle condition, mileage, equipment, and market information.

A generic book value may not accurately reflect the particular vehicle.

10. The Rash Decision

In Associates Commercial Corp. v. Rash, the Supreme Court addressed valuation of collateral retained by a Chapter 13 debtor.

The Court adopted a replacement-value approach under the statutory framework then applicable.

Congress later added § 506(a)(2), which provides more specific valuation guidance for qualifying personal property.

The decision remains important to the development of Chapter 13 valuation law.

The debtor should apply the current statutory language.

11. Interest Rates on Secured Claims

A creditor receiving payments over time may be entitled to interest sufficient to satisfy the present-value requirement.

In Till v. SCS Credit Corp., 541 U.S. 465 (2004), the Supreme Court addressed the appropriate interest-rate methodology.

The plurality endorsed a formula approach beginning with the prime rate and adjusting for risk.

The applicable rate depends on governing law and the case circumstances.

The debtor should not assume that the original contract rate automatically controls every modified secured claim.

12. Why the Plan Interest Rate Matters

A lower interest rate may materially reduce the amount required to pay a secured claim over the plan term.

For example, a debtor may have an automobile loan with a contract interest rate of 19%.

The Chapter 13 plan may propose a different rate when legally permissible.

The resulting monthly payment can be substantially lower.

However, the creditor may object.

The proposed rate must satisfy applicable law.

13. Paying Vehicle Loans Through the Trustee

A Chapter 13 plan may provide for vehicle payments through the trustee.

The trustee distributes funds according to the confirmed plan.

The debtor must make sufficient plan payments.

The arrangement can simplify administration of arrears and modified secured claims.

However, trustee compensation and distribution timing may affect the calculation.

The debtor should understand whether payments are made through the trustee or directly to the lender.

14. Adequate Protection Before Confirmation

Section 1326(a)(1)(C) addresses certain preconfirmation payments to creditors holding purchase-money security interests in personal property.

The debtor may be required to provide adequate protection before confirmation.

The precise payment arrangements depend on applicable law and court procedures.

The debtor should not assume that the lender receives no protection until the plan is confirmed.

15. What If the Debtor Is Behind on Payments?

Chapter 13 may provide a mechanism for addressing arrears.

The debtor may propose treatment of the secured claim through the plan.

However, the creditor may seek relief from the automatic stay when adequate protection is lacking or other statutory grounds exist.

The debtor must maintain required insurance and comply with applicable obligations.

A plan that cannot fund the vehicle treatment may not be feasible.

16. What If the Vehicle Was Repossessed Before Filing?

A debtor may retain certain rights after repossession under Maryland law.

However, filing bankruptcy does not automatically require immediate return of the vehicle.

In City of Chicago v. Fulton, 592 U.S. 154 (2021), the Supreme Court held that mere retention of property seized before bankruptcy does not itself violate § 362(a)(3).

The debtor may need to seek turnover or other relief.

The status of the repossession and any completed sale matters.

17. Surrendering the Vehicle

Section 1325(a)(5)(C) permits surrender of collateral as a form of secured claim treatment.

A debtor may choose surrender when the vehicle is unaffordable or substantially underwater.

The creditor may liquidate the collateral according to applicable law.

A deficiency may remain.

The deficiency's treatment depends on the claim, plan, and applicable bankruptcy provisions.

Surrender does not necessarily mean the creditor has received full payment.

18. Surrender After Confirmation

A debtor may initially retain a vehicle but later decide to surrender it.

This can create complicated modification issues.

The creditor may have received payments under the confirmed plan.

After surrender, the creditor may assert a deficiency.

Courts have disagreed about the permissible reclassification or modification of secured claims after confirmation.

The debtor should not assume that surrender automatically reduces the remaining plan obligation.

19. What If the Car Is Totaled During Chapter 13?

A vehicle may be destroyed in an accident during the repayment plan.

The lender may possess rights to insurance proceeds under the policy and security agreement.

The debtor may need replacement transportation.

The Chapter 13 trustee and bankruptcy court may also have interests in the disposition of proceeds.

The debtor should promptly notify counsel and the insurer.

The insurance settlement should not be distributed without determining the applicable rights.

20. Insurance Proceeds

Insurance proceeds may be payable jointly to the debtor and lienholder.

The creditor may assert rights under the security agreement.

The debtor may have an interest in any excess proceeds.

The bankruptcy estate's interest depends on the circumstances and applicable law.

The debtor should obtain the insurer's valuation, payoff information, and settlement documents.

21. GAP Claims After a Total Loss

If the vehicle is totaled, GAP coverage may reduce or eliminate a qualifying deficiency.

However, the coverage may contain exclusions or conditions.

For example, certain unpaid charges or overdue payments may not be covered.

The debtor should submit the claim promptly and preserve documentation.

The debtor should not assume that GAP automatically pays every amount remaining on the loan.

22. What If There Is No GAP Coverage?

A debtor whose vehicle is totaled may remain liable for a deficiency after application of insurance proceeds.

The deficiency may be treated as an unsecured claim when appropriate.

However, the plan and secured claim treatment may require modification.

The debtor should determine whether replacement financing is necessary and affordable.

The resulting financial circumstances may affect plan feasibility.

23. Replacing a Vehicle During Chapter 13

A debtor may need to purchase another vehicle during the plan.

New borrowing may require trustee consent, court approval, or compliance with applicable local procedures.

The debtor should not assume that financing can be obtained without regard to the confirmed plan.

The proposed payment must be affordable.

The debtor should consult counsel before signing a new financing agreement.

24. Vehicle Insurance

The debtor generally must maintain insurance required by the financing agreement.

Failure to insure collateral may support a creditor's request for stay relief.

Insurance costs should be included accurately in the Chapter 13 budget.

The debtor should notify counsel of substantial premium increases that threaten plan feasibility.

25. Cosigners

A vehicle loan may have a nonfiling cosigner.

Chapter 13 provides a limited codebtor stay for certain consumer obligations under § 1301.

The protection is subject to statutory exceptions.

The debtor's plan treatment may affect the cosigner.

Surrender or nonpayment may expose the cosigner to collection when the stay does not apply or relief is granted.

The debtor should consider the consequences for family members or other obligated parties.

26. Why Vehicle Loan Documents Must Be Reviewed

The attorney should obtain the retail installment contract, payment history, title information, insurance documents, and any GAP agreement.

These records establish the acquisition date, security interest, loan components, and payment terms.

The debtor should also provide accurate vehicle condition and mileage information.

The documents may determine whether cramdown is available and how the claim must be treated.

Conclusion

Chapter 13 provides important options for retaining or surrendering financed vehicles.

When cramdown is permitted, the secured claim may be reduced to the vehicle's value, with the remaining balance treated as unsecured.

But the 910-day rule restricts cramdown for qualifying recently acquired vehicles.

Interest, collateral valuation, adequate protection, and plan feasibility also affect the required treatment.

A vehicle destroyed during Chapter 13 presents additional issues involving insurance proceeds, GAP coverage, deficiencies, and replacement financing.

The appropriate Chapter 13 treatment depends on the loan's legal characteristics, the vehicle's value, the debtor's ability to pay, and the circumstances that arise during the plan.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes

  • 11 U.S.C. § 506 — Secured claim valuation.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1325(a)(5) — Secured claim treatment.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1326(a) — Preconfirmation payments.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1329 — Plan modification.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 1301 — Codebtor stay.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 362 — Automatic stay.

Maryland law

  • Maryland Commercial Law, Title 12, Subtitle 10 — Credit Grantor Closed End Credit Provisions, where validly elected; distinguish the separate Retail Installment Sales Act and the agreement’s governing law.
  • Maryland Commercial Law Article, Title 9 — Secured transactions.

Selected decisions

  • Till v. SCS Credit Corp., 541 U.S. 465 (2004) — Addresses Chapter 13 secured claim interest rates.
  • Associates Commercial Corp. v. Rash, 520 U.S. 953 (1997) — Addresses valuation of retained collateral.
  • In re Price, 562 F.3d 618 (4th Cir. 2009) — Addresses the 910-day provision and vehicle claim treatment.
  • City of Chicago v. Fulton, 592 U.S. 154 (2021) — Addresses retention of property seized before bankruptcy.
  • In re Wright, 492 F.3d 829 (7th Cir. 2007) — Addresses surrendered collateral and the 910-day provision.
  • In re Nolan, 232 F.3d 528 (6th Cir. 2000) — Addresses postconfirmation surrender and modification of secured claims.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm