Some Income Taxes Can Be Discharged in Bankruptcy, but Timing Is Critical
A person who owes substantial federal or Maryland income taxes may assume that bankruptcy cannot eliminate the obligation.
That assumption is incorrect.
Certain older income tax debts can be discharged in Chapter 7 bankruptcy when the statutory requirements are satisfied.
However, tax dischargeability is governed by detailed rules involving the original return due date, the date the return was filed, the date the tax was assessed, and whether any events suspended the applicable periods.
A debtor who files bankruptcy even a few days too early may remain liable for a tax obligation that could have been discharged through a later filing.
Conversely, waiting may permit the IRS or Maryland Comptroller to continue collection, obtain liens, or take other enforcement action.
The appropriate filing date must therefore be determined from verified tax records rather than estimates.
1. Income Taxes Are Not Categorically Nondischargeable
Section 523(a)(1) identifies tax obligations excepted from discharge.
The statute incorporates priority-tax provisions under § 507(a)(8).
Certain older income taxes may fall outside those provisions and become dischargeable.
But not every tax is treated alike.
Income taxes, payroll withholding taxes, sales taxes, property taxes, and tax penalties may be governed by different rules.
The analysis must identify the particular tax, tax period, and legal basis for the obligation.
2. The Three-Year Rule
Under § 507(a)(8)(A)(i), certain income taxes receive priority treatment when the return was last due, including extensions, within three years before the bankruptcy petition.
Older income taxes may fall outside this priority period.
Example
A taxpayer owes federal income tax for 2022.
Assume the return was due April 18, 2023, and no extension or tolling applies.
The ordinary three-year period generally would expire in April 2026.
A bankruptcy filed before expiration may leave the tax nondischargeable.
A later filing may satisfy the three-year requirement, assuming the other statutory conditions are met.
The precise deadline should be calculated using the legally applicable due date and any extensions or suspension periods.
3. Extensions Change the Three-Year Calculation
The three-year period is measured from the date the return was last due, including extensions.
For example, a taxpayer may obtain a valid extension to October.
The later due date may control the three-year calculation.
A debtor should not automatically use April 15 as the relevant date.
The attorney should verify the actual filing deadline applicable to the tax year.
4. The Two-Year Rule
Section 523(a)(1)(B)(ii) generally excepts from discharge certain taxes for which a required return was filed after its due date and within two years before the bankruptcy petition.
This provision can prevent discharge even when the tax year is old.
Example
A debtor files a delinquent 2019 income tax return in January 2025.
The debtor files Chapter 7 in December 2026.
Although the tax year is several years old, the return was filed less than two years before bankruptcy.
The tax may remain nondischargeable.
The debtor generally must satisfy the applicable two-year requirement in addition to the other dischargeability conditions.
5. The 240-Day Assessment Rule
Section 507(a)(8)(A)(ii) generally gives priority treatment to income taxes assessed within 240 days before bankruptcy, subject to statutory adjustments.
The assessment date may differ substantially from the tax return filing date.
For example, the IRS may assess additional tax after an audit.
That assessment can affect dischargeability.
A debtor should not assume that an old tax year is dischargeable merely because the return was filed several years earlier.
The actual assessment history must be examined.
6. The Three Rules Must Be Satisfied Together
For an ordinary income tax debt to be dischargeable, the debtor generally must satisfy the applicable three-year, two-year, and 240-day requirements.
The analysis is cumulative.
A tax may satisfy the three-year rule but fail the two-year rule.
It may satisfy both but remain within the 240-day assessment period.
Fraud, willful tax evasion, unfiled returns, and other statutory provisions may independently prevent discharge.
A complete analysis therefore requires more than calculating the age of the tax year.
Section 507(a)(8)(A)(iii) separately gives priority to certain income taxes not assessed before filing but still assessable afterward. Satisfying the usual three-year, two-year, and 240-day shorthand therefore does not establish dischargeability without checking this additional category and its statutory exceptions.
7. Why Filing a Few Days Too Early Can Be Costly
Consider a debtor who owes $65,000 in otherwise potentially dischargeable income taxes.
The applicable 240-day assessment period will expire in ten days.
If the debtor files Chapter 7 immediately, the taxes may remain nondischargeable.
If the debtor waits until the relevant period expires, the taxes may become dischargeable, assuming all other requirements are satisfied.
However, waiting may expose the debtor to garnishment, levy, or other collection activity.
The attorney must weigh the value of the potential discharge against the risks of delay.
The Bankruptcy Code contains a definition of return in the hanging paragraph following § 523(a).
The provision refers to applicable nonbankruptcy law, including filing requirements.
Courts have disagreed concerning the treatment of returns filed after the statutory deadline.
Some decisions apply strict interpretations that may prevent discharge of taxes associated with late-filed returns.
Other decisions distinguish different types of late filings and circumstances.
The debtor should not assume that waiting two years after filing a delinquent return necessarily makes the tax dischargeable.
9. The Fourth Circuit's Decision in Moroney
In In re Moroney, 352 F.3d 902 (4th Cir. 2003), the Fourth Circuit addressed the dischargeability of taxes associated with returns filed after the IRS had prepared substitute assessments.
The court concluded that the debtor's filings did not constitute returns for the relevant bankruptcy dischargeability purpose under the circumstances presented.
The decision predates the 2005 statutory amendments.
Its continuing significance must therefore be considered alongside the current statutory definition of return and subsequent case law.
For Maryland debtors, late-filed returns require particularly careful analysis.
10. Substitute Returns Prepared by the IRS
When a taxpayer fails to file, the IRS may prepare a substitute for return or otherwise determine and assess tax.
A substitute return does not necessarily satisfy the debtor's filing obligations for bankruptcy dischargeability purposes.
A later return submitted by the taxpayer may also present complications.
The statutory definition of return expressly addresses certain returns prepared under Internal Revenue Code § 6020(a) and excludes those prepared under § 6020(b).
The distinction matters.
The debtor should obtain the IRS account transcript and determine exactly what documents were filed and when.
11. Fraudulent Returns
Section 523(a)(1)(C) excepts taxes from discharge when the debtor made a fraudulent return or willfully attempted in any manner to evade or defeat the tax.
The provision can apply regardless of the ordinary aging rules.
For example, a debtor who intentionally concealed substantial income may face nondischargeability even when the tax year is old.
The government must establish the applicable statutory requirements.
An ordinary mistake or inability to pay does not automatically establish fraud or willful evasion.
12. Willful Tax Evasion
Willful evasion can involve conduct beyond filing a fraudulent return.
Courts may examine affirmative acts intended to evade payment or collection.
Examples may include concealment of assets, misleading financial representations, or other conduct satisfying the statutory standard.
The distinction between inability to pay and deliberate evasion is important.
A taxpayer who lacks sufficient resources to pay a tax debt has not necessarily willfully evaded it.
The Fourth Circuit's applicable precedent must be considered.
13. IRS Tax Liens
Discharge of personal liability does not necessarily eliminate a valid federal tax lien.
Under federal tax law, a lien may arise when the statutory requirements are satisfied.
A tax lien may attach to property interests owned by the taxpayer.
Bankruptcy may discharge the debtor's personal obligation while leaving the lien enforceable against qualifying property.
The debtor should determine whether a lien exists and what property it encumbers.
The lien's treatment is separate from dischargeability of the underlying tax.
14. Maryland Tax Liens
The Maryland Comptroller may possess statutory collection and lien rights concerning unpaid state taxes.
The effect depends on Maryland tax law and the nature of the obligation.
A debtor should determine whether a Maryland tax lien has attached to property.
Discharge of personal liability does not necessarily eliminate a valid prepetition lien.
The relevant state records should be examined.
15. Trust Fund Taxes
Certain taxes collected or withheld from others receive special treatment.
Examples include employee income tax withholding and the employee portion of payroll taxes.
Section 507(a)(8)(C) addresses taxes required to be collected or withheld and for which the debtor is liable.
These obligations generally are not discharged merely because they are old.
Business owners and responsible persons may face personal liability under applicable tax laws.
The debtor should distinguish trust fund taxes from ordinary income taxes.
16. Sales Taxes
Sales and use taxes may receive different treatment depending on the governing law and legal character of the tax.
Some obligations may qualify as trust fund taxes.
Others may be analyzed under different provisions of § 507(a)(8).
The debtor should not assume that every sales tax debt follows the ordinary three-year, two-year, and 240-day income tax rules.
The applicable state statute and nature of the obligation must be examined.
17. Property Taxes
Property taxes may receive different treatment from income taxes.
Section 507(a)(8)(B) addresses certain property taxes.
Valid tax liens may survive bankruptcy.
The debtor should distinguish personal liability from the government's rights against real estate.
A Chapter 7 discharge does not necessarily eliminate a property tax lien or prevent enforcement against the property.
18. Tax Penalties
Tax penalties may be dischargeable or nondischargeable depending on the statutory basis and circumstances.
Section 523(a)(7) contains provisions concerning certain governmental fines and penalties.
The relationship between the penalty and underlying tax can matter.
A debtor should obtain an itemized accounting separating principal tax, interest, penalties, and collection charges.
The entire balance should not automatically be treated as one indivisible obligation.
19. Interest on Tax Debts
Interest generally follows the dischargeability treatment of the underlying tax obligation, subject to applicable law.
If the underlying tax is nondischargeable, associated interest may also survive.
If the tax is discharged, associated prepetition interest ordinarily may be discharged as well.
However, valid liens and postpetition interest issues may require separate analysis.
The debtor should obtain a complete account transcript.
20. Tolling and Suspension of the Time Periods
The three-year and 240-day periods may be suspended or extended under specified circumstances.
Events affecting the calculation may include prior bankruptcy cases, offers in compromise, collection due process proceedings, and other statutory suspension periods.
The relevant provisions include § 507(a)(8) and applicable tax law.
A debtor should not calculate dischargeability simply by counting calendar days from the original tax return due date.
The history of the tax account matters.
21. Prior Bankruptcy Filings
A previous bankruptcy may affect the timing of tax dischargeability.
The automatic stay may have prevented tax collection during the earlier case.
The Bankruptcy Code contains provisions extending or suspending relevant tax priority periods.
A debtor who previously filed Chapter 13 and later seeks Chapter 7 relief should review the prior case dates.
The earlier filing may cause taxes to remain nondischargeable longer than expected.
22. Offers in Compromise
An offer in compromise may affect tax collection and certain statutory periods.
The Bankruptcy Code contains provisions concerning suspension of the 240-day assessment period in connection with offers in compromise.
The debtor should obtain records showing when the offer was submitted, pending, rejected, withdrawn, or otherwise resolved.
The precise dates can materially affect the dischargeability calculation.
23. IRS Account Transcripts
IRS account transcripts are essential to a reliable federal income tax dischargeability analysis.
They can identify return filing dates, assessments, payments, penalties, and certain account events.
However, one transcript may not always contain every fact necessary to calculate the statutory periods.
Counsel may need additional records concerning extensions, collection proceedings, prior bankruptcy cases, or offers in compromise.
The debtor's recollection alone should not be used to determine the filing date.
24. Maryland Comptroller Records
Maryland income tax obligations require separate analysis.
The attorney should obtain relevant Maryland Comptroller account records and identify the applicable return dates, assessments, and collection history.
Federal and state assessment dates may differ.
A federal tax debt may be dischargeable while the corresponding Maryland tax debt remains nondischargeable, or vice versa.
The two obligations should not automatically be treated as having identical dischargeability dates.
25. Chapter 7 Versus Chapter 13 for Tax Debts
Chapter 7 may discharge qualifying older income taxes relatively quickly.
However, nondischargeable taxes generally remain enforceable.
Chapter 13 may permit payment of qualifying priority tax claims through a repayment plan.
Certain tax liens may also receive treatment under the plan, subject to applicable law.
A debtor with substantial recent tax obligations may benefit from Chapter 13 even when Chapter 7 is available.
The appropriate chapter depends on the tax classifications, liens, income, and other debts.
26. Tax Refund Offsets
The IRS or Maryland Comptroller may assert rights to apply tax refunds against outstanding obligations.
Bankruptcy may affect those rights.
Section 553 generally preserves qualifying setoff rights, subject to statutory limitations.
The debtor should not assume that a tax refund will be paid directly merely because a return reflects an overpayment.
The relevant tax periods and obligations must be examined.
27. What If the IRS Continues Collecting After Discharge?
The IRS may continue collecting taxes that were not discharged, subject to applicable law.
It may also enforce certain surviving tax liens.
However, collection of a discharged personal tax obligation may violate the discharge injunction.
The debtor should determine whether the particular tax was discharged and whether the collection activity concerns personal liability or a surviving lien.
The discharge order alone may not identify each tax obligation's status.
28. Why Tax Dischargeability Should Be Determined Before Filing
Tax dischargeability is one of the clearest examples of why bankruptcy timing matters.
A debtor may have substantial unsecured debt and qualify for Chapter 7 but receive limited benefit if a large tax obligation survives.
Waiting a short period may sometimes change the result.
In other cases, waiting may be dangerous because of collection activity or asset exposure.
The attorney should calculate the applicable dates from verified records and evaluate the entire financial picture.
Conclusion
Certain older federal and Maryland income taxes can be discharged in Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
But the three-year, two-year, and 240-day rules must be considered together, along with return filing requirements, assessments, fraud, evasion, and statutory suspension periods.
Late-filed returns and substitute assessments can create particularly difficult questions.
Tax liens may survive even when personal liability is discharged.
Trust fund taxes, property taxes, and other obligations may be governed by different rules.
A debtor with substantial tax debt should not select a bankruptcy filing date until the relevant returns, assessments, and tolling events have been verified. Filing even a few days too early can have serious financial consequences.
11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(1) — Tax exceptions to discharge.
11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(7) — Certain tax penalties.
11 U.S.C. § 553 — Setoff.
11 U.S.C. § 1322 — Chapter 13 plan treatment.
26 U.S.C. § 6020 — Returns prepared by the IRS.
26 U.S.C. § 6321 — Federal tax liens.
Maryland law
Maryland Tax-General Article — State tax administration, assessments, and collection.
Maryland Comptroller — State tax account information.
Selected decisions
In re Moroney, 352 F.3d 902 (4th Cir. 2003) — Addresses late-filed returns following substitute assessments.
United States v. Noland, 517 U.S. 535 (1996) — Addresses bankruptcy treatment of certain tax penalties.
Young v. United States, 535 U.S. 43 (2002) — Addresses equitable tolling of the three-year tax priority period under the former statutory framework.
United States v. Sotelo, 436 U.S. 268 (1978) — Addresses trust fund tax liability.
United States v. Galletti, 541 U.S. 114 (2004) — Addresses federal tax assessments and partnership-related liabilities.
In re McCoy, 666 F.3d 924 (5th Cir. 2012) — Addresses late-filed state income tax returns under the post-2005 statutory definition.
In re Mallo, 774 F.3d 1313 (10th Cir. 2014) — Addresses late-filed returns and dischargeability.
In re Hindenlang, 164 F.3d 1029 (6th Cir. 1999) — Addresses late-filed returns after substitute assessment procedures.
Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions
Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.