Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Bankruptcy and Lawsuit Judgments: Which Judgments Can Be Discharged, Which Liens Survive, and When Fraud or Intentional Injury Changes the Result

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Judgments, Litigation, and Dischargeability

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

A Judgment Does Not Automatically Make a Debt Nondischargeable

A person who has been sued and lost may believe that bankruptcy can no longer eliminate the debt because the creditor obtained a judgment.

That belief is generally incorrect.

Many judgments are dischargeable in Chapter 7 bankruptcy. A judgment arising from an ordinary credit card account, personal loan, medical bill, or negligence claim may be eliminated just as the underlying debt could have been discharged before judgment.

But some judgments involve obligations that bankruptcy does not discharge.

Fraud, willful and malicious injury, certain governmental penalties, domestic support obligations, and other statutory exceptions may cause particular debts to survive.

A separate issue arises when the judgment creditor has obtained a lien against the debtor's property.

Even when personal liability is discharged, a valid prepetition judgment lien may remain unless it is avoided or otherwise extinguished.

The critical distinction is between the judgment as evidence of personal liability, the nature of the underlying debt, and any property rights created through the judgment.

1. What Does a Judgment Establish?

A judgment ordinarily establishes a legally enforceable obligation determined by a court.

The judgment may arise after trial, summary judgment, default, consent, or another procedural disposition.

The creditor may obtain collection remedies under applicable law.

These can include wage garnishment, bank account attachment, judgment liens, and execution against property.

But the existence of a judgment does not independently determine whether the obligation is dischargeable in bankruptcy.

Federal bankruptcy law governs dischargeability.

2. Ordinary Credit Card Judgments

A judgment arising from an ordinary credit card balance generally is dischargeable in Chapter 7.

For example, a creditor may obtain a $28,000 judgment based on unpaid credit card charges.

If the debt does not fall within a statutory exception, Chapter 7 may discharge the debtor's personal liability.

The creditor ordinarily may not continue collecting the discharged obligation personally after discharge.

However, a judgment lien that attached to property before bankruptcy requires separate analysis.

3. Medical Bill Judgments

Medical debts generally are dischargeable unsecured obligations.

A hospital or physician may obtain a judgment for unpaid treatment charges.

The judgment does not ordinarily convert the debt into a nondischargeable obligation.

The debtor may discharge qualifying personal liability in Chapter 7.

But any valid lien or separate statutory right must be evaluated independently.

4. Personal Loan Judgments

Judgments arising from ordinary personal loans generally may be discharged.

The fact that the lender obtained judgment does not automatically alter the debt's dischargeability.

However, a creditor may assert fraud or another statutory exception when supported by the underlying transaction.

A mere failure to repay ordinarily does not establish fraud.

The creditor must satisfy the applicable legal requirements.

5. Negligence Judgments

A judgment arising from ordinary negligence generally may be discharged in Chapter 7.

For example, a driver may cause an automobile accident and become personally liable for damages.

If the conduct involved ordinary negligence and no statutory exception applies, the resulting judgment may be dischargeable.

The fact that the injured person suffered serious harm does not automatically change the result.

Bankruptcy law distinguishes negligent conduct from intentional injury and other specified misconduct.

6. Willful and Malicious Injury

Section 523(a)(6) excepts certain debts arising from willful and malicious injury by the debtor to another person or another person's property.

In Kawaauhau v. Geiger, 523 U.S. 57 (1998), the Supreme Court distinguished intentional injury from conduct that merely causes an unintended injury.

Ordinary negligence generally does not satisfy the statutory standard.

Recklessness alone also does not establish the deliberate or intentional injury required by § 523(a)(6). Evidence must satisfy both the willful and malicious elements under governing precedent.

The debtor's intent and the nature of the injury are critical.

A judgment based on intentional assault may therefore present different dischargeability issues from a judgment based on negligent driving.

7. Fraud Judgments

Section 523(a)(2) excepts certain debts obtained through false pretenses, false representations, or actual fraud.

A judgment arising from fraud may be nondischargeable when the statutory elements are established.

However, the word fraud in a complaint or judgment does not automatically resolve the bankruptcy question.

The bankruptcy court may need to determine whether the underlying findings satisfy § 523.

The particular type of fraud, creditor's reliance where required, and other statutory elements matter.

8. Default Judgments

A default judgment may be dischargeable or nondischargeable depending on the underlying debt.

The fact that the debtor failed to defend the lawsuit does not automatically establish nondischargeability.

However, the judgment may have preclusive consequences under applicable law.

The bankruptcy court must determine whether the issues necessary for nondischargeability were actually litigated or otherwise satisfy the governing preclusion rules.

The effect of a default judgment can differ depending on the issuing court and applicable law.

9. Collateral Estoppel in Dischargeability Proceedings

Issue preclusion, sometimes called collateral estoppel, may prevent relitigation of issues already determined in prior proceedings.

In Grogan v. Garner, 498 U.S. 279 (1991), the Supreme Court recognized that collateral estoppel principles apply in dischargeability proceedings.

But the prior judgment must satisfy the applicable preclusion requirements.

For example, a judgment containing specific findings of intentional fraud may establish facts relevant to § 523(a)(2).

A general judgment for breach of contract may not.

The bankruptcy court must examine the record and determine which issues were actually and necessarily decided.

10. Punitive Damages

Punitive damages may be awarded to punish and deter certain misconduct.

Their dischargeability depends on the underlying debt and applicable statutory exception.

In Cohen v. de la Cruz, 523 U.S. 213 (1998), the Supreme Court held that the nondischargeability of a fraud debt under § 523(a)(2)(A) extended to associated treble damages, attorney's fees, and other liability arising from the fraud.

The decision illustrates that nondischargeability may extend beyond direct compensatory damages.

However, punitive damages are not categorically nondischargeable merely because they are punitive.

The underlying statutory basis matters.

11. Judgments Arising From Drunk Driving

Section 523(a)(9) excepts qualifying debts for death or personal injury caused by the debtor's operation of a motor vehicle, vessel, or aircraft when operation was unlawful because of intoxication.

The statute contains specific requirements.

A judgment arising from an intoxicated-driving injury may therefore survive Chapter 7 even when an ordinary negligence judgment would be discharged.

The nature of the conduct and statutory elements must be established.

12. Judgments for Domestic Support

Domestic support obligations generally are nondischargeable under § 523(a)(5).

A judgment for unpaid child support or qualifying alimony ordinarily survives Chapter 7.

Other divorce-related obligations may fall within § 523(a)(15).

The substance of the obligation matters more than its label.

A property settlement judgment may require different analysis from a support judgment, particularly when comparing Chapter 7 and Chapter 13.

13. Governmental Penalty Judgments

Section 523(a)(7) excepts certain fines, penalties, and forfeitures payable to and for the benefit of governmental units and not constituting compensation for actual pecuniary loss.

A government judgment may therefore be nondischargeable when it satisfies the statutory requirements.

But not every government judgment is a penalty.

A judgment requiring reimbursement of actual losses may present different issues.

The nature of the obligation controls.

14. Judgment Liens Are Different From Judgment Debts

A judgment creditor may acquire a lien against real estate under applicable Maryland law.

The lien is distinct from the debtor's personal liability.

A Chapter 7 discharge may eliminate personal liability while leaving a valid judgment lien enforceable against property.

For example, a debtor may discharge a $45,000 credit card judgment but discover that the creditor's lien remains attached to the debtor's home.

The debtor may need to seek lien avoidance under § 522(f).

Discharge alone does not necessarily clear title.

15. Avoiding Judgment Liens Under § 522(f)

Section 522(f)(1)(A) permits avoidance of qualifying judicial liens to the extent they impair exemptions.

Maryland's increased residential-property exemption may expand the amount of judicial lien avoidance available to qualifying homeowners.

The statutory impairment formula must be applied.

The debtor ordinarily must file a motion and obtain a court order.

The lien may be avoided in full or in part.

The remedy is separate from discharge of the underlying judgment debt.

16. Wage Garnishments Based on Judgments

A judgment creditor may garnish wages before bankruptcy.

Filing Chapter 7 ordinarily stops further garnishment on a prepetition unsecured judgment while the automatic stay applies.

But wages already garnished may present a separate recovery opportunity.

Under §§ 522(h) and 547, a debtor may, in specified circumstances, recover qualifying preferential transfers when the trustee does not pursue them.

The ninety-day preference period, statutory monetary threshold, and available exemptions matter.

The debtor should preserve pay records and garnishment documents.

17. Bank Account Garnishments

A creditor may obtain legal process attaching funds in a debtor's bank account.

A bankruptcy filing may affect further collection under the automatic stay.

However, funds seized before filing raise additional questions.

The Supreme Court's decision in City of Chicago v. Fulton, 592 U.S. 154 (2021), held that mere retention of property seized before bankruptcy does not itself violate § 362(a)(3).

Turnover and other statutory remedies may still be relevant.

The debtor should not assume that filing automatically releases every prepetition attachment.

18. Pending Lawsuits When Bankruptcy Is Filed

Section 362(a) generally stays continuation of many lawsuits against the debtor involving prepetition claims.

The plaintiff may need to suspend proceedings.

However, the stay does not necessarily prohibit every lawsuit or proceeding.

Criminal matters, certain governmental regulatory actions, and other statutory exceptions may continue.

The debtor should identify all pending litigation in the bankruptcy schedules and statement of financial affairs.

19. Can a Plaintiff Continue a Lawsuit to Reach Insurance?

In some circumstances, a plaintiff may seek relief from the automatic stay to proceed against a debtor nominally for the purpose of establishing liability and recovering available insurance proceeds.

The plaintiff may agree not to enforce any resulting judgment against the debtor personally or against property of the bankruptcy estate.

The bankruptcy court may impose conditions.

The existence of insurance does not automatically eliminate the stay.

The plaintiff ordinarily should obtain appropriate relief when required.

20. What Happens to a Lawsuit After Discharge?

When a debt has been discharged, § 524 generally prohibits collection of the discharged personal liability.

However, a plaintiff may seek to establish liability for purposes of recovering from another legally responsible party, including an insurer, when permitted by law.

Section 524(e) provides that discharge of the debtor does not affect the liability of another entity for the same debt.

The procedural route depends on the underlying claim and applicable law.

A plaintiff should not assume that the debtor's discharge necessarily extinguishes every insurance-related claim.

21. Does Bankruptcy Affect Appeals?

A pending appeal involving a claim against the debtor may be subject to the automatic stay.

The treatment can depend on the nature of the underlying proceeding and the party seeking relief.

For example, an appeal from a judgment entered against the debtor may remain subject to the stay even when the debtor is the appellant.

The procedural posture alone does not necessarily determine whether § 362 applies.

The parties should evaluate the underlying action and applicable exceptions.

22. What If the Judgment Was Entered Shortly Before Bankruptcy?

A judgment entered shortly before bankruptcy may create additional issues.

The creditor may have obtained a lien, garnished wages, or received payments.

Some transfers may be avoidable under § 547.

A judgment lien may be avoidable under § 522(f) if it impairs an exemption.

The debtor should not assume that the judgment's recent entry automatically makes it invalid.

Each enforcement action requires separate analysis.

23. Can the Bankruptcy Court Reexamine the Judgment?

A bankruptcy court generally does not sit as an ordinary appellate court reviewing state-court judgments.

However, it may determine dischargeability under federal bankruptcy law.

Issue preclusion may limit relitigation of factual issues already decided.

The court must distinguish between impermissible collateral attacks on a judgment and permissible determinations concerning the judgment debt's bankruptcy treatment.

The prior court record may be important.

24. Why the Judgment Documents Matter

A debtor should provide bankruptcy counsel with the complaint, judgment, relevant orders, and available litigation records.

The underlying allegations and findings may determine whether the debt is dischargeable.

The attorney should also identify any recorded judgment liens, garnishments, attachments, or other enforcement proceedings.

A judgment amount alone does not provide enough information to evaluate bankruptcy consequences.

25. Why Judgment Creditors May File Adversary Proceedings

Certain creditors may seek determinations that their judgments are nondischargeable.

Under § 523(c) and Rule 4007(c), complaints involving specified fraud, fiduciary misconduct, and willful and malicious injury generally must be filed within the applicable deadline.

Other exceptions may operate differently.

The creditor must satisfy the statutory requirements and any applicable procedural rules.

A debtor should not assume that every judgment creditor can prevent discharge merely by filing an objection.

Conclusion

Many lawsuit judgments are dischargeable in Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Ordinary credit card, medical debt, personal loan, and negligence judgments generally may be eliminated when no statutory exception applies.

But judgments arising from qualifying fraud, willful and malicious injury, intoxicated driving, domestic support, and certain governmental penalties may survive.

Valid judgment liens also may remain enforceable even when personal liability is discharged.

The critical question is not whether the creditor has a judgment. It is what the judgment represents, whether the debt falls within a statutory exception, and whether the creditor acquired enforceable property rights that survive bankruptcy.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes

  • 11 U.S.C. § 362 — Automatic stay.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 522(f) — Judicial lien avoidance.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 523 — Exceptions to discharge.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 524 — Discharge injunction and liability of other entities.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 547 — Preferential transfers.
  • Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 4007 — Dischargeability proceedings.

Maryland law

  • Maryland Courts and Judicial Proceedings § 11-402 — Judgment liens.
  • Maryland Courts and Judicial Proceedings § 11-504 — Exemptions.

Selected decisions

  • Grogan v. Garner, 498 U.S. 279 (1991) — Addresses issue preclusion and the burden of proof in dischargeability litigation.
  • Kawaauhau v. Geiger, 523 U.S. 57 (1998) — Distinguishes intentional injury from negligent or reckless conduct under § 523(a)(6).
  • Cohen v. de la Cruz, 523 U.S. 213 (1998) — Addresses damages and other liability arising from nondischargeable fraud.
  • Brown v. Felsen, 442 U.S. 127 (1979) — Addresses bankruptcy court consideration of the underlying nature of a judgment debt.
  • Archer v. Warner, 538 U.S. 314 (2003) — Addresses the effect of settlement agreements on fraud-based nondischargeability.
  • Farrey v. Sanderfoot, 500 U.S. 291 (1991) — Addresses judicial lien avoidance.
  • City of Chicago v. Fulton, 592 U.S. 154 (2021) — Addresses retention of seized property and the automatic stay.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm