Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Preferential Payments Before Bankruptcy: Why Paying Family Members or Favored Creditors Can Create Serious Problems

BELSKY BANKRUPTCY LEGAL LIBRARY | TRANSFERS AND TRUSTEE AVOIDANCE POWERS

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Paying a Legitimate Debt Before Bankruptcy Can Create an Unexpected Problem

Most people believe that paying their debts is responsible conduct. Ordinarily, it is. But bankruptcy law contains a counterintuitive rule: certain payments made to creditors before filing may be recovered by the Chapter 7 trustee, even when the debt was legitimate, the payment was voluntary, and neither party intended to do anything improper.

These transactions are called preferential transfers.

The purpose of preference law is to prevent a financially distressed debtor from favoring particular creditors shortly before bankruptcy at the expense of creditors who receive nothing.

The rule can produce particularly unpleasant consequences when a debtor repays a parent, sibling, adult child, or friend before filing.

The debtor may believe that the family loan has been responsibly repaid. The recipient may believe the transaction is finished. Yet the trustee may later demand that the recipient return the money to the bankruptcy estate.

Preference law does not require proof that the debtor intended to defraud anyone.

It is therefore essential to distinguish a preferential payment from a fraudulent transfer.

1. What Is a Preferential Transfer?

Section 547(b) of the Bankruptcy Code permits a trustee to avoid certain transfers of the debtor's interest in property made to or for the benefit of a creditor on account of an antecedent debt.

The trustee generally must establish that the transfer:

  • Was made to or for the benefit of a creditor.
  • Was made on account of a debt owed before the transfer.
  • Was made while the debtor was insolvent.
  • Occurred within the applicable preference period.
  • Enabled the creditor to receive more than the creditor would have received in a hypothetical Chapter 7 liquidation without the transfer.

All statutory elements must be satisfied.

Even when those elements are established, the recipient may have defenses under § 547(c).

2. The Ordinary Ninety-Day Preference Period

For most creditors, the relevant preference period is ninety days before the bankruptcy filing.

A payment made within that period may be avoidable if the other statutory requirements are met.

The ninety-day period is not a general prohibition against paying bills before bankruptcy.

Many ordinary payments are not preferential, and statutory defenses may apply.

For example, paying a utility bill for current service presents different issues from making an extraordinary lump-sum payment on an old unsecured loan.

The nature, timing, and circumstances of the payment matter.

3. The One-Year Period for Insiders

The preference period is generally extended to one year when the creditor was an insider at the time of the transfer.

Under § 101(31), insiders of an individual debtor include certain relatives and other persons or entities having specified relationships with the debtor.

The statutory definition is not necessarily exhaustive.

A person who exercises substantial control over the debtor's affairs may present insider issues even without a traditional family relationship.

Example: Repayment to a parent

A debtor borrowed $18,000 from a parent several years earlier.

Eight months before filing Chapter 7, the debtor repays $12,000.

Because the parent is an insider, the payment falls within the one-year preference period.

If the other statutory elements are satisfied and no defense applies, the trustee may seek recovery of the payment.

The fact that the parent genuinely loaned the money does not prevent the transaction from being preferential.

4. Why Family Loans Receive Particular Scrutiny

Debtors frequently feel a moral obligation to repay relatives before seeking bankruptcy relief.

They may be embarrassed about discharging a family loan or concerned about damaging personal relationships.

But preference law does not give family creditors priority because of emotional or moral considerations.

Indeed, the extended insider period reflects Congress's concern that debtors may favor persons with whom they have close relationships.

A debtor who intends to file bankruptcy should disclose significant payments to relatives and obtain advice before making additional payments.

The appropriate response is not to conceal the loan or the repayment.

5. Insolvency and the Presumption of Insolvency

A preferential transfer generally must have been made while the debtor was insolvent.

Under § 101(32), insolvency for most individuals is generally determined through a balance-sheet analysis comparing debts with the fair value of property, subject to statutory exclusions.

A debtor may be unable to pay monthly bills but still possess assets exceeding liabilities.

Conversely, a debtor who continues making minimum payments may nevertheless be insolvent.

Section 547(f) creates a presumption that the debtor was insolvent during the ninety days immediately preceding bankruptcy.

For transfers outside that period, including many insider transfers, the trustee may need to establish insolvency without relying on that presumption.

This distinction can be significant in defending an insider preference action.

6. The Creditor Must Have Received More Than in Chapter 7

A transfer is not preferential merely because it occurred during the lookback period.

The trustee must establish that the payment enabled the creditor to receive more than it would have received under the statutory hypothetical Chapter 7 liquidation analysis.

Payments to fully secured creditors may present different issues from payments to unsecured creditors.

If a creditor would have received full payment from its collateral in a Chapter 7 liquidation, the transfer may not satisfy the preference requirements.

The relevant analysis depends on the creditor's secured status, collateral value, priority, and the estate's likely distribution.

7. Ordinary-Course Payments

Section 547(c)(2) provides a defense for certain transfers made in payment of debts incurred in the ordinary course of business or financial affairs of the debtor and creditor.

The statute permits consideration of whether the transfer was made in the ordinary course of the parties' financial affairs or according to ordinary business terms.

The defense can protect routine payments that do not represent unusual favoritism.

For example, regular monthly payments on an established obligation may present a stronger ordinary-course defense than an extraordinary lump-sum payment made after collection threats.

The defense is fact-specific.

8. Contemporaneous Exchanges for New Value

Section 547(c)(1) protects certain transfers intended by the parties to be contemporaneous exchanges for new value and that are substantially contemporaneous.

For example, a debtor who pays cash for groceries ordinarily receives new value at the time of payment.

That transaction is fundamentally different from paying an old unsecured debt.

The contemporaneous-exchange defense helps prevent preference law from interfering unnecessarily with ordinary exchanges of equivalent value.

9. Subsequent New Value

Section 547(c)(4) provides a defense when, after receiving a potentially preferential transfer, the creditor gives qualifying new value to or for the benefit of the debtor.

The statutory requirements must be satisfied.

This defense is particularly relevant in commercial relationships involving repeated payments and extensions of credit.

For example, a supplier may receive payment on an old invoice and then deliver additional goods on credit.

The later extension of new value may reduce the creditor's preference exposure.

The precise calculation can be complex.

10. Wage Garnishments

Payments obtained through wage garnishment may constitute preferential transfers.

The fact that the creditor collected the money involuntarily does not automatically prevent preference recovery.

However, garnishment presents difficult timing questions.

Under § 547(e), the date of a transfer may depend on when the creditor's interest became effective against relevant parties under applicable law.

Maryland garnishment procedures and federal bankruptcy law must be considered together.

A debtor who has experienced significant wage garnishment shortly before filing may have potential avoidance rights, although recovery is not automatic.

11. Can the Debtor Recover Garnished Wages?

In some circumstances, § 522(h) permits a debtor to avoid certain transfers that the trustee does not pursue.

The debtor must satisfy statutory requirements, including those relating to the nature of the transfer and the availability of an exemption.

The debtor cannot assume that every prepetition garnishment is recoverable.

The amount, timing, exemption rights, and trustee's actions must be evaluated.

A debtor seeking recovery should preserve pay statements, garnishment records, and information concerning when the creditor received the funds.

12. Payments to Credit Card Companies

Large payments to credit card companies shortly before bankruptcy may raise preference questions.

For example, a debtor may pay $8,000 toward one credit card while leaving several other unsecured creditors unpaid.

If the payment satisfies the statutory requirements and no defense applies, the trustee may seek recovery.

However, ordinary minimum payments may qualify for defenses depending on the circumstances.

The trustee's economic incentive to pursue recovery also matters.

Preference analysis should not be reduced to the proposition that every credit card payment within ninety days is recoverable.

13. Payments to Secured Creditors

Payments to secured creditors require separate analysis.

A payment to a fully secured creditor may not satisfy the requirement that the creditor received more than it would have received in a Chapter 7 liquidation.

But payments to undersecured creditors, transfers creating or perfecting liens, and unusual transactions may present different issues.

For example, granting a previously unsecured creditor a lien shortly before bankruptcy may constitute a transfer subject to avoidance.

The existence of collateral does not automatically eliminate preference concerns.

14. Transfers Involving Joint Debts

Payments on joint obligations can raise additional questions.

Suppose a debtor pays a loan owed jointly with a spouse or family member.

The payment may benefit not only the creditor but also a co-obligor whose liability is reduced.

Under appropriate circumstances, the trustee may examine whether the transfer benefited an insider or another party.

The statutory treatment depends on the nature of the obligation, the recipient, the beneficiary, and applicable limitations on recovery.

The analysis can become especially complicated when one spouse files bankruptcy and the other does not.

15. The Small-Transfer Limitations

Section 547(c)(8) provides a limitation for certain transfers involving debtors whose debts are primarily consumer debts.

For primarily consumer-debt cases, § 547(c)(8) bars avoidance where the aggregate value of the qualifying transfer or transfers is less than $600. That $600 figure is not adjusted under § 104. Section 547(c)(9) separately provides an inflation-adjusted nonconsumer threshold of $8,575 for cases filed on or after April 1, 2025, subject to later statutory changes. The aggregation must be evaluated for the relevant creditor or beneficiary, rather than combining unrelated creditors to clear the threshold.

16. Who Must Return the Preferential Payment?

Under § 550, the trustee may recover an avoided transfer from specified transferees or beneficiaries, subject to statutory limitations and defenses.

In a family-loan situation, the trustee may seek recovery from the relative who received the payment.

The debtor's discharge does not necessarily protect the recipient.

This can produce an unexpected result: the debtor receives a bankruptcy discharge, but a family member becomes a defendant in litigation seeking return of money received before filing.

The recipient may have defenses and should not assume the trustee's demand conclusively establishes liability.

17. Does the Debtor Get in Trouble for Making a Preference?

A preferential payment is not necessarily fraudulent or wrongful conduct by the debtor.

Preference law often operates without proof of dishonest intent.

However, concealment of the payment, false statements about it, or other misconduct can create separate problems.

A debtor who accurately discloses a legitimate prepetition payment may face no personal wrongdoing allegation even though the trustee seeks recovery from the recipient.

The distinction between the avoidability of a transfer and misconduct by the debtor is important.

18. Preference Versus Fraudulent Transfer

Preferences and fraudulent transfers are separate legal concepts.

A preference generally concerns payment or security given on account of an existing debt that favors a creditor over others.

A fraudulent transfer may involve actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud creditors or a transfer for less than reasonably equivalent value under specified circumstances.

The federal fraudulent-transfer provisions generally appear in § 548.

A transaction may implicate one doctrine, both doctrines, or neither.

For example, repaying a genuine family loan may be preferential without being fraudulent.

Giving valuable property to a relative for no consideration may raise fraudulent-transfer issues even when no antecedent debt exists.

19. What Happens After the Trustee Recovers a Preference?

Recovered funds generally become available for administration through the bankruptcy estate.

The trustee may use them to pay allowable administrative expenses and distribute remaining proceeds according to the Bankruptcy Code.

The creditor who returned the payment may have a claim in the bankruptcy case, subject to applicable statutory provisions.

Section 502(h) addresses claims arising from recovery of property under specified avoidance provisions.

The recipient's ultimate recovery may therefore be only a fraction of the amount returned.

20. Why Preference Planning Matters Before Filing

Preference issues should be examined before a bankruptcy petition is filed.

The debtor should identify substantial payments made during the preceding ninety days and payments to insiders during the preceding year.

The analysis should also include unusual lien transactions, garnishments, and payments on joint obligations.

A debtor should not assume that waiting until a particular date automatically eliminates every avoidance issue.

Fraudulent-transfer provisions, state-law remedies, and other statutory rules may still apply.

Nor should the debtor attempt to manipulate transactions or conceal payments.

The objective is to understand the legal consequences of legitimate financial activity and select an appropriate filing strategy.

Conclusion

Preference law is one of the more counterintuitive aspects of bankruptcy.

A debtor may pay a legitimate obligation in good faith, only to have the Chapter 7 trustee seek recovery from the recipient.

The risk is particularly significant when family members or other insiders receive substantial payments within one year before filing.

Preferences do not necessarily involve fraud, and creditors may have statutory defenses.

But the consequences can be substantial.

Before filing Chapter 7, significant payments to creditors—especially relatives and other insiders—should be carefully reviewed to determine whether they may be recoverable by the trustee.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes

  • 11 U.S.C. § 547 — Preferential transfers and defenses.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 550 — Recovery of avoided transfers.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 502(h) — Claims arising from recovery of property.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 522(h) — Debtor avoidance of certain transfers.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 548 — Fraudulent transfers.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 101(31)–(32) — Definitions of insider and insolvent.

Selected decisions

  • Barnhill v. Johnson, 503 U.S. 393 (1992) — Addresses when a transfer by check occurs for preference purposes.
  • Union Bank v. Wolas, 502 U.S. 151 (1991) — Addresses the ordinary-course-of-business defense.
  • Begier v. IRS, 496 U.S. 53 (1990) — Addresses the requirement that a preference involve an interest of the debtor in property.
  • Palmer Clay Products Co. v. Brown, 297 U.S. 227 (1936) — Discusses the hypothetical liquidation comparison underlying preference law.
  • In re Barefoot, 952 F.2d 795 (4th Cir. 1991) — Addresses preference avoidance and the transfer of an interest in property.
  • In re ESA Environmental Specialists, Inc., 709 F.3d 388 (4th Cir. 2013) — Discusses the contemporaneous-exchange-for-new-value defense.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm