Bankruptcy Can Protect Essential Utility Services, but the Protection Is Not Unlimited
Individuals filing bankruptcy frequently owe past-due utility bills. Electricity, natural gas, water, and telephone services may be essential to maintaining a household, particularly when the debtor has children, medical needs, or limited income.
A debtor may fear that filing bankruptcy will cause the utility company to disconnect service or refuse to continue providing it.
Federal bankruptcy law provides important protections.
Under 11 U.S.C. § 366, a qualifying utility generally may not alter, refuse, or discontinue service solely because the debtor filed bankruptcy or failed to pay a prepetition utility debt.
But the statute also permits utilities to require adequate assurance of payment for future service.
The protection therefore does not necessarily eliminate deposit requirements or permit the debtor to receive unlimited service without paying postpetition charges.
The debtor should understand both the immediate protections and the conditions for continued service.
1. What Does § 366 Protect?
Section 366(a) generally prohibits a utility from altering, refusing, or discontinuing service to a debtor solely because the debtor commenced a bankruptcy case or failed to pay a prepetition debt for utility service.
The provision is intended to prevent utility companies from using essential service as leverage to collect discharged or dischargeable debts.
For example, an electric company ordinarily cannot disconnect service solely because the debtor included an old electric bill in a Chapter 7 petition.
However, § 366 does not eliminate every lawful basis for discontinuing service.
The debtor must comply with applicable requirements concerning adequate assurance and ongoing payments.
2. Which Services Qualify as Utilities?
Traditional electric, natural gas, and water providers generally fall within the utility framework.
Telephone service may also qualify in appropriate circumstances.
The treatment of internet service, cable television, and other communications services can be more complicated.
Whether a provider qualifies as a utility under § 366 depends on the nature of the service, the provider's obligations, and applicable law.
A debtor should not assume that every subscription service is protected merely because it is useful or important.
3. Prepetition Utility Arrears
A utility bill incurred before bankruptcy generally constitutes a prepetition debt.
An ordinary unsecured utility balance may be dischargeable in Chapter 7.
For example, a debtor may owe $1,800 for prior electric service.
The debtor may include that obligation in the bankruptcy schedules.
The utility generally cannot discontinue qualifying service solely to collect that prepetition debt.
However, the utility may request adequate assurance for future service as permitted by § 366.
4. The Twenty-Day Rule in Chapter 7
Section 366(b) provides that a utility may alter, refuse, or discontinue service if the debtor or trustee does not furnish adequate assurance of payment, in the form of a deposit or other security, within twenty days after the order for relief.
In a voluntary Chapter 7 case, the filing ordinarily constitutes the order for relief.
The twenty-day period is therefore particularly important.
A debtor should not assume that filing bankruptcy guarantees uninterrupted service for the entire case without further action.
The utility may be entitled to require adequate assurance for future service.
5. What Is Adequate Assurance of Payment?
Adequate assurance is intended to protect the utility against the risk of nonpayment for postpetition service.
In an individual Chapter 7 case, it may take the form of a deposit or other appropriate security.
The amount and form may be disputed.
Section 366(b) permits the court, upon request of a party in interest and after notice and hearing, to order a reasonable modification of the amount of a deposit or other security.
The debtor should not assume that the utility may demand any amount without limitation.
Nor should the debtor assume that no deposit can be required.
6. Can the Utility Demand a New Deposit?
Potentially, yes.
A utility may request a deposit or other qualifying security as adequate assurance of payment.
For example, a debtor who owes substantial prepetition arrears may be asked to provide a deposit for continued postpetition service.
The deposit is not necessarily payment of the discharged prepetition balance.
It is intended to secure future service.
The debtor should distinguish between a lawful adequate-assurance demand and an attempt to collect an old debt.
7. Can the Utility Apply an Existing Deposit to Old Bills?
The treatment of an existing utility deposit depends on the agreement, applicable law, and bankruptcy provisions.
The utility may assert setoff or other rights concerning the deposit.
Section 366(c)(4), which applies in Chapter 11 cases, expressly addresses certain applications of prepetition security deposits.
Individual Chapter 7 cases require analysis under the provisions applicable to that chapter.
A debtor should not assume that every existing deposit must be returned or that the utility may automatically apply it without regard to bankruptcy law.
8. What If the Debtor Cannot Afford the Deposit?
A debtor who cannot afford the requested deposit should promptly consult counsel.
Depending on the circumstances, the debtor may seek to negotiate a reasonable amount or request bankruptcy court intervention.
The court may modify the amount of a deposit or other security under § 366(b).
However, the debtor must act before service is lawfully discontinued.
The existence of financial hardship does not automatically eliminate the adequate-assurance requirement.
9. Postpetition Utility Bills Must Be Paid
Bankruptcy generally does not permit the debtor to continue receiving utility service indefinitely without paying for it.
Charges for service provided after filing ordinarily must be addressed.
A utility may possess rights to discontinue service for postpetition nonpayment, subject to § 366 and other applicable law.
The debtor should maintain ongoing payments whenever possible.
The discharge of prepetition arrears does not eliminate the obligation to pay for future service.
10. Can Service Be Restored After Disconnection?
A debtor whose utility service was disconnected before bankruptcy may seek restoration.
Section 366 may provide protection against refusal of service based solely on prepetition debt.
However, restoration can involve adequate-assurance requirements, applicable tariffs, safety conditions, and other lawful obligations.
A debtor should not assume that filing bankruptcy automatically restores service without further action.
Prompt communication with the provider and bankruptcy counsel is important.
11. What If the Utility Refuses Service Because of a Discharged Debt?
A utility that refuses qualifying service solely because of a discharged prepetition debt may violate § 366 or the discharge injunction, depending on the circumstances.
The debtor may seek relief in bankruptcy court.
However, the utility may have legitimate grounds for requiring adequate assurance or addressing postpetition defaults.
The legal basis for the refusal must be identified.
A debtor should preserve notices, account statements, and communications with the provider.
12. Chapter 13 Utility Protection
Chapter 13 also provides protections under § 366.
The debtor may address prepetition utility arrears through the repayment plan as permitted by the Bankruptcy Code.
But ongoing service must still be maintained.
The debtor should not assume that confirmation of a Chapter 13 plan eliminates the obligation to pay current utility charges.
Adequate-assurance issues may also arise.
13. Chapter 11 Has Different Rules
Section 366(c) contains special adequate-assurance provisions applicable to Chapter 11 cases.
These provisions are more detailed and impose different requirements concerning the form and timing of adequate assurance.
For example, § 366(c)(2) addresses the thirty-day period applicable in Chapter 11.
A debtor should not apply the Chapter 11 thirty-day framework automatically to an individual Chapter 7 case.
The relevant chapter matters.
14. Electric and Gas Service in Maryland
Maryland electric and gas utilities operate under state regulatory requirements, including provisions administered by the Maryland Public Service Commission.
State law and utility tariffs may govern deposits, disconnection notices, payment arrangements, medical protections, and restoration procedures.
Federal bankruptcy law operates alongside these requirements.
A debtor may have rights under Maryland utility regulations independent of bankruptcy.
Those rights should be examined when service is threatened.
15. Medical Necessity and Utility Disconnection
A household member may require electricity for medical equipment or other health-related needs.
Maryland utility regulations may provide special procedures or protections in qualifying medical circumstances.
These protections are separate from § 366.
The debtor should notify the utility promptly and provide required documentation.
Bankruptcy may provide additional protection, but medical-necessity procedures should not be ignored.
16. Water and Sewer Service
Water and sewer services may be provided by municipal authorities, counties, or other entities.
The legal treatment may depend on the provider and the nature of the charges.
Some water and sewer obligations may be associated with liens or assessments affecting real property.
A debtor should not assume that every unpaid water charge is an ordinary unsecured utility debt.
The existence of a property lien may materially affect the bankruptcy analysis.
17. Telephone and Internet Service
Traditional telephone service may qualify for § 366 protection in appropriate circumstances.
Internet service and bundled telecommunications arrangements require separate consideration.
A provider's classification, regulatory obligations, and service terms may affect whether it is treated as a utility.
A debtor should not assume that broadband service is automatically protected to the same extent as electric service.
The applicable case law should be examined.
18. Utility Bills Owed by a Former Spouse or Roommate
Utility accounts may be held in one person's name even though several household members used the service.
The utility's contractual rights generally depend on the account agreement and applicable law.
A debtor's discharge does not automatically eliminate another person's separate liability.
Conversely, a utility may not necessarily impose another person's discharged debt on the debtor.
The account ownership and relevant contractual obligations should be identified.
19. Moving After Bankruptcy
A debtor may seek utility service at a new address after filing or discharge.
Section 366 may prohibit a qualifying utility from refusing service solely because of the bankruptcy or unpaid prepetition debt.
However, the utility may require lawful adequate assurance or impose other conditions permitted by law.
The debtor should not assume that a discharged utility balance must be paid merely to obtain service at a new residence.
The reason for any refusal should be examined.
20. What Should a Debtor Do Before Filing?
A debtor with substantial utility arrears should identify each provider, account balance, disconnection notice, and deposit requirement.
Counsel should determine whether the provider qualifies under § 366 and whether additional Maryland protections apply.
The debtor should also evaluate the ability to pay ongoing charges and any reasonable adequate-assurance deposit.
Where disconnection is imminent, timing may be critical.
The objective is to preserve essential service while addressing prepetition obligations lawfully.
Conclusion
Section 366 provides important protection against utility disconnection or refusal of service based solely on bankruptcy or unpaid prepetition utility debt.
But the protection is conditional.
In Chapter 7, a utility may require adequate assurance of payment within the statutory twenty-day period.
The debtor generally must continue paying for postpetition service.
Maryland utility regulations may provide additional protections concerning deposits, disconnection procedures, and medical needs.
A debtor facing utility disconnection should evaluate both bankruptcy protections and Maryland utility law before assuming that service can be terminated—or that filing bankruptcy guarantees uninterrupted service.
Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities
Federal statutes
11 U.S.C. § 366 — Utility service and adequate assurance.
11 U.S.C. § 362 — Automatic stay.
11 U.S.C. § 524 — Discharge injunction.
11 U.S.C. § 553 — Setoff.
Maryland law and regulations
Maryland Public Utilities Article — Regulation of public utilities.
Maryland Public Service Commission — Utility regulations and consumer protections.
COMAR Title 20 — Maryland utility regulations, including applicable service termination and deposit requirements.
Selected decisions
In re Begley, 760 F.2d 46 (3d Cir. 1985) — Addresses utility service and adequate assurance under § 366.
In re Hanratty, 907 F.2d 1418 (3d Cir. 1990) — Addresses utility deposits and bankruptcy.
In re Jones, 369 B.R. 745 (1st Cir. BAP 2007) — Discusses utility service protections and adequate assurance.
In re Moorefield, 218 B.R. 795 (Bankr. M.D.N.C. 1997) — Addresses utility service and bankruptcy issues.
Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions
Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.