Bankruptcy May Temporarily Stop an Eviction, but It Does Not Guarantee the Right to Remain
A tenant facing eviction may consider bankruptcy as a means of stopping a landlord from obtaining possession of the property.
Filing Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 ordinarily triggers the automatic stay under 11 U.S.C. § 362, which prohibits many collection and enforcement activities.
But eviction proceedings receive special treatment under federal bankruptcy law.
A tenant who files before a judgment for possession is entered may have substantially different rights from a tenant who files after the landlord obtains judgment.
Even when bankruptcy temporarily stops an eviction, the tenant generally must address ongoing rent obligations.
The landlord may seek relief from the automatic stay, and certain statutory exceptions permit eviction proceedings to continue notwithstanding bankruptcy.
The timing of the filing, status of the Maryland eviction case, and nature of the landlord's claim are therefore critical.
1. How Residential Evictions Work in Maryland
Maryland law provides several procedures through which a landlord may seek possession of residential property.
Common proceedings include failure-to-pay-rent actions, tenant-holding-over cases, and breach-of-lease actions.
These proceedings arise under different provisions of the Maryland Real Property Article.
The landlord ordinarily must obtain the required judgment and follow applicable procedures before recovering possession through lawful eviction.
The precise notice, cure, and enforcement requirements depend on the type of case and applicable law.
A bankruptcy filing must be evaluated against the status of the particular eviction proceeding.
2. The Automatic Stay
Under § 362(a), filing bankruptcy ordinarily stays many actions to recover prepetition claims or obtain possession of estate property.
A residential lease may constitute a property interest relevant to the bankruptcy estate.
The automatic stay may therefore temporarily prevent a landlord from continuing an eviction proceeding.
However, the stay is subject to exceptions.
The landlord may also request relief under § 362(d).
A tenant should not assume that filing bankruptcy permanently prevents eviction.
3. Filing Before the Landlord Obtains Judgment for Possession
When the tenant files bankruptcy before a judgment for possession has been entered, the automatic stay may prevent the landlord from continuing the eviction proceeding without relief from the bankruptcy court.
The tenant's leasehold interest and the nature of the landlord's claim must be examined.
The landlord may seek stay relief.
The debtor's ability to remain in possession may depend on payment of ongoing rent and compliance with applicable lease obligations.
A bankruptcy filing ordinarily does not provide a permanent right to occupy property without paying rent.
4. Filing After Judgment for Possession
Section 362(b)(22) creates an important exception to the automatic stay.
The exception generally applies to continuation of certain eviction, unlawful detainer, or similar proceedings involving residential property when the landlord obtained a judgment for possession before the bankruptcy petition.
The provision is subject to the debtor's rights under § 362(l).
A tenant who files after judgment therefore may receive substantially less protection than one who files earlier.
The tenant should not assume that bankruptcy automatically stops execution of an existing possession judgment.
5. The Thirty-Day Certification Procedure
Section 362(l) provides a limited procedure through which certain residential tenants may obtain temporary protection notwithstanding a prepetition judgment for possession.
The debtor generally must file a certification concerning applicable nonbankruptcy law and deposit with the bankruptcy court the rent that would become due during the thirty-day period after filing.
The certification must satisfy the statutory requirements.
The debtor must establish that applicable nonbankruptcy law permits the debtor to cure the monetary default giving rise to the judgment for possession.
The procedure does not apply automatically to every eviction.
The initial § 362(l)(1) certification is filed with the petition and served on the landlord; it addresses circumstances in which nonbankruptcy law permits cure of the entire monetary default after the possession judgment. The required deposit covers rent becoming due during the 30 days after filing. Within that period, the debtor must cure the entire monetary default and file and serve the further certification to invoke § 362(l)(2). A landlord’s objection prompts the statutory expedited hearing, rather than making either certification conclusive.
6. Curing the Default Within Thirty Days
Under § 362(l), a qualifying debtor may obtain additional protection by curing the monetary default within the statutory period and filing the required certification.
The landlord may object.
The bankruptcy court may determine whether the statutory requirements have been satisfied.
The debtor should not assume that merely promising to pay rent is sufficient.
The required deposit, certifications, cure, and procedural deadlines must be satisfied.
7. Maryland's Right of Redemption
Maryland law permits certain residential tenants facing failure-to-pay-rent eviction to redeem possession by paying the legally required amount before execution of the eviction, subject to statutory restrictions.
The right of redemption is governed principally by Maryland Real Property Article § 8-401.
However, redemption rights may be restricted in specified circumstances, including certain repeated judgments for possession.
The precise amount required and availability of redemption must be determined under current Maryland law.
These state-law rights are important when evaluating whether the debtor qualifies for the federal certification procedure under § 362(l).
8. What If the Tenant Has Lost the Right of Redemption?
A tenant who no longer possesses a right to cure the monetary default under applicable Maryland law may be unable to satisfy the requirements of § 362(l).
In that circumstance, the bankruptcy filing may not prevent continuation of the eviction under § 362(b)(22).
The tenant's rights depend on the type of judgment, procedural history, and applicable law.
The debtor should not assume that every failure-to-pay-rent judgment can be cured after bankruptcy is filed.
9. Evictions Based on Endangerment or Illegal Drug Use
Section 362(b)(23) provides an exception concerning certain eviction proceedings involving endangerment of property or illegal use of controlled substances on the property.
The statute requires specified certifications and procedures.
Section 362(m) provides mechanisms through which the debtor may contest the landlord's certification.
Under § 362(m), the endangerment or illegal-drug-use exception ordinarily becomes effective 15 days after the landlord files and serves the prescribed certification. A debtor wishing to contest it must file and serve an objection within that 15-day period; the statute then requires an expedited hearing. This is a separate procedure from the monetary-default certifications in subsection (l).
These provisions differ from the ordinary nonpayment-of-rent exception.
A debtor should not assume that the thirty-day monetary cure procedure applies to every eviction.
10. What Happens to Past-Due Rent?
Rent owed before bankruptcy generally constitutes a prepetition claim.
Depending on the circumstances, the debt may be dischargeable in Chapter 7.
However, discharge of personal liability for unpaid rent does not necessarily restore a terminated lease or eliminate the landlord's right to possession.
The landlord's claim for money and the landlord's right to recover the property are distinct.
A tenant may discharge substantial rent arrears but still be required to vacate.
11. Postpetition Rent Must Be Addressed
Bankruptcy ordinarily does not give the debtor a right to occupy leased property indefinitely without paying rent.
Rent obligations arising after filing may receive different treatment from prepetition arrears.
The debtor should determine whether the lease remains in effect, whether it has been assumed or rejected, and what obligations continue.
A landlord may seek relief from the stay when postpetition rent is not paid.
The debtor should not rely on bankruptcy as a substitute for an affordable housing arrangement.
12. Executory Contracts and Residential Leases
Section 365 governs executory contracts and unexpired leases.
A residential lease may be subject to assumption or rejection under the applicable provisions.
In Chapter 7, the trustee generally possesses authority concerning estate contracts and leases.
Special statutory provisions may affect leases of residential real property.
The debtor's rights and obligations depend on the lease's status and applicable law.
A lease that was validly terminated before bankruptcy may present different issues from an unexpired lease.
13. Can the Debtor Assume the Lease?
Assumption generally requires satisfaction of applicable statutory requirements.
Under § 365(b), certain defaults must be cured or adequately addressed, and adequate assurance of future performance may be required.
The particular rules depend on the lease and circumstances.
A debtor should not assume that filing bankruptcy automatically reinstates a terminated lease.
The legal status of the lease under Maryland law must be established.
14. What If the Lease Was Terminated Before Filing?
A lease validly terminated before bankruptcy may leave the debtor with limited rights.
Bankruptcy generally does not create property interests that did not exist under applicable nonbankruptcy law.
However, the tenant may retain certain statutory or equitable rights concerning possession or cure.
The precise effect depends on the type of termination and Maryland law.
The debtor should not assume that every notice of termination has the same legal effect as a judgment for possession.
15. What If the Landlord Files a Motion for Relief From Stay?
A landlord may request relief from the automatic stay under § 362(d).
The landlord may argue that the debtor is not paying ongoing rent, lacks a viable right to possession, or that other cause exists.
The debtor may oppose the motion.
The bankruptcy court determines whether relief is appropriate.
Even when the stay initially applies, the court may permit the landlord to continue eviction proceedings.
16. Chapter 7 Versus Chapter 13
Chapter 7 may discharge qualifying prepetition rent obligations relatively quickly.
But it ordinarily does not provide a long-term repayment mechanism designed to preserve a residential lease.
Chapter 13 may permit a debtor to address certain obligations through a repayment plan.
However, the debtor must satisfy the applicable requirements concerning lease assumption, cure, and ongoing performance.
Chapter 13 does not automatically guarantee continued occupancy.
The appropriate chapter depends on the lease status, arrears, income, and available cure rights.
17. Repeat Bankruptcy Filings
Repeat filings can limit automatic-stay protection.
Under § 362(c)(3), certain debtors with one qualifying dismissed case during the preceding year may face termination of the stay after thirty days.
Under § 362(c)(4), the stay generally does not arise when two or more qualifying cases were pending and dismissed during the preceding year.
The debtor may seek relief under the statutory procedures.
A tenant should not assume that repeatedly filing bankruptcy will stop each scheduled eviction.
18. What If the Sheriff Is Scheduled to Execute the Eviction?
The timing is critical.
A tenant who files before judgment may have different rights from one who files after judgment.
When § 362(b)(22) applies, the landlord may be able to proceed despite bankruptcy unless the debtor satisfies § 362(l).
The tenant should determine whether a judgment for possession exists, whether redemption remains available, and whether the required federal procedures can be completed.
A last-minute filing without satisfying the statutory requirements may fail to stop the eviction.
19. Can the Landlord Collect a Discharged Rent Debt?
A Chapter 7 discharge generally prohibits collection of discharged personal liabilities.
If prepetition rent was discharged, the landlord ordinarily cannot pursue prohibited collection of that personal obligation.
However, the discharge does not necessarily eliminate the landlord's possessory rights.
Nor does it necessarily discharge postpetition obligations.
The debtor should distinguish collection of money from enforcement of the right to possession.
20. Security Deposits
A residential security deposit may be subject to rights and obligations under Maryland law.
The landlord may assert claims for unpaid rent, damage, or other lawful charges.
The debtor may possess an interest in any refundable balance.
The bankruptcy treatment depends on the lease, timing, applicable law, and whether the deposit is property of the estate.
The debtor should disclose qualifying rights to refundable deposits.
21. Why Eviction Cases Require Immediate Review
A tenant facing eviction should obtain the relevant court documents before deciding whether bankruptcy will help.
Important documents include the lease, notices, complaint, judgment for possession, rent ledger, and scheduled eviction information.
The attorney should determine the type of eviction proceeding and whether any statutory right to cure remains.
The debtor's ability to pay ongoing rent is also important.
Bankruptcy may provide temporary relief, but a sustainable housing solution requires more than delaying the eviction.
Conclusion
Bankruptcy may temporarily stop an eviction, but the protection depends on the timing and nature of the landlord's proceedings.
A tenant who files before judgment for possession may receive broader automatic-stay protection than one who files afterward.
Section 362(b)(22) permits continuation of certain residential evictions following prepetition judgments for possession, subject to the limited protections of § 362(l).
Maryland's right-of-redemption provisions can be important in determining whether a tenant may cure the default.
A tenant facing eviction should not assume that filing bankruptcy automatically stops removal from the property. The judgment, cure rights, and federal certification requirements must be examined before filing.
Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities
Federal statutes and rules
11 U.S.C. § 362(b)(22)–(23) — Exceptions to the automatic stay involving certain residential evictions.
11 U.S.C. § 362(l)–(m) — Tenant certifications, deposits, and objections.
11 U.S.C. § 365 — Executory contracts and unexpired leases.
11 U.S.C. § 523 — Exceptions to discharge.
11 U.S.C. § 524 — Discharge injunction.
Maryland law
Maryland Real Property § 8-401 — Failure-to-pay-rent proceedings and redemption.
Maryland Real Property § 8-402 — Tenant holding over.
Maryland Real Property § 8-402.1 — Breach-of-lease proceedings.
Selected decisions
In re Stoltz, 315 F.3d 80 (2d Cir. 2002) — Addresses bankruptcy protections concerning certain residential lease interests under the pre-2005 statutory framework.
In re DiCamillo, 206 B.R. 64 (Bankr. D.N.J. 1997) — Addresses residential lease termination and bankruptcy.
In re Williams, 144 F.3d 544 (7th Cir. 1998) — Discusses bankruptcy and possessory interests.
In re Smith, 105 B.R. 50 (Bankr. C.D. Cal. 1989) — Addresses landlord-tenant issues under bankruptcy law.
In re Ross, 198 B.R. 5 (Bankr. E.D. Pa. 1996) — Discusses lease termination and bankruptcy estate interests.
Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions
Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.