Maryland Bankruptcy Legal Library

Bankruptcy and Debt Settlement Companies: Why Negotiated Settlements Sometimes Cost More Than Chapter 7

Belsky Bankruptcy Legal Library | Alternatives to Bankruptcy and Consumer Debt Relief

By , Attorney at Law

On This Page — View Topics

Debt Settlement May Reduce What You Owe, but It Can Also Make a Financial Crisis Worse

Advertisements for debt settlement services frequently promise substantial reductions in credit card balances and other unsecured obligations.

A consumer may be told that creditors will accept a fraction of the amount owed if the consumer stops making payments and deposits money into a designated settlement account.

Sometimes negotiated settlements provide meaningful relief.

But the process can involve substantial risks.

Creditors are not required to settle. Interest and fees may continue accumulating. Collection lawsuits may be filed while the consumer saves money for proposed settlements.

A settlement company may also charge fees that materially reduce the consumer's savings.

In some circumstances, forgiven debt can create taxable income.

For a consumer who qualifies for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the financial comparison may strongly favor bankruptcy.

However, debt settlement can be appropriate when the consumer has limited debt, substantial nonexempt assets, or another reason to avoid bankruptcy.

The decision should be based on the actual cost, risks, and likely outcome of each alternative.

1. What Is Debt Settlement?

Debt settlement generally involves negotiating with a creditor to accept less than the full amount owed in satisfaction of an obligation.

For example, a creditor owed $20,000 may agree to accept $9,000 as full settlement.

The creditor's willingness to settle depends on the account, collection history, debtor's circumstances, and other considerations.

A settlement may be negotiated directly by the consumer, through an attorney, or through a debt settlement company.

The legal consequences depend on the agreement's terms.

2. How Debt Settlement Companies Operate

Some debt settlement companies instruct consumers to stop paying unsecured creditors and instead accumulate funds in a dedicated account.

The company then attempts to negotiate reduced balances.

The strategy assumes creditors eventually will prefer accepting partial payment rather than continuing collection.

However, creditors are not required to participate.

A creditor may sue before sufficient settlement funds accumulate.

The consumer may therefore face judgments, garnishments, or other collection consequences while waiting.

3. Settlement Companies Cannot Guarantee Results

A debt settlement company cannot force a creditor to accept less than the amount legally owed.

The company may advertise average settlement percentages, but those figures may not predict the consumer's outcome.

Some creditors may refuse to negotiate.

Others may demand larger payments than anticipated.

The consumer should be cautious about representations suggesting that all debts will be settled for a guaranteed percentage.

The actual agreements and creditor responses control.

4. Interest and Fees May Continue Accumulating

When a consumer stops paying credit cards, contractual interest, late fees, and other lawful charges may continue accumulating.

A $15,000 balance may increase substantially before settlement occurs.

Even if the creditor eventually accepts a reduced payment, the savings should be measured against the actual balance and total cost.

The consumer should not compare only the original principal with the negotiated payment.

The settlement company's fees must also be considered.

5. Debt Settlement Fees

Debt settlement companies may charge fees based on the amount of debt enrolled or the savings achieved.

Federal law restricts certain advance fees charged by covered debt relief services.

The Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 C.F.R. Part 310, contains requirements governing qualifying debt relief services.

The application depends on the provider and manner in which services are marketed.

The consumer should obtain a complete written explanation of fees and when they become payable.

6. The Advance-Fee Rule

Under the Telemarketing Sales Rule, covered debt relief services generally may not collect fees before satisfying specified conditions, including obtaining a settlement or other qualifying alteration of the debt and the consumer making at least one payment under the arrangement.

The rule also addresses dedicated accounts and related consumer protections.

The consumer should not assume that every company demanding an upfront payment is operating lawfully.

However, the application of the rule depends on the service and statutory definitions.

7. Maryland Regulation of Debt Settlement Services

Maryland’s Debt Settlement Services Act is in Financial Institutions Title 12, Subtitle 10 and generally uses a provider-registration framework, subject to its definitions and exemptions. Debt management services are separately regulated under Title 12, Subtitle 9 and generally require a license. Verify the provider’s actual service and required Maryland registration or license rather than treating the two authorizations as interchangeable.

The existence of a website or national advertising campaign does not establish compliance with Maryland law.

The provider's actual services and legal status matter.

8. Creditors May Sue During Settlement Negotiations

Debt settlement negotiations ordinarily do not automatically stop collection lawsuits.

A creditor may file suit while the consumer is accumulating settlement funds.

If the consumer fails to respond, the creditor may obtain a default judgment.

The creditor may then pursue lawful collection remedies.

The consumer should not assume that enrolling in a settlement program prevents litigation.

9. Wage Garnishment

A judgment creditor may seek wage garnishment under Maryland law.

The consumer may have statutory exemption rights.

However, debt settlement enrollment generally does not create an automatic stay comparable to bankruptcy.

A consumer whose wages are being garnished may find it difficult to accumulate the funds needed for settlement.

Chapter 7 may provide more immediate protection when the automatic stay applies.

10. Bank Account Garnishment

A creditor may also seek attachment of funds in a bank account after obtaining the necessary legal authority.

The consumer may have exemption rights.

But a private debt settlement arrangement generally does not prevent lawful collection proceedings.

A consumer should not assume that money saved for settlement is immune from creditor process.

11. Credit Reporting Consequences

Debt settlement can negatively affect credit reports.

Accounts may become delinquent, charged off, or reported as settled for less than the full balance.

The reporting consequences depend on the creditor and applicable law.

Bankruptcy also affects credit reporting, but it provides a different legal outcome.

A consumer should compare the likely consequences rather than assuming that debt settlement necessarily preserves credit better than Chapter 7.

12. Forgiven Debt May Be Taxable

Under Internal Revenue Code § 61(a)(11), cancellation of indebtedness generally may constitute gross income unless an exclusion or exception applies.

For example, a creditor may forgive $25,000 of a credit card balance.

The consumer may receive a Form 1099-C.

The forgiven amount may create taxable income.

However, the Internal Revenue Code provides exclusions, including certain bankruptcy and insolvency exclusions under § 108.

The consumer should not assume that every settlement creates taxable income or that every forgiven amount is automatically tax-free.

13. The Insolvency Exclusion

Section 108(a)(1)(B) excludes qualifying cancellation-of-debt income to the extent the taxpayer was insolvent immediately before the discharge.

Insolvency generally involves liabilities exceeding the fair market value of assets under the statutory definition.

The exclusion requires an appropriate calculation.

A consumer should not assume that having substantial credit card debt automatically establishes insolvency.

Assets and liabilities must be evaluated.

14. Bankruptcy and Cancellation-of-Debt Income

Section 108(a)(1)(A) generally excludes qualifying discharge-of-indebtedness income when the discharge occurs in a Title 11 bankruptcy case and the taxpayer is under the court's jurisdiction.

This can provide an important tax distinction between ordinary negotiated settlements and debts discharged through bankruptcy.

However, tax attributes may be reduced under § 108(b).

The debtor should consider the complete tax consequences.

15. Example: Settlement Versus Chapter 7

Assume a consumer owes $80,000 in unsecured credit card debt.

A settlement company proposes negotiating settlements averaging 45% of the enrolled balances.

If successful, the consumer may need approximately $36,000 to fund settlements, plus applicable fees.

Interest and charges may increase the balances before settlement.

The consumer may also face potential cancellation-of-debt tax consequences.

If the consumer qualifies for Chapter 7 and has fully protected assets, the same debts may be discharged without funding a multiyear settlement program.

The comparison depends on eligibility, assets, and the actual debts involved.

16. When Debt Settlement May Be Preferable

Debt settlement may be appropriate when the consumer has a manageable number of obligations and sufficient funds to resolve them.

For example, a consumer may owe $18,000 to one creditor and have access to a reasonable lump-sum settlement.

The consumer may prefer negotiation over bankruptcy.

Debt settlement may also be considered when bankruptcy would expose valuable nonexempt property to liquidation.

The decision should reflect the consumer's actual circumstances.

17. Settling One Debt Does Not Resolve Others

A consumer may settle one credit card account while remaining liable for several others.

The successful settlement does not automatically protect the consumer from collection by other creditors.

A settlement program may therefore produce uneven results.

The consumer should evaluate whether the proposed settlements provide a comprehensive solution.

Chapter 7 generally addresses qualifying unsecured debts collectively through the bankruptcy process.

18. Preference Risks Before Bankruptcy

A consumer may make substantial payments to selected creditors shortly before filing bankruptcy.

Under § 547, certain transfers may be avoidable as preferences.

Payments to ordinary creditors within ninety days before filing may receive scrutiny.

Payments to insiders may be examined over a longer statutory period.

The applicable monetary threshold and other requirements matter.

A debtor should disclose significant settlement payments made before bankruptcy.

19. Settlements With Family Members

A debtor may repay relatives before filing bankruptcy because of personal obligations or family pressure.

Such payments may create preference exposure.

The trustee may seek recovery from the recipient when the statutory requirements are satisfied.

The debtor should not assume that repayment of a genuine family loan is automatically protected.

The timing and relationship matter.

20. Settlement Agreements Must Be Clear

A negotiated settlement should establish the amount to be paid, payment deadline, and legal effect of payment.

The agreement should address whether the creditor releases the remaining balance and whether any judgment or lien will be satisfied.

A debtor should not rely solely on an oral promise.

The creditor's authority to settle should also be established.

A settlement that fails to resolve a judgment lien may leave significant problems.

21. What If the Consumer Defaults on the Settlement?

Some settlements require installment payments.

The agreement may provide consequences if the consumer misses a payment.

The creditor may claim that the original balance or another amount becomes due.

The enforceability depends on the agreement and applicable law.

A consumer should not assume that a partial payment permanently resolves the debt unless the settlement terms provide that result.

22. Debt Management Plans Are Different

A debt management plan generally involves repayment of debts under negotiated interest rates or payment arrangements.

It does not necessarily involve forgiveness of principal.

Nonprofit credit counseling agencies may offer such plans.

The consumer should distinguish debt management from debt settlement.

The cost, credit consequences, and legal effects differ.

23. Negotiating Directly With Creditors

A consumer may negotiate directly with creditors without hiring a debt settlement company.

Some creditors may consider hardship arrangements, reduced interest, payment plans, or lump-sum settlements.

The consumer should obtain written confirmation of any agreement.

Direct negotiation may avoid settlement company fees.

However, the consumer must still consider tax consequences, credit reporting, and the risk of collection by other creditors.

24. When Bankruptcy Provides a More Complete Solution

Chapter 7 may be particularly attractive when the consumer has substantial unsecured debt, limited nonexempt property, and no realistic ability to fund settlements.

The automatic stay generally provides immediate protection against many collection activities.

The discharge ordinarily eliminates qualifying personal liabilities.

However, Chapter 7 does not eliminate every debt or lien.

The debtor's assets and eligibility must be evaluated.

25. Why the Comparison Should Be Made Before Enrolling

A consumer should compare debt settlement and bankruptcy before committing substantial money to a settlement program.

The analysis should include the amount owed, expected settlement payments, company fees, taxes, collection risks, assets, income, and available bankruptcy exemptions.

A consumer who spends years accumulating settlement funds may discover that Chapter 7 could have provided a faster and less expensive resolution.

Conversely, a consumer with limited debt and substantial nonexempt property may find negotiation preferable.

Conclusion

Debt settlement can provide meaningful relief in appropriate circumstances, but it is not necessarily cheaper or safer than bankruptcy.

Creditors are not required to settle. Interest and fees may accumulate. Collection lawsuits and garnishments may continue.

Forgiven debt may also create taxable income.

Chapter 7 offers a different form of relief by discharging qualifying debts through a federal court proceeding.

Before paying a debt settlement company, a consumer should determine whether Chapter 7 or another bankruptcy option would provide a more complete and economical solution.

Related Bankruptcy Cases and Authorities

Federal statutes and regulations

  • 11 U.S.C. § 362 — Automatic stay.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 523 — Exceptions to discharge.
  • 11 U.S.C. § 547 — Preferential transfers.
  • 26 U.S.C. § 61(a)(11) — Cancellation-of-debt income.
  • 26 U.S.C. § 108 — Exclusions from cancellation-of-debt income.
  • 16 C.F.R. Part 310 — Telemarketing Sales Rule.

Maryland law

  • Maryland Financial Consumer Protection laws — Applicable regulation of debt settlement and management services.
  • Maryland Office of Financial Regulation — Licensing and consumer information.

Selected decisions

  • United States v. Kirby Lumber Co., 284 U.S. 1 (1931) — Addresses income arising from discharge of indebtedness.
  • Commissioner v. Tufts, 461 U.S. 300 (1983) — Addresses tax consequences of liabilities and property dispositions.
  • Grogan v. Garner, 498 U.S. 279 (1991) — Addresses dischargeability litigation standards.
  • Midland Funding, LLC v. Johnson, 581 U.S. 224 (2017) — Addresses time-barred claims in bankruptcy.
  • In re Bane, 720 F.3d 465 (4th Cir. 2013) — Addresses fraudulent transfers and discharge consequences.

Discuss Your Bankruptcy Questions

Consultations with Alan J. Belsky are by Zoom or telephone, by appointment. Call (410) 234-0100 or contact the firm. Identify any approaching sale, repossession, garnishment or court deadline.

← Return to the Legal Library

Call Alan BelskyContact the Firm